Dynamical friction and massive black hole orbits: analytical predictions and numerical solutions

Alice Damiano, Stefano Borgani, Milena Valentini, Giuseppe Murante, Luca Tornatore, Petr Strakos, Milan Jaros · 2025

Read Dynamical friction and massive black hole orbits: analytical predictions and numerical solutions by Alice Damiano, Stefano Borgani, Milena Valentini, Giuseppe Murante, Luca Tornatore, Petr Strakos, Milan Jaros (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-20740.txt.

Introduction

Damiano leads a team refining how simulations handle the drag that sinks massive black holes in a 2025 paper. Dynamical friction slows a black hole moving through dark matter and stars. Simulations often get this drag wrong at low resolution.

The team built an analytic framework plus a Python library for the hole's equations of motion. Simulations with an improved, kernel-weighted friction correction matched the analytic predictions closely. Sinking sped up and results converged as resolution rose. The correction still worked when the hole weighed less than single simulation particles. A stellar bulge oddly delayed sinking through numerical heating, partly offset by the fix. The work targets future galaxy and cosmology runs.

Catalog record

CREATORAlice Damiano, Stefano Borgani, Milena Valentini, Giuseppe Murante, Luca Tornatore, Petr Strakos, Milan Jaros
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE97 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-20740

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Dynamical friction and massive black hole orbits: analytical predictions and numerical solutions Alice Damiano, Stefano Borgani, Milena Valentini, Giuseppe Murante, Luca Tornatore, Petr Strakos, Milan Jaros Abstract Aims. We investigate the orbital decay of a massive BH embedded in a dark matter halo and a stellar bulge, using both analytical and numerical simulations with the aim of developing and validating a reliable dynamical friction (DF) correction across simulation resolutions. Methods. We develop a Python-based library to solve the equations of motion of the BH and provide an analytical framework for the numerical results. Then, we carry out simulations at different resolutions and for different softening choices using the Tree-PM code OpenGADGET3 , where we implement an improved DF correction based on a kernel-weighted local density estimation. Results. Our results demonstrate that the DF correction significantly accelerates BH sinking and ensures convergence with increasing resolution, closely matching analytical predictions. We find that in low-resolution regimes—particularly when the BH mass is smaller than that of the background particles—our DF model still effectively controls BH dynamics. Contrary to expectations, the inclusion of a stellar bulge can delay sinking due to numerical heating, an effect partially mitigated by the DF correction. Conclusions. We conclude that our refined DF implementation provides a robust framework for modeling BH dynamics both in controlled simulation setups of galaxies and in large-scale cosmological simulations. This will be crucial for future simulation campaigns, to enable more accurate predictions of AGN accretion and feedback, and to estimate gravitational-wave event rates. 1 Introduction Massive black holes (MBHs) reside at the center of massive galaxies ( Kormendy & Richstone 1995 ; Ferrarese & Merritt 2000 ) , and they gradually sink toward the core of a newly-formed galaxy when their host galaxies undergo mergers ( Callegari et al. 2009 ; Mayer et al. 2007 ; Capelo et al. 2015 ; Comerford et al. 2009 ; Volonteri et al. 2015 ) , eventually forming a dual or binary system ( Volonteri et al. 2022 ; Dotti et al. 2010 ; Volonteri et al. 2021 ; Cao et al. 2025 ; Merritt & Milosavljevic 2004 ) . The diversity in MBH population demography arises from the dynamical processes governing their motion. In the dense stellar environments of galactic centers, MBHs experience dynamical friction (DF) ( Chandrasekhar 1943 ) , a drag force exerted by the surrounding stellar and DM distribution. DF not only anchors MBHs to the galactic center but also facilitates their gradual loss of angular momentum, driving their inspiral toward the core ( Antonini & Merritt 2011 ; Li et al. 2020 ; Vecchio et al. 1994 ; Volonteri et al. 2016 ; Just et al. 2010 ; Boylan-Kolchin et al. 2008 ) . Determining the timescale for MBH sinking and coalescence remains a complex issue stemming from the complex dynamical environment in which MBHs evolve—a regime that