Disentangling network dependence among multiple variables
Zhejia Dong, Corwin Zigler, Youjin Lee · 2025
Read Disentangling network dependence among multiple variables by Zhejia Dong, Corwin Zigler, Youjin Lee (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-20974.txt.
Introduction
Zhejia Dong, Corwin Zigler, and Youjin Lee tackle a stats problem from 2025 that arises when two traits are measured on people linked in a network. If both traits spread or cluster along the same links, the two can look related even when they are not. The authors compare two older fixes for this trap and adapt them to networks.
One fix, borrowed from time series work, strips shared patterns out before testing. The other models how a trait echoes across links directly. Each fix rests on its own view of how traits move through a network. In computer trials, both fixes cut false links when their views held true. Both failed more often when the true pattern differed, so the choice of method matters.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zhejia Dong, Corwin Zigler, Youjin Lee |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 60 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-20974
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Disentangling network dependence among multiple variables Zhejia Dong, Corwin Zigler, Youjin Lee Abstract When two variables depend on the same or similar underlying network, their shared network dependence structure can lead to spurious associations. While statistical associations between two variables sampled from interconnected subjects are a common inferential goal across various fields, little research has focused on how to disentangle shared dependence for valid statistical inference. We revisit two different approaches from distinct fields that may address shared network dependence: the pre-whitening approach, commonly used in time series analysis to remove the shared temporal dependence, and the network autocorrelation model, widely used in network analysis often to examine or account for autocorrelation of the outcome variable. We demonstrate how each approach implicitly entails assumptions about how a variable of interest propagates among nodes via network ties given the network structure. We further propose adaptations of existing pre-whitening methods to the network setting by explicitly reflecting underlying assumptions about “level of interaction” that induce network dependence, while accounting for its unique complexities. Our simulation studies demonstrate the effectiveness of the two approaches in reducing spurious associations due to shared network dependence when their respective assumptions hold. However, the results also show the sensitivity to assumption violations, underscoring the importance of correctly specifying the shared dependence structure based on available network information and prior knowledge about the interactions driving dependence. Keywords: Autocorrelation, Pre-whitening, Network autocorrelation model 1 Introduction Network dependence , or network autocorrelation—statistical dependence within a variable due to network ties—is prevalent across various studies where subjects are interconnected through network relationships ( Dow et al. 1982 ; Dow et al. 1984 ; O’malley and Marsden 2008 ; Peeters and Thomas 2009 ; Lee and Ogburn 2021 ) . Numerous statistical methods have been developed to either account for or assess autocorrelation within a single network-dependent variable, typically the primary outcome of interest ( Leenders 2002 ; Christakis 2004 ) , often focusing on its relationship with a fixed covariate. However, in practice, it is common for both outcome and exposure variables to exhibit network dependence. Despite the widespread use of methods for correcting dependence in multiple variables in other settings, there has been little discussion of statistical inference when examining relationships among multiple network-dependent variables. 1.1 Spurious associations due to network dependence It is well known that two independently generated time series can appear statistically correlated if they exhibit similar patterns of strong autocorrelation. This is also known as nonsense or volatile correlations in econometrics literature ( Yule 1926 ; Ernst et al. 2017 ) . In fact, any form of autocorrelation shared by two or more variables can lead to such misleading associations. Lee and Ogburn 2021 demonstrate that two variables sampled from the same network, exhibiting shared dependence structure, may appear statistically correlated, even in the absence of a true association. Following Lee and Ogburn 2021 , we refer to this phenomenon as spurious associations due to network dependence . Despite the shared underlying mechanisms behind spurious associations across different fields, statistical approaches to addressing this issue remain discipline-specific. To our knowledge, no existing literature comprehensively examines the applicability of existing methods for disentangling shared dependence in the context of network dependence. While spurious associations due to network dependence have been routinely unacknowledged in many human subjects studies, accounting for network dependence in statistical models has been widely practiced in network research, particularly when network data are explicitly collected. Such models primarily focus on assessing the presence and extent of autocorrelation ( Wang et al. 2014 ; Dittrich et al. 2020 ) or evaluating whether network relationships causally induce correlations among observations ( Carr and Zube 2015 ; De-Marcos et al. 2016 ) . These analyses do not necessarily require multiple variables beyond the primary outcome of interest, and even when additional variables are included, no further statistical assumptions about them are typically required. In this work, we focus on cases where the relationships between two variables sampled from the same network are of interest, assuming that the presence of autocorrelation in these variables is already known and thus not our focus. 1.2 Our contribution In this work, we examine the utility of two widely used approaches for accounting for autocorrelation in addressing spurious associations due to network dependence. The first approach is pre-whitening methods, which are commonly applied in time series analysis but have seen limited use in network settings, and the second approach is the network autocorrelation model, which is not explicitly designed to correct for shared dependence among multiple variables, but rather to address autocorrelation in the outcome variation within regression models. While neither approach was originally developed for the present setting, we demonstrate that either of them can be effective in addressing shared network dependence across multiple variables—though only under specific circumstances related to the presumed network structure. Our main contributions are as follows. First, we identify key differences between network dependence and dependence arising in other contexts, and we highlight important elements that should be considered when modeling network dependence. Second, we discuss how pre-whitening approaches can be adapted in network settings. We propose a general approach to constructing the dependence structure based on certain statistical assumptions and known network structure and introduce an estimation method that addresses computational challenges due to the complexity of network dependence, illustrated through a concrete example. Lastly, we examine the assumptions underlying network autocorrelation models and compare them with those used in the pre-whitening approach. Overall, our work highlights the importance of considering the level of interactions on a network that induces autocorrelation across multiple variables. This is because different approaches for addressing within-variable dependence implicitly assume different levels of interaction, which has important implications for both model specification and interpretation. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we review autocorrelation in other settings and discuss the unique challenges in network dependence. Section 3 introduces the pre-whitening approach and examines its potential application to network dependence. Section 4 discusses the network autocorrelation model and examines its underlying assumptions regarding shared dependence. Section 5 presents a simulation study comparing the performance of these two approaches in correcting spurious associations due to network dependence. Finally, we discuss the results and their implications in Section 6 . 2 Preliminaries 2.1 Structured autocorrelation in other contexts Autocorrelation is common in temporal, spatial, genetic, and network spaces, where the degree of dependence between two observations depends on their respective distance measures. In temporal autocorrelation, distance is often defined by time lags on \mathbb{R} between observations, meaning that observations closer in time are more likely to be correlated than those farther apart ( Makridakis 1994 ) . In spatial autocorrelation, the Euclidean distance on \mathbb{R}^{2} is often used to quantify dependence between observations ( Legendre 1993 ) . In both temporal and spatial autocorrelation, as the number of observations ( n ) increases, the distribution of temporal and spatial distances becomes more variable, leading to an exponential growth in the number of observation pairs with large (relative) distances. As a result, autocorrelation among most pairs decays. This scarcity of strongly autocorrelated pairs plays a crucial role in statistical inference by ensuring statistical independence among most observation pairs