Strong Correlations, Green’s Function Zeros and Topological Transitions in Orbital-Symmetry-Controlled Chemical Reactions

Ziren Xie, Amir Mirzanejad, Lukas Muechler · 2025

Read Strong Correlations, Green’s Function Zeros and Topological Transitions in Orbital-Symmetry-Controlled Chemical Reactions by Ziren Xie, Amir Mirzanejad, Lukas Muechler (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-18984.txt.

Introduction

Ziren Xie, Amir Mirzanejad, and Lukas Muechler bring tools from the physics of materials into chemistry, in a 2025 arXiv paper. Some reactions are classed as allowed or forbidden by whether electron orbitals cross as the atoms move. That neat scheme breaks down when electrons push hard on each other, as they do in many real reactions.

The team recasts the scheme with Green's functions, a math tool that tracks how electrons move through a system. In their test case, a ring-closing reaction, forbidden paths show crossings of the tool's zeros, not the peaks the old scheme predicts. They define a counting rule that spots both kinds of crossing. The rule may extend to reactions with no saved symmetry at all.

Catalog record

CREATORZiren Xie, Amir Mirzanejad, Lukas Muechler
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-18984

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Strong Correlations, Green’s Function Zeros and Topological Transitions in Orbital-Symmetry-Controlled Chemical Reactions Ziren Xie, Amir Mirzanejad, Lukas Muechler Abstract We integrate concepts from topological band theory and strong-correlation physics with the principle of orbital symmetry conservation, which characterizes reactions as symmetry allowed or forbidden based on whether molecular orbitals cross along the reaction coordinate. Using a 4 ​ π 4\pi electrocyclization as an example, we show how Green’s functions generalize the concepts of symmetry allowed and symmetry forbidden reactions even in the presence of strong multi-reference correlations. We demonstrate how symmetry forbidden reactions are characterized by strong multi-reference correlations, resulting in crossings of Green’s function zeros rather than poles as MO-theory would predict. Taking into account Green’s functions zeros, a topological invariant is introduced that captures symmetry protected crossings of poles or zeros. We discuss the effects of symmetry breaking and outline generalizations of our approach to reactions without any conserved spatial symmetries along the reaction path. Our work lays the groundwork for systematic application of modern topological methods to chemical reactions and can be generalized to reactions involving different spin states or to excited states. I Introduction Recent developments in topological band theory have systematically classified all possible band structures in crystalline materials Chiu et al. 2016 ; Bradlyn et al. 2017 ; Watanabe et al. 2018 ; Po et al. 2017 ; Kruthoff et al. ; Vergniory et al. a ; Zhang et al. ; Vergniory et al. b . The classification is achieved via topological invariants, non-local order parameters calculated from the electronic wavefunctions, first made rigorous by Berry Berry . Invariants predict the existence of topological surface or interface states that can be measured in experiment and predicted with high accuracy from first principles calculations Bansil et al. ; Manna et al. ; Xiao and Yan ; Lv et al. ; Kumar et al. . Further, they facilitate the classification of crossings or avoided crossings of energy levels, which can occur at isolated points, lines or surfaces in reciprocal space. A classification through invariants is inherently resistant to small changes and perturbations of the system. A quantum phase transition is required to change them, requiring significant changes to system parameters. Materials that have the same topological invariant belong to the same universality class, meaning that they possess the same topological states even if they are chemically distinct. Recent work has highlighted how spatial symmetries enrich this classification Chiu and Schnyder 2014 ; Bradlyn et al. 2016 ; Chiu et al. 2016 ; Kruthoff et al. ; Po et al. 2017 ; Song et al. ; Po ; Wieder et al. Computed from the symmetry properties of wavefunctions, symmetry indicators allow for efficient and inexpensive calculation of topological invariants and enable high-throughput exploration of material databases Zhang et al. ; Tang et al. ; Vergniory et al. a ; Vergniory et al. b . Figure 1: Summary of main