DefElement: an encyclopedia of finite element definitions
Matthew W. Scroggs 0000-0002-4658-2443, Pablo D. Brubeck 0000-0002-3824-0080, Joseph P. Dean 0000-0001-7499-3373, Jørgen S. Dokken 0000-0001-6489-8858, India Marsden 0009-0006-0152-4780 · 2025
Read DefElement: an encyclopedia of finite element definitions by Matthew W. Scroggs 0000-0002-4658-2443, Pablo D. Brubeck 0000-0002-3824-0080, Joseph P. Dean 0000-0001-7499-3373, Jørgen S. Dokken 0000-0001-6489-8858, India Marsden 0009-0006-0152-4780 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-20188.txt.
Introduction
Matthew Scroggs and co-authors describe an online encyclopedia that pins down the exact definitions of finite elements, in a 2025 paper. Finite elements are the building blocks of simulation software for engineering and physics. Many libraries implement the same named element with slightly different basis functions, and checking that two versions truly match is painstaking. Their site, DefElement, states each element's definition in one standard format.
The paper derives when two elements count as equivalent and gives an algorithm that checks implementations against each other. Scheduled runs of the checker feed the site, so readers see which libraries agree and which quietly differ. The authors maintain the encyclopedia themselves and offer it as shared ground truth for the simulation community. The aim is fewer silent mismatches between codes that claim to compute the same thing.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Matthew W. Scroggs 0000-0002-4658-2443, Pablo D. Brubeck 0000-0002-3824-0080, Joseph P. Dean 0000-0001-7499-3373, Jørgen S. Dokken 0000-0001-6489-8858, India Marsden 0009-0006-0152-4780 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 111 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-20188
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
DefElement: an encyclopedia of finite element definitions Matthew W. Scroggs 0000-0002-4658-2443, Pablo D. Brubeck 0000-0002-3824-0080, Joseph P. Dean 0000-0001-7499-3373, Jørgen S. Dokken 0000-0001-6489-8858, India Marsden 0009-0006-0152-4780 Abstract DefElement is an online encyclopedia of finite element definitions that was created and is maintained by the authors of this paper. DefElement aims to make information about elements defined in the literature easily available in a standard format. There are a number of open-source finite element libraries available, and it can be difficult to check that an implementation of an element in a library matches the element’s definition in the literature or implementation in another library, especially when many libraries include variants of elements whose basis functions do not match exactly. In this paper, we carefully derive conditions under which elements can be considered equivalent and describe an algorithm that uses these conditions to verify that two implementations of a finite element are indeed variants of the same element. The results of scheduled runs of our implementation of this verification algorithm are included in the information available on DefElement. keywords finite element methods 1 Introduction The finite element method has its origins in the 1940s, when methods involving the meshing of a domain began to be used by engineers Courant 1943 ; Liu et al. 2022 ; Clough 1980 . The name finite element method was coined in a 1960 paper by Ray Clough Clough 1960 . Throughout the 1960s, significant progress was made in analysing the finite element method. The use of a triple to represent a finite element was introduced in 1975 in a set of lecture notes by Philippe Ciarlet Ciarlet 1975 , before appearing in his popular 1978 book Ciarlet 1978 . This definition was first written with scalar-valued elements in mind, but it was used shortly after its introduction by Pierre-Arnaud Raviart and Jean-Marie Thomas Raviart and Thomas 1977 and Jean-Claude Nédélec Nédélec 1980 to define vector-valued H(div)-conforming and H(curl)-conforming elements. Since its introduction, Ciarlet’s triple—with some small notable adjustments—has become the widely accepted definition of a finite element, and it has been used to define a huge range of elements designed for specific applications including fluid dynamics Guzmán and Neilan 2018 ; Rannacher and Turek 1992 , plate deformation Pechstein and Schöberl 2017 , and solid mechanics Arnold and Awanou 2011 . Details of Ciarlet’s triple and an overview of different element types is presented in section 2 . Often, only the lowest-order version of an element is introduced initially, with higher-order versions and versions on other cell types presented in