Assessing the accuracy of the GENIE event generator with electron scattering data: Reduced cross section and nuclear transparency
A. V. Butkevich and S. V. Luchuk · 2025
Read Assessing the accuracy of the GENIE event generator with electron scattering data: Reduced cross section and nuclear transparency by A. V. Butkevich and S. V. Luchuk (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-19355.txt.
Introduction
A V Butkevich and S V Luchuk benchmark the GENIE event generator against electron scattering data in this 2025 paper. GENIE simulates neutrino hits on nuclei for big experiments. Electron scattering data can test the same nuclear models, since the nuclear response is shared. Carbon target data on knocked out protons anchor the test.
Reduced cross sections act like distorted pictures of the nuclear spectral function. Those curves should match between electron and neutrino probes up to charge effects. Persistent mismatches appear at low missing momentum, under 80 units in their data. Generator tuning has missed something in that corner. Neutrino oscillation results depend on such models, so the gap matters beyond one code.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | A. V. Butkevich and S. V. Luchuk |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-19355
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Assessing the accuracy of the GENIE event generator with electron scattering data: Reduced cross section and nuclear transparency A. V. Butkevich and S. V. Luchuk Abstract The reduced cross sections of the semi-exclusive ( l , l ′ p ) (l,l^{\prime}p) lepton scattering process can be identified with distorted nuclear spectral functions. Irrespective of the type of interaction the distorted spectral function is determined mainly by intrinsic properties of the target and the ejected nucleon interaction with residual nucleus. Thus the reduced cross sections of the neutrino and electron scattering on nuclei as functions of nucleon missing momentum and energy are similar up to Coulomb corrections. Here we demonstrate the utility of this approach by benchmarking the GENIE neutrino event generator against a broad set of semi-exclusive electron scattering data for carbon target. We observe persistent disagreements between the generator predictions and data in the range of nucleon missing momenta less than 80 MeV/c. The approach presented in this paper provide a great opportunity to test better the accuracy of nuclear models of quasi-elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering, employed in neutrino event generators. pacs 25.30.-c, 25.30.Bf, 25.30.Pt, 13.15.+g I Introduction The primary physics goal for current NOvA1 ; T2K and future DUNE ; HK2T ; SBN accelerator-based neutrino experiments are measuring the lepton CP violation phase, determining neutrino mass ordering, and testing the three-flavor paradigm. In these experiments to evaluate the oscillation parameters, the probabilities of neutrino oscillations as functions of neutrino energy are measured. The accuracy to which neutrino oscillation parameters can be extracted depends on the ability of experiments to determine the individual energy of detected neutrino. The neutrino beams are not monoenergetic and have broad distributions that range from tens of MeVs to a few GeVs. At the GeV- scale neutrino energies the neutrino can interact with a nucleus through a wide range of reaction channels. These include the charged-current (CC) quasielastic (QE) scattering, two-body meson exchange current (MEC) channels, resonance production and deep inelastic scattering. The incident neutrino energy is reconstructed using kinematic or calorimetric methods. At energy about 1 GeV, where the CCQE scattering is dominant, the incoming neutrino energy can be derived from lepton kinematics alone. Conservation of total energy in neutrino interactions imply that \mbox{\boldmath$\varepsilon$}_{\nu}=\mbox{\boldmath$\varepsilon$}_{l}+\mbox{\boldmath$\varepsilon$}_{h} , where \mbox{\boldmath$\varepsilon$}_{\nu} , \mbox{\boldmath$\varepsilon$}_{l} , and \mbox{\boldmath$\varepsilon$}_{h} are neutrino, leptonic, and hadronic energies, respectively. The total hadronic energy deposit is obtained by summing all the visible energy not associated with lepton. A model dependent fit \mbox{\boldmath$\varepsilon$}_{h}=f(E_{vis}) obtained from simulation is used to relate the visible energy E_{vis} to the estimated total hadronic energy \mbox{\boldmath$\varepsilon$}_{h} . Thus, the calorimetric method relies not only on the visible energy measured in the detector, but also on the models of the neutrino-nucleus interactions that are implemented in neutrino event generators. In addition the neutrino-nucleus scattering model is critical for obtaining background estimates, in analysis aimed at determining the neutrino oscillation parameters. Unfortunately, due to wide range of neutrino energy