results of this paper Crossings as well as avoided crossings of energy levels are of fundamental importance to our understanding of chemical reactions. Topological concepts such as Berry phases and extensions have been applied to molecules Faure and Zhilinskii 2000 ; Zhilinskií 2001 ; Faure and Zhilinskii 2002 ; Muechler et al. 2014 ; Dhont et al. 2017 ; Wu et al. 2020 ; Wu and Subotnik 2021 ; Bian et al. 2022 ; Culpitt et al. 2021 ; Culpitt et al. 2024 ; Morreale and Persico 2024 , and are vital in understanding nuclear dynamics close to conical intersections, which have recently been revisited in the framework of exact factorization methods Ribeiro and Yuen-Zhou 2018 ; Ryabinkin et al. 2017 ; Ibele et al. 2023 ; Requist et al. 2016 ; Requist et al. 2017 ; Valahu et al. 2023 . The interplay of energy level crossings and symmetries on the other hand is well established in symmetry controlled reactions such as those described by the Woodward-Hoffmann rules (WHR) and generalizations thereof Woodward and Hoffmann 1969 ; Waschewsky et al. 1994 ; Butler 1998 ; Muechler 2020 ; Zhou et al. 2024 ; Ong et al. 2009 ; Kochhar et al. 2010 ; Brown et al. 2021 . Reactions are classified as allowed when no crossing of molecular orbitals (MOs) occur along the reaction coordinate. Reactions with a crossing between occupied and unoccupied MOs are classified as forbidden . This apparent connection between energy level crossings and symmetries suggests symmetry controlled reactions as an ideal platform to study the application of modern topological methods in reaction chemistry. However, the application of topological concepts to these reactions is not straightforward. A principal limitation is that topological band theory is typically formulated within a single-electron or single-reference framework. While molecules close to their equilibrium geometry can often be described by single-reference methods, taking into account electron-electron correlations explicitly is especially important for chemical reactions when bonds are broken and formed Boguslawski et al. 2013 ; Krylov 2017 ; Park et al. 2020 ; Zhou et al. 2024 . In particular, when HOMO and LUMO are degenerate or near-degenerate, as in symmetry forbidden reactions, electronic interactions become significant, and single-electron approximations break down. The limitations of the single-electron picture in the presence of strong static correlations present a challenge for a topological analysis. For example, in symmetry forbidden reactions, MO theory predicts a crossing of occupied and unoccupied MOs with different irreducible representations (Fig. 1 ). When electron correlation is explicitly included using multi-reference methods, the MO crossing is no longer well-defined Longuet-Higgins and Abrahamson 1965 ; Goddard 1972 ; Ross et al. 1979 . Instead, there is an avoided crossing between the low-lying many-electron singlet states ( S_{0},S_{1},S_{2} ). While this accurately describes the energetics, forbidden reactions are no longer distinguished from allowed reactions, as both feature a gapped ground-state along the reaction coordinate. To address this limitation and facilitate the application of topological tools to a wider range of chemical systems, we introduce a theoretical framework based on Green’s functions developed recently for strongly correlated crystalline materials. This method is capable of describing both weakly and strongly correlated electronic systems on a consistent basis, and allows to diagnose the crossings of molecular orbitals even when strong multi-reference correlations are present. II Green’s functions and multi-reference correlations Green’s functions are central objects in electronic structure theory Cederbaum and Domcke 1977 ; Schirmer et al. 1983 ; von Niessen et al. 1984 ; Rusakov and Zgid 2016 ; Phillips et al. 2015 ; Jacquemin et al. 2017 ; Van Setten et al. 2015 ; Golze et al. 2019 ; van Setten et al. 2013 ; Laughon et al. 2022 ; Phillips and Zgid 2014 , the theory of strongly correlated electrons Luttinger 1960 ; Georges et al. 1996 ; Onida et al. 2002 ; Zgid and Chan 2011 ; Lin et al. 2011 ; Shee and Zgid 2019 ; Mahan 2010 and topological condensed matter physics Gurarie 2011 ; Slager et al. 2015 ; Seki and Yunoki 2017 ; Lessnich et al. 2021 ; Iraola et al. 2021 ; Misawa and Yamaji 2022 ; Soldini et al. 2023 ; Peralta Gavensky et al. 2023 ; Queiroz et al. 2024 . The Green’s Function describes single particle properties of molecules, such

Read the complete text