deviates significantly from idealized analytical descriptions and demands both high numerical precision and spatial resolution in simulations to be properly captured. First introduced by Chandrasekhar 1943 , the DF force describes the gravitational drag exerted by a background medium of stars or dark matter (DM) on a massive object moving through it. In the simplified case where the surrounding particles are negligible in mass compared to the perturber, and are distributed in a uniform and homogeneous medium, a simple analytical formula for the sinking timescale can be derived ( Binney & Tremaine 1987 ). However, it is unlikely that the BH experiences the passage through a homogeneous and isotropic medium when infalling to the galactic core. Furthermore, the choice of the maximum radius where to account for the DF is a free parameter whose choice has a significant impact on the resulting timescale for sinking. While the analytical solution derived from the Chandrasekhar DF formula can be inaccurate, searching for a numerical solution is equally challenging ( Taffoni et al. 2003 ). The primary difficulty lies in the large spatial range required to properly simulate the infall of a MBH toward the galactic center, alongside the high spatial and mass resolution necessary to accurately capture gravitational interactions, including both DF and large-scale galactic torques ( Bortolas et al. 2020 ). In the context of N-body simulations, both coarse mass resolution and too aggressive gravitational force softening can introduce numerical heating into the BH’s motion. To mitigate this limitation, several ad hoc prescriptions have been proposed. Among them, a widely used approach involves repositioning the BH at the local minimum of the gravitational potential ( Springel et al. 2005 ; Davé et al. 2019 ; Bassini et al. 2019 ). However, this method suffers from significant drawbacks, particularly in environments having a shallow potential well or during galaxy mergers, where it may lead to unphysical BH trajectories (e.g., Damiano et al. 2024 and references therein). Another serious limitation in correctly following orbits of BH particles arises close to epoch of BH seeding. In this regime BH masses are generally smaller than that of surrounding DM and stellar particles, thus rendering DF poorly described by the N-body solver. To mitigate this limitation, it has been proposed to artificially boost the BH ”dynamical mass”, i.e. the mass felt by gravity, so as to enhance the DF effect ( Curtis & Sijacki 2015 , e.g.) . Currently, a variety of DF-based sub-resolution models for BH dynamics are implemented across different cosmological and galaxy formation simulations, each attempting to compensate for numerical limitations while ensuring realistic BH sinking and merging processes ( Hirschmann et al. 2014 ; Tremmel et al. 2015 ; Chen et al. 2022 ; Ma et al. 2023 ) . All such models involve the addition of corrective terms to the BH acceleration predicted by the N-body solver, to account for the DF exerted by the surrounding particles. However, it is generally accepted that even with a DF correction, the dynamics of MBHs remains unresolved when the BH mass is lower than approximately twice the mass of the surrounding particles ( Genina et al. 2024 ) . In such cases, numerical inaccuracies can still dominate the BH’s trajectory, making it challenging to accurately describe the expected sinking process. A validation of these numerical techniques requires testing them with controlled and idealized numerical experiments, which satisfy the assumptions on which analytical predictions are based. In this paper, we investigate the infall of a BH in a DM halo, with and without the inclusion of a stellar bulge, to address the following key questions: how do the sinking timescales of the BH compare with and without the DF correction? Is there numerical convergence of the sinking timescale at increasing resolution when using the DF correction? How do numerical results compare with analytical predictions at progressively increasing resolution and including a DF correction? How does the presence of a stellar bulge impact the BH dynamics? Finally, can a DF correction be developed to accurately control the BH dynamics in the critical regime where the BH mass is smaller than that of the surrounding particles? To address these questions, we introduce a refined DF prescription, built upon the framework of Damiano et al. 2024 , but tailored to accurately model the challenging regime where the BH mass is smaller than that

Read the complete text