subsequent papers. This can make tracking down appropriate elements that would be suitable for solving a particular problem a challenging task. To simplify this task, we have created DefElement, an online encyclopedia of finite element definitions hosted at defelement.org 1 1 1 DefElement was originally hosted at defelement.com . This old URL now forwards to defelement.org . DefElement contains the definitions of a large number of finite elements and useful information about each one. Our encyclopedia was partly inspired by the Periodic Table of Finite Elements Arnold and Logg 2014 , which displays the elements in four common de Rham families, and the Online Encyclopedia of Integer Sequences (OEIS) OEIS Foundation Inc. 1996– . DefElement includes a page with information about each finite element. As shown in fig. 1 for Raviart–Thomas elements, this information includes: • alternative names of the element; • details of the element’s definition; • the polynomial and Lagrange subdegree and superdegree of the element, as we will define in section 2.3 ; • the number of degrees of freedom (DOFs) that the element has in terms of the degree k ; • details of any variants of the element, as we will define in section 3 ; • details of libraries in which the element is implemented. Currently, the libraries Basix Scroggs et al. 2022 , Bempp-cl Betcke and Scroggs 2021 , FIAT Kirby 2004 , ndelement Scroggs 2024 , and Symfem Scroggs 2021 are included • some example low-degree elements, with functions and plots generated using Symfem. These plots, and all other diagrams on DefElement, are licensed under a Creative Commons license, so that they can be reused in papers and elsewhere as long as an attribution is included; • a list of references where the full definition of the element can be found. Figure 1: Information about Raviart–Thomas elements, as shown on its DefElement page at defelement.org/elements/raviart-thomas.html (accessed 7 April 2025). This information includes details of the element’s definition (top left), implementations that include the element and example low-degree elements (top right), and references to literature where full details of the element can be found. For Raviart–Thomas elements, the included references are Raviart and Thomas 1977 ; Nédélec 1980 ; Rao et al. 1982 ; Arnold and Logg 2014 ; Cockburn and Fu 2017 . Alongside the implementation detail, the DefElement page shows the status of DefElement’s element verification—in fig. 1 , this status is shown via a green tick next to a library’s name. The aim of element verification is to confirm that the implementation of the element in each library matches the definition given in the literature. Element verification will be discussed in more detail in section 4 . We encourage readers of this paper to consider contributing to DefElement by updating the information currently available or adding new information and new elements. In section 5 , we outline how contributions can be made to DefElement. We finish with some concluding remarks in section 6 . 2 Defining finite elements In this section, we give an overview of the definition of finite elements. First, we define the names we use for the sub-entities of a reference cell. Definition 1 (Sub-entities) . The sub-entities of a polytope R\subset\mathbb{R}^{d} are its vertices, edges, faces, and volumes: these have dimension 0, 1, 2 and 3 (respectively). The codimension of a sub-entity is computed by subtracting the dimension of the sub-entity from the topological dimension d . Sub-entities of codimension 0, 1, 2 and 3 are called the cell , facets , ridges and peaks respectively. These definitions are summarised for cells of topological dimensions 0 to 3 in table 1 . Topological dimension Entities by dimension 0 1 2 3 0 (a vertex) the cell - - - 1 (an interval) vertices / facets the cell - - 2 (a polygon) vertices / ridges edges / facets the cell - 3 (a polyhedron) vertices / peaks edges / ridges faces / facets the cell Topological dimension Entities by codimension 0 1 2 3 0 (a vertex) the cell - - - 1 (an interval) the cell vertices / facets - - 2 (a polygon) the cell edges / facets vertices / ridges - 3 (a polyhedron) the cell faces / facets edges / ridges vertices / peaks Table 1: The entities of cells with topological dimensions 0 to 3. The most widely used abstract definition of a finite element is the Ciarlet definition Ciarlet 1978 , which is as follows. Definition 2 (Ciarlet finite element) . A finite element is defined by the triple (R,\mathcal{V},\mathcal{L}) , where • R\subset\mathbb{R}^{d} is the reference cell, usually an interval, polygon or polyhedron; • \mathcal{V}