Self-assembled clusters of mutually repelling particles in confinement

P. D. S. de Lima, R. De La Cour, K. Gaff, J. M. de Araújo, S. J. Cox, M. S. Ferreira, S. Hutzler · 2025

Read Self-assembled clusters of mutually repelling particles in confinement by P. D. S. de Lima, R. De La Cour, K. Gaff, J. M. de Araújo, S. J. Cox, M. S. Ferreira, S. Hutzler (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-19772.txt.

Introduction

De Lima and six co-authors show, in 2025 work, that particles which shove each other away sort into the same shapes when penned, no matter how unlike their shove laws are. Sims and bench tests agree: tune the ratio of shove to pen strength, and one set shape comes out for long- and short-range shoves alike.

The trick holds in round pens, and stays as the pen is squeezed step by step from a disc to a line. Shape can thus be dialled by force, not by stuff. The team sees a route to built clusters with set jobs, from light craft to drug craft.

Catalog record

CREATORP. D. S. de Lima, R. De La Cour, K. Gaff, J. M. de Araújo, S. J. Cox, M. S. Ferreira, S. Hutzler
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-19772

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Self-assembled clusters of mutually repelling particles in confinement P. D. S. de Lima, R. De La Cour, K. Gaff, J. M. de Araújo, S. J. Cox, M. S. Ferreira, S. Hutzler Abstract Mutually repelling particles form spontaneously ordered clusters when forced into confinement. The clusters may adopt similar spatial arrangements even if the underlying particle interactions are contrastingly different. Here we demonstrate with both simulations and experiments that it is possible to induce particles of very different types to self-assemble into the same ordered geometric structure by simply regulating the ratio between the repulsion and confining forces. This is the case for both long- and short-ranged potentials. This property is initially explored in systems with two-dimensional (2D) circular symmetry and subsequently demonstrated to be valid throughout the transition to one-dimensional (1D) structures through continuous elliptical deformations of the confining field. We argue that this feature can be utilized to manipulate the spatial structure of confined particles, thereby paving the way for the design of clusters with specific functionalities. I Introduction Understanding the mechanisms that govern the formation and evolution of particle clusters is of fundamental interest in scientific areas as diverse as statistical physics Agarwal et al. 2019 ; Santra et al. 2022 , condensed matter physics Saado et al. 2002 ; Yamilov and Cao 2003 ; Kuznetsov 2018 , and astrophysics, to name a few. The composing particles may be magnetic Snezhko et al. 2009 ; Carstensen et al. 2015 ; Kuznetsov 2018 ; de Lima et al. 2024 and/or ionic Partner et al. 2013 , thermally and/or optically active Christofi and Stefanou 2018 , and may range in size from the nanometer up to very large scales Theurkauff et al. 2012 ; Koehler et al. 2024 . The breadth of particle types and sizes of these clusters means that they may be controlled through different types of force fields, suggesting diverse applications Sarcletti et al. 2019 ; Gandhi et al. 2020 ; Dorroh et al. 2020 ; Liao et al. 2023 . The coexistence of two competing force fields acting on the particles is what drives their spontaneous clustering: one that traps them within a restricted area of space and a pairwise repulsion that prevents them from coalescing into a high-density region. \epsilon 0 0.44 0.66 0.87 0.95 N=5 hard spheres floating magnets bubbles N=10 hard spheres floating magnets bubbles Table 1: Interacting particles in confinement arrange themselves in similar configurations, despite the very different physical nature of their interactions. The table shows photographs of N=5 and 10 close-packed hard spheres, magnetically active particles in the form of floating dipoles, and soap bubbles. All are confined within ellipses, for five different values of eccentricity, \epsilon=0,0.44,0.66,0.87 and 0.95 . (Details about the respective experimental set-ups are provided in Section III .) Alternative arrangements exist (see Appendix A ); here we show only those of minimal energy, as identified in computer simulations (Section IV ). The hard sphere packings for \epsilon=0 (circular confinement) correspond to conjectured densest circle packings, as obtained from simulations Specht 2025 , also N=5 , \epsilon=0.87 and N=10 , \epsilon=0.66 Fri 2025 . Previous studies of such clusters (sometimes referred to as ‘classical Wigner clusters’ Radzvilavičius and Anisimovas 2011 ) have reported that particles may self-assemble into similar spatial arrangements when their underlying interactions are not too different. Numerical results were obtained for particles placed in a harmonic (circular) confining potential and interacting via a Coulomb potential Bolton and Rössler 1993 ; Bedanov and Peeters 1994 ; Kong et al. 2002 , but also for elliptic confinement, with particles interacting via Coulomb Rancova et al. 2011 or a Yukawa potential Cândido et al. 1998 ; Lai and I 1999 , or with a logarithmic force law Apolinario et al. 2005 . In Ref. Lai and I 1999 , a parameter could be varied to approximate arrangements of hard spheres in confinement; Ref. Specht 2025 is an online database of conjectured optimal sphere packings in circular confinement, obtained computationally, for a large range of sphere numbers. Experimental studies include arrangements of magnetic particles Mayer 1878a ; Mayer 1878b ; Riveros et al. 2004 ; Nemoianu et al. 2022 ; de Lima et al. 2024 or those interacting via a Coulomb potential Saint Jean et al. 2001 ; Saint Jean and Guthmann 2002 . In this article, we argue that the conditions that interaction potentials must obey to generate clusters with the same equilibrium structure might be much less restrictive than previously thought. As a result, it is possible to identify systems that, at first glance, have very little in common with one another and yet display similar geometrical layouts. In fact, here we bring together examples of electrically charged particles, magnetic dipoles, hard spheres, and bubbles in a liquid foam, all under a common framework. We show that a simple model based on the repulsion-confinement ratio can describe cluster formation in widely diverse systems. This suggests a strong degree of universality of self-assembled particle clusters in general, as seen in Table 1 where three of the aforementioned systems display similar geometrical arrangements, even though the nature and the range of the interaction between the parts are totally different. Furthermore, given the expected sensitivity of the spatial arrangement of particles to system dimensionality, we focus on the evolution as particles initially confined to a two-dimensional environment are deformed towards a one-dimensional structure. For simplicity, we constrain the clusters to elliptical geometries, where a circle (of eccentricity \epsilon=0 ) can be continuously transformed into a line as \epsilon\rightarrow 1 . Published results regarding particles in elliptical confinement appear to be limited, motivating our experiments, depicted in Table 1 , and the simulations that follow. Saint Jean and Guthmann performed experiments with electrically charged stainless steel balls placed within a charged elliptic confinement Saint Jean and Guthmann 2002 . The structures they found are consistent with our results, as will be discussed in Section VI . Systematic computational results for particles confined within an ellipse also appear to be limited, due to the much more demanding computation in determining circle-ellipse overlaps. For the hard-sphere problem, Birgin et al. describe a nonlinear optimization procedure which computes dense packings of discs within an ellipse Birgin et al. 2013 . (However, their main interest relates to algorithm efficiency.) Amore et al. Amore et al. 2023 compute the variation in packing density with the shape of the ellipse for a limited range of numbers of particles. The structure of the manuscript is as follows. The next section introduces the model that will guide us throughout the manuscript to describe the equilibrium configurations of the particles in all the clusters. In addition, we demonstrate that under certain conditions it is possible for a cluster to retain its equilibrium configuration even if the interaction between the composing particles is drastically modified. Sections III and IV present a summary of experimental and numerical results, respectively, obtained for a number of different systems. The particle arrangements themselves are discussed in section V . Finally, Section VI addresses the potential impact of our findings and how they can be used in real applications. II Guiding model To illustrate our theoretical argument, we start by considering a confining region of

Read the complete text