beams and poor statistics available from current neutrino experiments, it is challenging to provide reliable and consistent predictions for the diversity of processes that can take place in the energy range covered by these neutrino beams. Various contributions to the cross sections can significantly overlap with each other making it difficult to identify, diagnose and remedy shortcomings of nuclear models. Moreover, neutrino scattering measurements are typically reported integrated over a range of energies and angles. Therefore the task to assess the accuracy of the neutrino event generators is more complicated than simply comparing generators predictions to neutrino data. It is necessary to come up with independent validation methods, which would allow specific physical mechanisms to be tested. While electron and neutrino interactions are different at the primary vertex, many underlying physics processes in the nucleus are very similar. From the nuclear point of view the influence of nuclear medium effects such as the nuclear ground state and interaction of the outgoing nucleon with the residual nucleus can be expected to be largely the same for electron and for neutrino-induced processes. It is possible to exploit this similarity and use electron scattering data with precise kinematics and large statistics to test the neutrino energy reconstruction methods and interaction models. Electron and neutrino scattering are strongly linked in theory. Therefore any model of neutrino interactions (vector+axial) should also be able to reproduce electron (vector) interactions. The vector part of the electroweak interaction can be inferred directly from the electron scattering data. A model unable to reproduce electron measurements cannot be expected to provide accurate prediction for neutrino cross sections. Recent years have seen a plethora of analyses of electron-scattering data to test the vector current part of the lepton-nucleus interaction against existing inclusive electron scattering cross sections for different target nuclei. The relativistic distorted wave impulse approximation (RDWIA), initially designed for description of exclusive (e,e^{\prime}p) data Pick ; Udias ; JKelly and then adopted for neutrino reactions was successfully tested against inclusive (e,e^{\prime}) data Gon3 ; BAV7 . The SuSAv2 model exploits the similarities between both interaction types to guide the description of weak scattering process Megias2 ; Megias3 . Neutrino event generators GENIE Ankow ; e4v1 ; CLAS ; Ruso , NuWro NuWro1 ; NuWro2 , ACHILLES ACHI , and NEUT NEUT have been extended to electron scattering and their results were compared with measured inclusive cross sections of electron-nucleus ( eA ) interaction. The further progress in reducing systematic errors in neutrino oscillation experiments requires a more extensive use of measurements of final-states protons. It is needed for neutrino energy reconstruction, because more exclusive final state measurement allows to better estimate the neutrino energy and provide information about multinucleon contribution to the inclusive cross section. Inclusive reactions are relatively insensitive to the details of the final nuclear states. Therefore, rather simple models may yield inclusive and total cross sections that are not very different from cross sections calculated in the most sophisticated models, but cannot make predictions on both leptons and hadrons in the final states. The event generators model final state interactions (FSI) of knocked-out nucleon with residual nucleon using the intranuclear cascade models. These models should be able to reproduce nuclear transparency data from electron scattering. Nuclear transparency is defined as a probability that a knocked-out nucleon leaves the residual nucleus without re-interaction. The nucleon cascade models, implemented in the GENIE Dytman and NuWro NuWro3 event generators were tested against the nuclear transparency data. It was shown that these generators are able to reproduce these data if short-range nucleon-nucleon (NN) correlations in the ground state of the nucleus are taken into account. The semi-exclusive (l,l^{\prime}p) lepton scattering process involves the specific asymptotic states and allows to test more in detail the nuclear model. The reduced cross section, obtained from the measured differential semi-exclusive electron scattering cross section dividing by the kinematic factor and the off-shell electron-proton cross section, can be identified as the distorted spectral function. Thus, irrespective of the type of interaction (electromagnetic or weak) the distorted spectral function is determined mainly by the intrinsic properties of the target and the ejected nucleon interaction with residual nucleus and depends upon the initial and ejectile nucleon’s momenta and angle between them. Microscopic and unfactorized RDWIA was used BAV1 ; BAV2 ;