The OATMEAL Survey. II. The 3D spin-orbit obliquity of an eccentric transiting brown dwarf in the Ruprecht 147 open cluster

Theron W. Carmichael, Steven Giacalone, Noah Vowell, Daniel Huber, Xian-Yu Wang, Malik Bossett, Luke Handley, Aaron Householder, Yaguang Li, Benjamin J. Fulton, Andrew Howard, Howard Isaacson, Samuel Halverson, Arpita Roy · 2025

Read The OATMEAL Survey. II. The 3D spin-orbit obliquity of an eccentric transiting brown dwarf in the Ruprecht 147 open cluster by Theron W. Carmichael, Steven Giacalone, Noah Vowell, Daniel Huber, Xian-Yu Wang, Malik Bossett, Luke Handley, Aaron Householder, Yaguang Li, Benjamin J. Fulton, Andrew Howard, Howard Isaacson, Samuel Halverson, Arpita Roy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-18971.txt.

Introduction

Theron Carmichael and co-authors measure the tilt between a brown dwarf's orbit and its star's spin, in a paper from 2025. The system sits in an open star cluster that is close to three billion years old. The brown dwarf crosses in front of its host star, which lets observers probe the geometry of the pair.

Precise speed measures taken during a crossing show the crossing body moving in the same sense as the star's spin. The flat on view tilt came out near zero, and the full three dimensional tilt was modest as well. That near alignment hints that the dwarf formed in a calm disk rather than being flung into place. The study is part of a survey that maps such tilts for heavy planets and low mass stars.

Catalog record

CREATORTheron W. Carmichael, Steven Giacalone, Noah Vowell, Daniel Huber, Xian-Yu Wang, Malik Bossett, Luke Handley, Aaron Householder, Yaguang Li, Benjamin J. Fulton, Andrew Howard, Howard Isaacson, Samuel Halverson, Arpita Roy
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-18971

