Establishing validated standards for Home and Work location Detection

Silvia de Sojo, Lorenzo Lucchini, Ollin D. Langle-Chimal, Samuel P. Fraiberger, Laura Alessandretti · 2025

Read Establishing validated standards for Home and Work location Detection by Silvia de Sojo, Lorenzo Lucchini, Ollin D. Langle-Chimal, Samuel P. Fraiberger, Laura Alessandretti (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-20679.txt.

Introduction

Sílvia de Sojo and co-authors give mobility research a validated yardstick for its most basic question: where does this phone live and work? Smartphone traces power studies of commuting and jobs, yet home and work detection is usually hand-rolled per data set. Their open-source library, HoWDe, standardizes the step.

The pipeline is modular and transparent, built to survive missing data, uneven sampling, and sparse users, with a few readable knobs to tune. Against ground truth for over five thousand people in sixty-eight countries, it found homes with up to ninety-seven percent accuracy and workplaces up to eighty-eight. The team also shows how settings ripple into job and commuting estimates, arguing that shared standards make mobility science comparable.

Catalog record

CREATORSilvia de Sojo, Lorenzo Lucchini, Ollin D. Langle-Chimal, Samuel P. Fraiberger, Laura Alessandretti
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-20679

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Establishing validated standards for Home and Work location Detection Silvia de Sojo, Lorenzo Lucchini, Ollin D. Langle-Chimal, Samuel P. Fraiberger, Laura Alessandretti Abstract Smartphone location data have transformed urban mobility research, providing unprecedented insights into how people navigate and interact in cities. However, leveraging location data at scale presents methodological challenges. Accurately identifying individuals’ home and work locations is critical for a range of applications, including commuting analysis, unemployment estimation, and urban accessibility studies. Despite their widespread use, home–work detection methods lack a standardized framework that accounts for differing data quality and that is validated against ground-truth observations. This limits the comparability and reproducibility of results across studies and datasets. In this paper, we present HoWDe, a robust algorithm for identifying home and work locations from mobility data, explicitly designed to handle missing data and varying data quality across individuals. Using two unique ground-truth datasets comprising over 5,100 5,100 individuals from more than 80 80 countries, HoWDe achieves home and work detection accuracies of up to 97 % 97\% and 88 % 88\% , respectively, with consistent performance across countries and demographic groups. We examine how parameter choices shape the trade-off between accuracy and user retention, and demonstrate how these methodological decisions influence downstream applications such as employment estimation and commuting pattern analysis. By supporting in-house pre-processing through a transparent and validated pipeline, HoWDe also facilitates the sharing of privacy-preserving mobility data. Together, our tools and findings establish methodological standards that support more robust, scalable, and reproducible mobility research at both individual and urban scales. Keywords: GPS data, Home and work detection, Human Mobility, Stop-location sequences, Mobility algorithms, Missing data, Urban analytics 1 Introduction Location data collected from smartphones has become indispensable for human mobility analyses [ 1 , 2 ] . These datasets allow studying large samples of individuals globally, providing insights on fundamental aspects of human movements [ 3 ] , epidemic spreading [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 ] , migration patterns [ 8 , 5 ] , transportation modeling [ 9 ] , urban planning [ 10 , 11 ] , and the impact of natural disasters and societal shocks on population movements [ 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] . In light of these advancements, developing robust methods for location data analysis has become a pressing need for scientists and practitioners [ 17 ] . A critical component of location data analyses involves the detection of individuals’ visits to their residential [ 18 , 19 , 20 ] , and work location [ 17 ] . The accurate identification of home and work locations is key for mobility research, as it enables the analysis of factors such as socio-economic background [ 21 , 22 , 15 ] , commuting behaviors [ 23 , 16 ] , social contact networks [ 24 , 14 ] , and accessibility to amenities and services [ 25 , 14 ] . More broadly, it contributes to advancements in computational demography and social science research [ 26 , 17 ] . The most widely used methods for home and work detection are heuristic approaches that leverage the regularity of human behavior, such as the tendency to spend nights at home and working hours at a workplace [ 27 , 28 , 29 ] . These methods face significant challenges. First, they are sensitive to missing data, which is common in smartphone records [ 17 ] . Data quality varies across individuals and over time, as location gaps arise due to factors like inactivity, disabled services, or poor signal, introducing biases in home and work inference [ 30 , 31 , 17 ] . Second, they rely on the choice of parameters, such as time span required to establish a home location or the minimum number of hours per day spent at work. Despite their importance for mobility analyses, the extent to which heuristic approaches for home/work location detection are reliable remains unclear, and there is no consensus on how to choose one specific algorithm and its parameters’ values [ 21 , 32 , 33 , 34 , 35 , 17 ] , in part due to a lack of ground truth data. Validation efforts so far have been limited, focusing on small subsets of individuals, home detection alone, and datasets with low spatial resolution and short time periods [ 34 , 35 , 32 , 21 ] . Furthermore, the influence of key parameter choices (such as the length of the period considered or the minimum activity level necessary to define home/work locations) has not been understood in relation to algorithmic performance. The lack of thorough validation has hindered the refinement and harmonization of these methods into standardized best practices [ 36 , 17 ] . In turn, the absence of such standards can impact the comparability and reproducibility of mobility studies [ 17 ] . In this work, we leverage two distinct ground truth datasets to address these key challenges in home/work location detection. Both datasets include sequences of visits to detailed locations with corresponding ground truth: the first dataset (D1) contains self-reported home and work locations from 4,599 users collected between 2015 and 2019, while the second (D2) is based on independent expert annotations for 500 users throughout 2020 (see Methods for details). First, we leverage these data to uncover behavioral patterns in home and work visits. This allows us to empirically assess whether the assumptions underlying home and work detection hold in practice. Additionally, it enables us to quantify the variability in home-work visit behavior across a diverse set of users. Second, we formalize HoWDe , an algorithm for home and work detection that enhances existing heuristics by integrating key elements from previous work into a comprehensive approach. HoWDe combines the explicit detection of both home and work locations [ 14 , 29 ] , the identification of the workplace based on recurrent visits during working hours [ 29 ] , the identification of the home as the most frequently visited location at night [ 35 , 28 , 34 , 21 ] , a sliding window to identify home and job changes over time [ 14 ] , with tunable window length [ 14 ] . Additionally, HoWDe improves upon existing approaches by better accounting for data gaps and their variation across users and over time. We provide an open-source implementation of the algorithm [ 37 ] . Finally, we assess HoWDe’s performance against the ground truth data. We provide a detailed analysis of the role of its parameters, and we study how performance changes across age groups, gender, countries, and urbanization levels. We conclude by quantifying how errors in the estimation of home and work locations propagate to key downstream tasks such as estimating employment rates or commuting distances. 2 Results 2.1 Unveiling temporal patterns of home-work visits We analyze the regularity of home and work visits by measuring how often and when individuals are recorded at their annotated locations. Figure 1 a-b shows the probability of being at home or work by hour of the day. We find that home visits peak between midnight and 6 AM, while work visits are most frequent during typical business hours (between

Read the complete text