“I forgot the formula:” How students can use coherence to reconstruct a (partially) forgotten equation

Katherine Gifford and Gabriel S. Ehrlich, Engin Bumbacher, Eric Kuo · 2025

Read “I forgot the formula:” How students can use coherence to reconstruct a (partially) forgotten equation by Katherine Gifford and Gabriel S. Ehrlich, Engin Bumbacher, Eric Kuo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-19641.txt.

Introduction

Katherine Gifford, Gabriel Ehrlich, Engin Bumbacher, and Eric Kuo wrote this 2025 paper on how physics students rebuild a half forgotten formula. Intro physics trains smooth problem routines, but students often stall mid task. A common stall is a key equation that will not come back in full.

The team studied interviews where students worked on circuit problems aloud. Many noted they had partly forgotten the central equation. Case studies show students fixing the gap by chasing coherence: they chained how quantities depend on each other and matched words to math. The authors argue these repair moments reveal broad goals of physics learning.

Catalog record

CREATORKatherine Gifford and Gabriel S. Ehrlich, Engin Bumbacher, Eric Kuo
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-19641

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

“I forgot the formula:” How students can use coherence to reconstruct a (partially) forgotten equation Preprint: APS/123-QED Katherine Gifford and Gabriel S. Ehrlich, Engin Bumbacher, Eric Kuo Abstract Introductory physics instruction emphasizes fluency with routine problem-solving procedures. However, even when applying these procedures, students frequently encounter challenges. This paper investigates how students navigate such moments when answering qualitative E&M problems in interviews. Students frequently noted they had partially forgotten a key equation on a problem involving RC circuits. We present focal cases that show how coherence-seeking approaches were employed to overcome this problem-solving challenge. In attempts to reconstruct these equations, participants were guided by identifying and chaining qualitative dependencies and seeking coherence between qualitative and mathematical understanding of the physical system. These moments of forgetting and reconstructing equations are a useful site for studying broader physics learning goals. While prior work investigates the use of mathematical sensemaking by examining how students respond to explicit prompts, our cases illustrate how students can spontaneously use mathematical sensemaking strategies. We reflect on these cases to consider how such adaptive reasoning can be a target for instruction and assessment. I Introduction Research into student problem solving in physics has revealed a range of strategies beyond formal derivations that physics students and experts use to leverage their understanding of physical concepts to create, interpret, and check mathematical equations and solutions Hestenes1987 ; Sherin2001 ; GrecaMoreira2002 ; Sherin2006 ; Brewe2008 ; Uhden2012 ; Kuo2013 ; OddenRuss2018 ; Hahn2018 ; Sikorski2018 ; EichenlaubRedish2019 ; GiffordFinkel2020 ; Kuo2020 ; Zhao2021 ; Kuo2023 . Such strategies are categorized as mathematical sensemaking in physics –- the different ways in which alignment between physical conceptual understanding and mathematical equations is leveraged in physics reasoning. Though an important part of disciplinary physics practice, the application of these strategies–- such as dimensional analysis, checking functional dependencies, and limiting case analysis–- is not widely evident in students’ typical coursework. To increase students’ use of these strategies, research commonly employs tasks that explicitly prompt students to create, interpret, or check mathematical expressions to assess these mathematical sensemaking skills ( Sikorski2018 ; Hahn2018 ; lenz2019surprise , e.g.,) . The trade-off of this approach is that it does not reveal how strategies are opportunistically applied and coordinated with other reasoning in the course of problem solving. In a series of interviews where students answered qualitative E&M problems, students commonly noted that they had (partially) forgotten a key equation on one particular problem (The Four Circuits Problem). We illustrate the range of strategies that students turn to after noting that they couldn’t precisely remember a key equation. In particular, we present focal cases that highlight the ways that students leverage coherence between their qualitative and mathematical understanding of a physical system to guide reconstruction of that equation. We explore how mathematical sensemaking relies on coherence in a particular context (between physical concepts and mathematical equations) and thus is a subset of coherence-seeking strategies –- utilizing the inherent connection and consistency of knowledge thagard2007 . These cases illustrate students’ in-situ use