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The OATMEAL Survey. II. The 3D spin-orbit obliquity of an eccentric transiting brown dwarf in the Ruprecht 147 open cluster Theron W. Carmichael, Steven Giacalone, Noah Vowell, Daniel Huber, Xian-Yu Wang, Malik Bossett, Luke Handley, Aaron Householder, Yaguang Li, Benjamin J. Fulton, Andrew Howard, Howard Isaacson, Samuel Halverson, Arpita Roy Abstract We present new analysis of the CWW 89 system as part of the Orbital Architectures of Transiting Massive Exoplanets And Low-mass stars (OATMEAL) survey. The CWW 89 system is a member of the 2.8 Gyr old Ruprecht 147 (NGC 6774) cluster and features two stars, CWW 89A (EPIC 219388192) and CWW 89B, with the primary hosting a transiting brown dwarf. We use in-transit, highly precise radial velocity measurements with the Keck Planet Finder (KPF) to characterize the Rossiter-McLaughlin (RM) effect and measure the projected spin-orbit obliquity | λ | = 1.4 ± 2.5 ∘ |\lambda|=1.4\pm 2.5^{\circ} and the full 3D spin-orbit obliquity of the brown dwarf to be ψ = 15.1 − 10.9 + 15.0 ∘ \psi=15.1^{+15.0^{\circ}}_{-10.9} . This value of λ \lambda implies that the brown dwarf’s orbit is prograde and well-aligned with the equator of the host star, continuing the trend of transiting brown dwarfs showing a preference for alignment ( λ ≈ 0 ∘ \lambda\approx 0^{\circ} ) regardless of the stellar effective temperature. We find that this contrast with the transiting giant planet population, whose spin-orbit alignments depend on host T eff T_{\rm eff} , shows an increasingly clear distinction in the formation and orbital migration mechanisms between transiting giant planets and transiting brown dwarfs like CWW 89Ab. For this system in particular, we find it plausible that the brown dwarf may have undergone coplanar high-eccentricity migration influence by CWW 89B. I Introduction Our understanding of the tidal realignment of close-in planetary orbits around main sequence stars has substantially improved since the first measurements of spin-orbit obliquities were made for gas giant planets ( D. Queloz et al. 2000a ; J. N. Winn et al. 2005 ; A. H. M. J. Triaud et al. 2010 ; T. Hirano et al. 2011 ; S. Albrecht et al. 2012 ) . Here, we define “spin-orbit obliquity” to mean the angle between the rotation axis of the primary star and the orbital axis of the companion(s). With recent works by J. Zak et al. 2024 ; J. I. Espinoza-Retamal et al. 2024 ; E. Knudstrup et al. 2024 ; X.-Y. Wang et al. 2024 ; J. Zhang et al. 2025 , the number of obliquity measurements made for giant planets now numbers in the dozens, with a wide range of aligned to misaligned systems. A relatively coherent story is emerging for the orbital evolution of these systems and it is centered on a general theory of the interior structures of stars that host giant planets. As main sequence stars that are more massive than the Sun evolve, expand in radius, and decrease in effective temperature, their outer envelopes transition from being predominantly radiative to convective. R. P. Kraft 1967 first established a temperature threshold at which this change occurs, now known as the Kraft Break ( T_{\rm eff}=6250 K). From this, a trend in the projected spin-orbit alignments, or obliquities \lambda , for giant planets around the Kraft Break has emerged: Stars hotter than the Kraft Break show a population of planets with no preferential value of \lambda whereas stars cooler than the Kraft Break yield a companion planet population with preferentially aligned obliquities ( \lambda=0^{\circ} ) ( J. N. Winn et al. 2010 ; M. Rice et al. 2022 ; J. Rusznak et al. 2024 , e.g.) . Recent observations of subgiant stars that have crossed the Kraft break during their evolution confirmed that alignments of giant planets are strongly tied to presence of convective envelopes ( N. Saunders et al. 2024 , e.g.) . The more massive siblings to giant planets, brown dwarfs (BDs), have recently seen a boom in their known transiting population in large part thanks to the TESS mission ( G. R. Ricker et al. 2015 ) and efforts from ground-based facilities like the Next Generation Transit Survey (NGTS) ( P. J. Wheatley et al. 2018 ) . Recent works from ( B. A. Henderson et al. 2024a ; N. Vowell et al. 2025 ; A. Larsen et al. 2025 , and references therein) show more than 50 known transiting brown dwarfs and like with their giant planet siblings, astronomers have pursued measurements of their spin-orbit obliquities for insight into their orbital histories. However, in contrast to the dozens spin-orbit alignments measured for transiting giant planets, only 9 such measurements exist for transiting BDs. Every measurement of \lambda for transiting BDs thus far indicates a preference for an aligned orbit ( A. H. M. J. Triaud et al. 2009 ; R. J. Siverd et al. 2012 ; A. H. M. J. Triaud et al. 2013 ; G. Zhou et al. 2019 ; S. Giacalone et al. 2024 ; T. Ferreira dos Santos et al. 2024 ; M. Brady et al. 2025 ; L. Doyle et al. 2025 ; C. M. Johns-Krull et al. 2008 ) . One widely-used technique to measure \lambda for transiting system is the Rossiter-McLaughlin (RM) Effect ( D. Queloz et al. 2000b ; A. H. M. J. Triaud 2018 ) . This requires taking spectra of the host star during a transit to observe the radial velocity (RV) anomaly induced by the transiting companion blocking varying amounts of red- or blue-shifted light depending on the orbital configuration relative to the orientation of the host star’s spin axis. The RM effect alone can only offer an estimate of the projected spin-orbit alignment \lambda , but in some cases, the system supplies all of the ingredients needed to determine the full 3D obliquity \psi , namely both the orbital inclination of the transiting companion and the stellar spin axis angle, which is determined from combining the projected rotational velocity of the star with its rotation period (often observed via photometric modulations in its light curve). Here we present an RM measurement of \lambda for the transiting BD CWW 89Ab. CWW 89Ab’s environment distinguishes it from other BD systems with measured obliquities. The CWW 89 system receives its name from J. L. Curtis et al. 2013a , who catalog it and over 100 other stars as members of the Ruprecht 147 open cluster. This makes CWW 89Ab one of four known transiting BDs that reside in a stellar association or cluster (the other three being AD 3116b in Praesepe, RIK 72b in Upper Scorpius, and HIP 330609b in MELANGE 6 from E. Gillen et al. 2017 , T. J. David et al. 2019 , and N. Vowell et al. 2023 respectively), and the oldest BD to reside in such an environment at 2.76\pm 0.61 Gyr ( G. Torres et al. 2018 ) . CWW 89 consists of a primary G-dwarf star, CWW 89A, and a secondary M-dwarf, CWW 89B, orbiting at a 24.9 AU (81 mas) projected separation ( T. G. Beatty et al. 2018 ) . A handful of transiting BD systems comprise 3 or more objects, typically a primary star, a transiting BD companion, and a more distant outer stellar companion,

Read the complete text