Leveraging Relational Evidence: Population Size Estimation on Tree-Structured Data with the Weighted Multiplier Method Publication type: PREPRINT
Mallory J Flynn, Paul Gustafson, M.J. Flynn, P. Gustafson · 2025
Read Leveraging Relational Evidence: Population Size Estimation on Tree-Structured Data with the Weighted Multiplier Method Publication type: PREPRINT by Mallory J Flynn, Paul Gustafson, M.J. Flynn, P. Gustafson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-21020.txt.
Introduction
Mallory Flynn and Paul Gustafson stretch the multiplier method to tree-shaped data for sizing hidden groups. Their paper is from two thousand twenty-five; the pack row gives no title or year, so the text head is the source. Hidden groups still need counts to guide funds and policy. The classic method backs a total out of one known subgroup and its share.
Their weighted form blends many subgroups in a tree by the least-spread blend of their shares. They set it against a Bayesian stacked model on made-up and real data. Reads of which data drive each method, and of how each bears strain, round out the work. The aim is a tool that less technical teams can run.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mallory J Flynn, Paul Gustafson, M.J. Flynn, P. Gustafson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 73 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-21020
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Leveraging Relational Evidence: Population Size Estimation on Tree-Structured Data with the Weighted Multiplier Method Publication type: PREPRINT Mallory J Flynn, Paul Gustafson, M.J. Flynn, P. Gustafson Abstract Populations of interest are often hidden from data for a variety of reasons, though their magnitude remains important in determining resource allocation and appropriate policy. One popular approach to population size estimation, the multiplier method, is a back-calculation tool requiring only a marginal subpopulation size and an estimate of the proportion belonging to this subgroup. Another approach is to use Bayesian methods, which are inherently well-suited to incorporating multiple data sources. However, both methods have their drawbacks. A framework for applying the multiplier method which combines information from several known subpopulations has not yet been established; Bayesian models, though able to incorporate complex dependencies and various data sources, can be difficult for researchers in less technical fields to design and implement. Increasing data collection and linkage across diverse fields suggests accessible methods of estimating population size with synthesized data are needed. We propose an extension to the well-known multiplier method which is applicable to tree-structured data, where multiple subpopulations and corresponding proportions combine to generate a population size estimate via the minimum variance estimator. The methodology and resulting estimates are compared with those from a Bayesian hierarchical model, for both simulated and real world data. Subsequent analysis elucidates which data are key to estimation in each method, and examines robustness and feasibility of this new methodology. keywords Bayesian modeling; multiplier method; population estimation; tree; overdose; opioid † † copyright-year: 2025 † † corresponding: Mallory Flynn, † † citation: ), , , . † † copyright: , and ( † † year: 2025 † † ctitle: Leveraging Relational Evidence: Population Size Estimation on Tree-Structured Data with the Weighted Multiplier Method † † cjournal: Preprint † † cvolume: 2025;00:1–26 Mallory J Flynn et al \presentaddress Department of Statistics, Faculty of Science, University of British Columbia, 2207 Main Mall, Vancouver, BC, V6T 1Z4, Canada 0 0 footnotetext: Abbreviations: MM, multiplier method; WMM, weighted multiplier method; ATD, acute toxicity death 1 Introduction Population size estimation is of interest in many disciplines, as key populations may be hidden from data for a variety of reasons. Within public health and epidemiology, determining the magnitude of these populations is important to both policy makers allocating resources, as well as clinicians developing prevention, care, and treatment programs. Factors such as healthcare accessibility, symptom presentation, stigmatization, or marginalization, may contribute to medical conditions or events not being captured by administrative health data, leading in turn to underestimated or misguided resource allocation. Capture-recapture (CRC) studies are popular methods of population size estimation. In it’s most basic form, CRC estimates are based on two independent samples, where individuals who were captured by the first sample are marked so that they may be identified if recaptured in the second sample. Under the assumption that all members of the population have equal probability of capture in the second sample, a total population estimate can be obtained by dividing the size of the first sample by the proportion of recaptured individuals existing in the second sample ? . The original methodology does employ several assumptions, including equal probability of capture, independence of samples, and demographic closure ? . Extensions have been made in the literature to address these, as many applications violate one or more of these assumptions. In particular, methods which incorporate multiple-recapture ?? , dependence between capture events ? , and individual heterogeneity have been developed ? . While these extensions make CRC more suitable to applications involving health administrative data ? , further assumptions about individual heterogeneity must be made, and quantifying dependency between sampling occasions is complex to model. In public health, organizations providing data which inform a target population often provide healthcare to that same population, commonly making referrals between one another for follow-up or complementary treatments. Furthermore, a representative sample is not typically achieved, and individuals from the target population are more likely to appear in multiple data sources along the natural progression through various health service departments. While dependencies between data sources can be accounted for through the use of interaction terms in log-linear models, this method is inadequate in the presence of referrals and can lead to multiple seemingly plausible models generating widely varying estimates ? . The multiplier method is a commonly used alternative to CRC which is based upon back-calculation from a known subpopulation. In it’s most general form, a service or unique object identifier is distributed to individuals of a target population. To obtain a size estimate of the target population, the count of individuals receiving this service or unique object is then used with an estimate of the proportion of the population receiving it ? . While the data source for the latter must be representative of the population, the subpopulation receiving the service or object need not be random. Furthermore, while the two data sources must be independent and define the population in the same terms, the multiplier method is often able to be employed using readily available, existing data ? . The method is widely implemented in public health, where some service or trait may serve as a unique identifier defining a subpopulation ? . Health administrative data are often suitable sources of subpopulations, and to estimate proportions, either existing surveys can be used, or resource allocation can simply focus on gathering data on service/trait proportions via sample surveys ? . Although the multiplier method makes it possible to exploit existing information at all levels, it is sensitive to the accuracy of both marginal counts and estimates of proportions, and will not produce reliable or robust population size estimates with variable data ? . Furthermore, back-calculated estimates are generated using the count of a single subpopulation of the target population; in practice, multiple subpopulations with corresponding estimates of proportions may be available, but an optimal method of combining target population size estimates produced by multiple sources is not yet developed. As an alternative to simpler methods, a fully Bayesian approach can be implemented to estimate population size and provides a framework capable of synthesizing data from multiple sources and combining expert knowledge to make inference on model values and parameters ?????? . A wealth of literature exists demonstrating the utility of both the multiplier method and Bayesian modeling to provide accurate population size estimates and corresponding uncertainty. The multiplier method is commonly used by public health agencies and institutes globally in the estimation of the size of key populations such as populations at higher risk of blood-borne infectious disease transmission (e.g., HIV, hepatitis), including people who inject drugs ??? or men who have sex with men ????? . Similarly, Bayesian modeling is widely used to inform unknown population sizes in these same applications ??? and is also used to estimate the impact of intervention strategies or therapies ??? . While Bayesian inference is a powerful means of estimation in a variety of settings, it needs to be tailored to the specific problems at hand and requires non-trivial theoretical and practical knowledge to implement. When this is infeasible, the simplicity of the multiplier method makes it an attractive alternative; however, in it’s current form,