Modelling Statistics of Polypeptides in Emissions from Smokers Near Ocean Ridges
Ben Intoy and J. W. Halley · 2025
Read Modelling Statistics of Polypeptides in Emissions from Smokers Near Ocean Ridges by Ben Intoy and J. W. Halley (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-20052.txt.
Introduction
Ben Intoy and J W Halley model the chemistry of hot vents on the ocean floor in a twenty twenty-five paper. The vents, called smokers, sit near ocean ridges and spew hot fluid. Their past work showed that fast cooling of amino acid mixes can lock in odd chemical states, a possible step toward the origin of life.
Here they fix a flaw in the old model: it assumed all amino acids were present in equal amounts, which real vent samples contradict. With the true uneven mix fed in, they compare the model to polypeptide data gathered by a submersible in the Mariana Trough. The match holds, which backs the idea that vents brewed vast, diverse sets of chains far from equilibrium.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ben Intoy and J. W. Halley |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 28 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-20052
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Modelling Statistics of Polypeptides in Emissions from Smokers Near Ocean Ridges Ben Intoy and J. W. Halley Abstract We have previously shown in model studies that rapid quenches of systems of monomers interacting to form polymer chains can fix nonequilibrium chemistries which could lead to the origin of life. We suggested that such quenching processes might have occurred at very high rates on early earth, giving an efficient mechanism for natural sorting through enormous numbers of nonequilibrium chemistries from which those most likely to lead to life could be naturally selected. Taking account of kinetic barriers, we found good agreement between laboratory quenching experiments on solutions of amino acids and the resulting model. We also made a preliminary comparison between reported data on polypeptides sampled from emissions from smokers near ocean ridges and our model. However that previous model assumed that the concentrations of all monomeric amino acids in the medium were the same whereas that is not the case in samples taken from ocean smokers. Here we take account of the heterogeneous concentrations of the amino acid monomers in the medium in the analysis of the smoker data and compare the results with the data on polypeptide concentrations found in the samples taken by a submersible in the Marianna Trough. Results are consistent with the hypothesis that smokers were the source of large and extremely diverse number of polypeptides in thermal disequilibrium which could incubate processes leading to life. pacs PACS numbers: I Introduction The likelihood of natural formation of an initial genome in ’genome first’ models of prebiotic evolution appears to be nearly impossible eigen . That has motivated interest in alternative models in which the early phases of prebiotic systems were characterized by collections of polymers exhibiting lifelike behavior and storing information collectively without a central genome. Estimates of the likelihood of the random natural formation of such entities, of which prions and amyloids mauryprions , reisnerprions . baskakovprions , portilloprions , greenwald are often mentioned as examples, are probably higher but detailed understanding of how likely they are to form prebiotically is poorly understood and a major issue in evaluating such models. Here we address the necessary first step, namely the identification of a source of macromolecular polypeptides far from equilibrium which could incubate the formation of such prebiotic systems. In previous papers wynveen , conditions , quench , life , life2 , intoy we showed that coarse grained models of putative polymer prebiotic chemistry suggested that quenching of a collection of interacting amino acids from a high temperature to ambient conditions could allow a wide natural exploration of the space of polymer combinations in the high temperature phase followed by fixing of many diverse nonequilibrium states some of which could have led to the initiation of life-like entities, possibly like amyloids or prions. Such quenches occur continuously in the fluids emitted continuously from fluids emitted from ’smokers’ found on ocean ridges on ocean floors. Those fluids have been proposed as possible locations of terrestrial life’s origin for other reasons for a long time schreibera ; schreiberb ; shock . Including a simple account of kinetic barriers to peptide hydrolysis life2 in the model of quench allowed us to make a quantitative description of results from laboratory quench experiments yin , matsunoa ; matsunob ; matsunoc . We also briefly discussed the use of the same model to account for measured concentrations of polypeptides found in samples from smokers in the Mariana Trough trench . However a more quantitative analysis requires a reformulation of our statistical model in which the concentrations of the various available monomeric amino acids are allowed to be different from one another, whereas our model in reference life2 assumed that those concentrations are all the same. Here we report a modification of the model of reference life2 which corrects that defect and we compare the results with the observational oceanic data. We assume the same model for polymer formation which was used in quench ; life2 . In life2 we argued that the temperatures and dwell times of the fluid emitted from the smokers before it was emitted were such that the polymer length distributions in the fluid after quench in the cold water at the ocean floor would be essentially the equilibrium distributions that they had before quench. Therefore we will assume here, as we did in life2 ,that the polymer length distribution of the polypeptides in the fluid after emission into the cold ocean water remains the same as the thermally equilibrated length distribution that it had with at a high temperature seyfriedchapter just before quench. The thermally initiated breaking of peptide bonds in the hot fluid is ’frozen out’ after quench, leaving the length distribution fixed in a nonequilibrium state in the cold environment after quench. This assumption is consistent with our rate estimates based on reported laboratory data and also with our analysis reported in intoyhalleypopulations of the polypeptide length distribution in modern prokaryotes showing that their length distribution is very nearly the same as that expected at tempertures much higher than the temperatures at which those organisms currently live. With this assumption the analysis of the data from smokers does not require results from the kinetic models of the dynamics associated with covalent bond scission and ligation which we used in life2 and earlier papers to analyze laboratory quench experiments because the very high temperatures of the fluid before quench can be assumed to have achieved thermal equilibration of the polypeptide lengths while there can only be negligble peptide bond changes after quench. The main difference between the state before the quench and after it is that the numbers of polymers of each length is assumed to be the same before and after quench but the rate of scission and ligation is different and much slower in the cold state after quench. Thus the main analytical problem in analyzing the oceanographic data is to formulate a description of the equilibrium distribution of polymer lengths in the case that the concentrations of available monomers in the medium in which the chemistry is taking place are not all the same. II Equilibrium with variable available concentrations We briefly review our earlier analysis and how it has been modified here: As in quench , wynveen , conditions , life2 and elsewhere kauffman , others , we represent biopolymers as strings of monomers labelled by type with a total number of types b . In dynamic simulations, the polymers undergo scission and ligation. However, following the arguments in life2 we assume that in the analysis of the oceanographic data we can forego dynamic simulation and consider that the equilibrium distribution in the hot fluid before quench is retained in the cold fluid after quench as the fluid passes quickly into the cold water near the ocean floor. As in all our previous reports except intoy , we assume here that the system is ’well mixed’ and no effects of spatial diffusion are considered. We assign to any ’polymer’ ( string) of length L an energy -(L-1)\Delta where \Delta is a real number which is the bonding energy between two monomers. The ’bonding energies’ determine the thermodynamic driving force for bond formation