Epitaxial Stabilization and Emergent Charge Order in Copper Selenide Thin Films

Becker Sharif, Benjamin Theunissen, Connor Westbrook, Swosti Choudhuri, Ryan Baumbach, David Lederman, Thomas Steele, Sergey Savrasov · 2025

Read Epitaxial Stabilization and Emergent Charge Order in Copper Selenide Thin Films by Becker Sharif, Benjamin Theunissen, Connor Westbrook, Swosti Choudhuri, Ryan Baumbach, David Lederman, Thomas Steele, Sergey Savrasov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-20076.txt.

Introduction

Sharif and co-authors grow in 2025 thin films of copper selenide in two crystal forms that bulk material cannot hold at room temperature. Using a beam growth method on a sapphire base, they froze in the high heat cubic form far below its normal change point. The rhombohedral form grew beside it for comparison.

In the cubic films, resistance spiked near one hundred forty kelvin with a lag on warming, and X-rays showed the cell doubling along one axis, both hallmarks of a charge density wave. Math models tied the wave to matching curves on the electron energy surface. The other form showed no such wave, giving a clean contrast.

Catalog record

CREATORBecker Sharif, Benjamin Theunissen, Connor Westbrook, Swosti Choudhuri, Ryan Baumbach, David Lederman, Thomas Steele, Sergey Savrasov
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-20076