of mathematical sensemaking (and coherence-seeking, more broadly) to overcome a problem-solving challenge. We reflect on these cases to consider how such reasoning can be a feasible target for instruction and assessment. II Theoretical Background Connecting conceptual understanding to mathematical equations is core to physics and has been investigated throughout the history of physics education. Early physics education research on problem solving had a focus on (re)producing the accuracy and systematicity of expert solution methods Kuo2023 . Investigations of expert problem solving revealed that identification of the key physical concepts for a problem situation drives experts’ use of mathematics Chi1981 . That is, the physical concepts are pointers that indicate which particular mathematical equations one should use in problem solving. These investigations have led to the development and implementation of physics problem-solving frameworks that scaffold students’ initial physical analysis of the problem situation to guide the subsequent selection and use of mathematical equations Reif1982 ; vanheuvelen1991 ; heller1992 ; huffman1997 ; gaigher2007 ; Docktor2015 ; dufresne1992 ; larkinreif1979 . While this procedural problem-solving framework can increase students’ fluency with routine procedures, this research does not explore adaptive expertise –- the ability to productively modify existing knowledge and procedures for application in new contexts hatano1986 . Flexibility in reasoning makes one’s problem-solving robust against deviations from these routine physics problem-solving procedures. Therefore, moments of forgetting an equation are a useful opportunistic research context for studying students’ adaptive problem solving in physics. What adaptive strategies could students use to reconstruct an equation that was forgotten and cannot be looked up? One could rederive them from first principles. For instance, if one forgets the equation v^{2}=v_{0}^{2}+2a\Delta x , it could be rederived from the definitions of velocity and acceleration or by combining Newton’s Second Law with the Work-Energy Theorem. Similarly, the time constant for RC circuits, \tau=RC , can be rederived by analyzing an RC circuit using Kirchhoff’s Laws in combination with Ohm’s law and the definition of capacitance, Q=CV . While such formal derivations are valuable, they are not the only strategy one could use. There are many ways in which an understanding of physical concepts can be used to constrain the mathematical forms that can describe those physical systems. Sherin Sherin2001 showed how undergraduate physics students could create novel equations to describe physical systems using their knowledge of symbolic forms –- conceptual schemata that are associated with particular equation symbol templates. By understanding physical quantities as being comprised of parts-of-a-whole or competing terms, students constructed equations to match those conceptual schemata without going through a first-principles derivation. For example, to describe the motion of a free-falling object that reaches terminal velocity due to air resistance, students wrote the equation a(t)=-g+\frac{f(v)}{m} to indicate that the acceleration due to gravity is opposed by the acceleration due to a velocity-dependent resistance force f(v) . Here, the conceptual schema of opposing influences was represented by the symbol template \Box-\Box , where each \Box was filled in with a particular expression representing one of the two opposing influences. Investigations into symbolic forms have shown that this mathematical sensemaking strategy is applicable in a range of physics topics RyanSchermerhorn ; riihiluoma2022applying ; Kapodistrias2024 and can be used to explain students’ problem-solving insights Kuo2013 . Another way mathematical sensemaking can support equation reconstruction is through the practice of checking a symbolic answer by matching its properties to the expected physical behavior. Research in this area has investigated student usage and uptake of approaches including dimensional analysis, checking functional dependencies, and limiting case analysis redish2022 ; EichenlaubRedish2019 . Dimensional analysis (or unit analysis) allows one to check that both sides of an equation or terms in a sum have the same dimensions (or units), a requirement for physical equations. Another method involves checking the physical plausibility of the functional dependencies within an equation–- i.e., if X increases, would it make sense for Y to increase, decrease, or stay the same? One can also check that the equation produces the expected outcome for special or limiting cases. Research has investigated how and how often students evaluate their symbolic answers in courses that explicitly teach these mathematical sensemaking strategies Hahn2018 ; Sikorski2018 ; Kuo2020 . Mathematical sensemaking strategies are a

Read the complete text