Theory of Anderson transition in three-dimensional chiral symmetry classes: Connection to type-II superconductors
Pengwei Zhao, Ryuichi Shindou · 2025
Read Theory of Anderson transition in three-dimensional chiral symmetry classes: Connection to type-II superconductors by Pengwei Zhao, Ryuichi Shindou (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-21050.txt.
Introduction
Pengwei Zhao and Ryuichi Shindou build a theory of the Anderson transition in three-dimensional materials with a special symmetry, in a research paper from 2025. At this transition, electrons switch between roaming freely and staying trapped. In two dimensions, swirling vortex defects drive the change.
In three dimensions, the key defects are loops of vortex lines. The authors rewrite their model in a dual form and build a mean-field theory of the transition. To their surprise, the dual form matches the magnetostatics of type-II superconductors. The material's two-step path from metal to insulator mirrors a superconductor's path under a magnetic field. A weak band topology also plays a role, they show.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Pengwei Zhao, Ryuichi Shindou |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 89 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-21050
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Theory of Anderson transition in three-dimensional chiral symmetry classes: Connection to type-II superconductors Pengwei Zhao, Ryuichi Shindou Abstract Phase transitions governed by topological defects constitute a cornerstone of modern physics. Two-dimensional (2D) Anderson transitions in chiral symmetry classes are driven by the proliferation of vortex-antivortex pairs—a mechanism analogous to the Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless (BKT) transition in the 2D XY model. In this work, we extend this paradigm to three-dimensional (3D) chiral symmetry classes, where vortex loops emerge as the key topological defects governing the Anderson transition. By deriving the dual representation of the 3D nonlinear sigma model for the chiral unitary class, we develop a mean-field theory of its Anderson transition and elucidate the role of 1D weak band topology in the Anderson transition. Strikingly, our dual representation of the 3D NLSM in the chiral symmetry class uncovers its connection to the magnetostatics of 3D type-II superconductors. The metal-to-quasi-localized and quasi-localized-to-insulating transitions in 3D chiral symmetry class share a unified theoretical framework with the normal-to-mixed and mixed-to-superconducting transitions in 3D type-II superconductors under an external magnetic field, respectively. I Introduction Topological defects are universal entities in physical systems with symmetries mermin1979 ; chaikin_lubensky1995 . Characterized by quantized charges, topological defects exhibit remarkable stability against local perturbations. Well-known examples include domain walls in Ising magnets kittel1946 ; sethna2006 , vortices in superconductors and superfluids onsager1949 ; feynman1955 ; abrikosov1957 ; tinkham1996 ; donnelly1991 , and skyrmions in Heisenberg magnets skyrme1961 ; skyrme1962 ; bogdanov1989 ; nagaosa2013 ; fert2017 . Thermodynamic properties of physical systems are profoundly influenced by topological defects, whose spatial proliferation introduces disorder in an ordered phase, leading to dramatic changes in the macroscopic properties of the systems. This mechanism drives fundamental phase transitions, such as Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless (BKT) transition berezinskii71 ; berezinskii72 ; kosterlitz1973 ; kosterlitz1974 , melting transitions of 2D solids nelson1979 ; young1979 ; halperin1978 , and the superfluid transition onsager1949 ; feynman1955 ; nelson1977 ; dasgupta1981 ; williams1987 ; shenoy1989 , underscoring the pivotal role of topological defects in shaping collective phenomena kibble1976 ; zurek1985 ; zurek1996 . In disordered electron systems—such as an electron gas with random impurities—charge carriers experience repeated scattering events that reduce their mean-free time. In the weak disorder regime, electrons retain sufficient coherence to propagate diffusively, resulting in a metallic phase with finite conductivity. When disorder strength exceeds a critical disorder strength, the random potentials cause spatial localization of electronic states anderson1958 ; thouless1974 ; abrahams1979 . This metal-insulator transition, known as the Anderson transition, has been experimentally studied in diverse wave systems, which include not only electron waves in solid-state materials rosenbaum1980 ; tsui1982 but also electromagnetic and atomic waves in optical, photonic, and cold-atom systems wang2011 ; hu2008 ; roati2008 ; skipetrov2016 . Decades of theoretical and numerical studies wegner1976 ; wegner1979 ; efetov1980 ; hikami1980 ; hikami1981 ; efetov1983 ; mackinnon1981 ; mackinnon1983 ; altlandNonstandardSymmetryClasses1997 ; slevin1999 ; eversAndersonTransitions2008 ; slevinCriticalExponentAnderson2014 have demonstrated that the Anderson transitions exhibit universal scaling behaviors characterized by critical exponents, which define distinct universality classes. The universality classes are classified according to fundamental Hamiltonian symmetries—time-reversal (TRS), particle-hole (PHS), and chiral (CS) symmetries—which constitute the celebrated Altland-Zirnbauer ten-fold way altlandNonstandardSymmetryClasses1997 . The classification scheme has since been extended to non-Hermitian matrices kawabataSymmetryTopologyNonHermitian2019a ; bernard2002 ; zhou2019 and their eigenstates’ localization phenomena kawabata2021 ; luoUnifyingAndersonTransitions2022 ; chen2025 , revealing its broad applicability in the study of non-Hermitian disordered systems hatano1996 ; cao1999 ; wersma2008 ; wersma2013 ; yamilov2014 ; basiri2014 ; xu2016 ; yusipov2017 ; hamazaki2019 ; tzortzakakis2020 ; wang2020 ; huang2020a ; huang2020b ; weidemann2021 ; claes2021 ; liuzhoushu2021 ; liu2021 ; luo2021a ; luoTransferMatrixStudy2021 ; luoUnifyingAndersonTransitions2022 ; tomasi2023 ; wang2023 ; huang2025 ; mo2025 . Despite decades of research, the nature of the Anderson transition in some symmetry classes remains enigmatic gadeReplicaLimitUnSOn1991 ; gadeAndersonLocalizationSublattice1993 ; balentsDelocalizationTransitionSupersymmetry1997 ; hatsugai1997 ; altland1999 ; fukui1999 ; fabrizio2000 ; guruswamy2000 ; motrunich2002 ; horovitz2002 ; mudry2003 ; bocquet2003 ; yamada2004 ; garcia-garcia2006 ; dellanna2006 ; markos2007 ; konigMetalinsulatorTransitionTwodimensional2012 ; mondragon-shem2014 ; luoCriticalBehaviorAnderson2020 ; li2020 ; wang2021 ; karcherMetalinsulatorTransitionTwodimensional2023 ; karcher2023b ; xiaoAnisotropicTopologicalAnderson2023 ; zhaoTopologicalEffectAnderson2024c ; silva2025 . The Anderson transition has been studied by using effective field theories for disordered quantum systems—nonlinear sigma models (NLSMs)—in which the coupling constant corresponds to conductivity, and the \beta function of the conductivity determines the presence (or absence) of the Anderson transition as well as its universality class wegner1976 ; wegner1979 ; efetov1980 ; hikami1980 ; hikami1981 ; efetov1983 ; eversAndersonTransitions2008 . In the early 90s, Gade and Wegner found that the perturbative \beta function for chiral symmetry classes (AIII, CII, and BDI) has no localization effects in the dimension D\geq 2 , implying that metallic phases in these classes remain stable regardless of disorder strength—contrary to the expectation that sufficiently strong disorder should always induce the Anderson transition gadeAndersonLocalizationSublattice1993 ; gadeReplicaLimitUnSOn1991 . The puzzle was later resolved in 2D by König et al. konigMetalinsulatorTransitionTwodimensional2012 , who incorporated non-perturbative effects arising from topological defects in the NLSMs. The NLSM field variable in chiral symmetry classes resides in curved manifolds of the unitary group. Such manifolds inherently possess a U(1) subgroup symmetry, permitting vortex solutions. Thus, the 2D Anderson transition in chiral symmetry classes can be understood as a quantum phase transition driven by the spatial proliferation of U(1) vortex-antivortex pairs konigMetalinsulatorTransitionTwodimensional2012 ; zhaoTopologicalEffectAnderson2024c . In contrast, the theoretical framework of the 3D Anderson transition in chiral symmetry classes remains largely unexplored, despite numerical confirmations of its existence garcia-garcia2006 ; luoCriticalBehaviorAnderson2020 ; wang2021 ; xiaoAnisotropicTopologicalAnderson2023 . In this paper, we generalize the 2D theory konigMetalinsulatorTransitionTwodimensional2012 into three-dimensional (3D) chiral symmetry classes, where the NLSM field variable permits vortex loop solutions. We argue that the 3D Anderson transition in chiral classes is driven by the spatial proliferation of the vortex loops. We derive a dual representation of the 3D NLSM for the chiral unitary class and construct a mean-field theory of its 3D Anderson transition. The dual model takes the form of \mathrm{U}(N) type-II superconductors. • The diffusive metal phase with a sparse population of vortex loops is described as the normal (Maxwell) phase in the type-II superconductors, where magnetic gauge field fluctuations—driven by the entropic effect but controlled by the Maxwell action—suppress superconductivity entirely. • The localized phase, signaled by vortex-loop proliferation, is described as the superconducting (Meissner) phase, where the Josephson coupling stabilizes superconducting order, and the spontaneous symmetry breaking of the global U(1) gauge symmetry renders the magnetic gauge field massive via the Anderson-Higgs mechanism anderson1963 ; higgs1964 . Recent studies have demonstrated that nontrivial 1D weak band topology in chiral symmetry classes gives rise to an intermediate quasi-localized phase, bridging metallic and fully localized phases xiaoAnisotropicTopologicalAnderson2023 ; zhaoTopologicalEffectAnderson2024c . In the quasi-localized phase, the exponential localization length diverges only along the weak topological direction while remaining finite in the other directions. We show that, in the dual representation, the 1D weak topology manifests as an external magnetic field applied to the type-II superconductors along the topological direction. Thereby, • the quasi-localized phase—characterized by divergent localization length only along the topological direction—can be described as an intermediate mixed phase in which the external magnetic field penetrates through the 3D superconducting bulk in the form of magnetic flux tubes blatter1994 ; brandt1995 ;