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Epitaxial Stabilization and Emergent Charge Order in Copper Selenide Thin Films Becker Sharif, Benjamin Theunissen, Connor Westbrook, Swosti Choudhuri, Ryan Baumbach, David Lederman, Thomas Steele, Sergey Savrasov Abstract We demonstrate epitaxial growth of copper selenide (Cu 2-x Se) thin films in both cubic and rhombohedral phases, achieved via molecular beam epitaxy on Al 2 O 3 3 (001) substrates. Remarkably, the high-temperature cubic phase—which in bulk transforms into the rhombohedral structure below 400 K—is stabilized at room temperature and below, well outside its bulk equilibrium stability range. In the cubic phase films, temperature-dependent electrical transport reveals a pronounced, hysteretic resistivity peak near 140 K, accompanied by unit cell doubling along the [111] direction, as observed by x-ray diffraction, which are hallmarks of a charge density wave (CDW) transition. First-principles calculations show strong Fermi surface nesting in the cubic phase, consistent with the observed CDW instability. In contrast, the rhombohedral films exhibit suppressed nesting and no structural modulation. These results not only unambiguously identify a previously unreported CDW in Cu 2-x Se thin films, but also establish an epitaxial platform for tuning emergent electronic phases via strain and interface engineering. I Main Copper selenide Cu 2-x Se has been the focus of extensive research due to its remarkable structural and electronic properties. In particular, it is known to exhibit a low temperature rhombohedral \beta -phase and a high temperature cubic \alpha -phase, with a range of applications in thermoelectric, ionic conduction, and emerging electronics Eikeland et al. 2017 ; Li et al. 2021 . Although the \alpha - and \beta -phases of copper selenide have been studied in their bulk forms, epitaxial thin films of these phases have not been grown to the best of our knowledge to date. Although prior studies have focused primarily on bulk thermoelectric properties, the electronic transport in thin films remains largely unexplored. Charge density waves (CDWs) are an example of translational symmetry breaking in the underlying crystal lattice of solid-state systems. They are characterized by periodic modulations in the electronic charge density, often coupled with lattice distortions. These phenomena predominantly arise in low-dimensional systems with favorable Fermi surface nesting conditions, where the wave vector connecting regions of high electronic density facilitates strong electron-phonon coupling Cho et al. 2018 . CDWs have been observed in 2D Di Salvo et al. 1976 , and 3D Klintberg et al. 2012 systems, where their formation may not be solely driven by lattice distortions. In such cases, electron-electron interactions are presumed to play a significant role in the emergence of CDWs. Theoretical studies have shown that CDWs may compete with superconductivity, as both CDWs and superconductivity depend on effective attractive interactions—often mediated by phonons—it is worth noting that CDWs can also arise from purely electronic mechanisms, particularly when long-range interactions dominate (e.g., U<V in extended Hubbard models). Balseiro and Falicov 1979 . Unlike superconductivity, which is driven by electron-electron pairing into Cooper pairs, CDWs stem from electron-hole coupling, resulting in a redistribution of charge that opens a gap in the electronic spectrum. Experimentally, CDWs have been studied extensively in transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs) such as TiSe 2 and TaS 2 , where their formation is often accompanied by sharp anomalies in resistivity and other transport properties Di Salvo et al. 1971 ; Wilson and Yoffe 1969 . These materials highlight the interplay between lattice structure and electronic behavior, providing a framework to explore similar transitions in Cu 2-x Se. Here we report on the successful epitaxial growth of the high-temperature \alpha - and low-temperature \beta -phases of Cu 2-x Se. Remarkably, epitaxial stabilization enables the \alpha -phase, which is ordinarily stable only at elevated temperatures, to persist down to room temperature and below. This extended temperature range opens new opportunities to explore the intrinsic properties of the \alpha -phase that are inaccessible in the bulk form. The transport properties of the Cu 2-x Se thin films reveal signatures suggestive of CDW transitions. Such transitions are characterized by resistivity anomalies as a function of temperature, typically indicative of electron-phonon coupling leading to charge redistribution. The \alpha -phase thin films, in particular, exhibit behavior consistent with Fermi surface nesting, a critical condition for CDW formation. I.1 Crystallographic Characterization Room-temperature x-ray diffraction (XRD) data for the \alpha -phase films, grown with high selenium flux rates, revealed a non-stoichiometric \alpha -phase structure of Cu 2-x Se ( 0.05\leq x\leq 0.4 ) with a (111) out-of-plane orientation. The stoichiometry was found to depend on the selenium flux along with the substrate temperature. The calculated out-of-plane lattice constants ranged from d_{111}={3.291} Å to d_{111}=3.314 Å, depending on the stoichiometry. Figure 1 (a) shows the XRD pattern of a non-stoichiometric \alpha -phase Cu 1.78 Se (111) oriented film, with a calculated lattice constant of a=5.724~\AA ( d_{111}=3.305 Å) according to a fit to the Nelson and Riley function (supplementary figure S7.a) et. al. 2025 . These results are in agreement with the findings of Danilkin et al. who reported that Cu 1.78 Se belongs to the space group Fm\bar{3}m with a cubic lattice parameter of a=5.7464(1) Å Danilkin et al. 2003 . The thickness of the \alpha -phase sample was found to be 30.053 nm, according to the X-ray reflectivity (XRR) fit (supplementary figure S6.a) et. al. 2025 . Figure 1: Comparison of structural characterization for the cubic and rhombohedral phases. (a) and (b) show XRD patterns with the scattering vector aligned along the growth direction for the cubic and rhombohedral phases, respectively. (c) and (d) display the corresponding rocking curves with AFM images shown as insets. (e) and (f) present RHEED patterns for the cubic and rhombohedral phases, respectively. Rocking curve scans, shown in Fig. 1 (c), were performed around the (111) reflection of Cu 1.78 Se. The data were fit to two peaks with full width at half maximum (FWHM) values of 0.1 ∘ and 0.6 ∘ . This suggests that part of the film exhibits a high degree of out-of-plane crystalline order. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) images [inset, Fig. 1 (c)] revealed that the film grew in island-like structures with a typical island lateral size of approximately 0.5 \mu m. The island surfaces were atomically smooth, with a root mean square (RMS) roughness of 0.1 nm. Room-temperature XRD data for the \beta -phase films, grown with low Se flux rates, revealed a non-stoichiometric \beta -phase structure of Cu 2-x Se ( 0.05\leq x\leq 0.25 ) with a (003) out-of-plane orientation. The stoichiometry was found to depend on the selenium flux and growth temperature. The calculated lattice constants ranged from c=20.413 Å to c=20.460 Å, depending on the stoichiometry and growth temperature. Figure 1 (b) shows the XRD pattern of a non-stoichiometric \beta -phase Cu 1.95 Se (003) oriented film, with a calculated lattice constant of c=20.446~\AA (supplementary figure S7.b) et. al. 2025 . These results are in agreement with the findings of Eikeland et al., who reported that Cu 1.95 Se belongs to the space group R\bar{3}m:H with a rhombohedral lattice parameter of c=20.449(1) Å Eikeland et al. 2017 . The thickness of the \beta -phase sample was found to be 30.74 nm, according to the XRR fit (supplementary figure S6.b) et. al. 2025 . Rocking curve scans, shown in Fig. 1 (d), were

Read the complete text