Novel Phases of a Baryon-Dense QCD-like Theory
Yang Bai, Carlos Henrique de Lima, Daniel Stolarski · 2025
Read Novel Phases of a Baryon-Dense QCD-like Theory by Yang Bai, Carlos Henrique de Lima, Daniel Stolarski (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-18964.txt.
Introduction
What phases does strongly interacting matter take when it is packed dense with baryons? Yang Bai, Carlos Henrique de Lima, and Daniel Stolarski probe that question in a stand-in theory where the maths can be finished. Their 2025 paper uses a supersymmetric cousin of QCD, softened by a known breaking pattern, with three colours and four flavours.
As the baryon chemical potential rises, the theory passes through novel phases, including ones where baryon number or parity breaks on its own. Some borders between phases are sharp first-order jumps and others smooth second-order ones. The authors offer the map as a hint for real QCD at middling densities, the regime that neutron star cores may occupy and that experiments cannot yet reach.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yang Bai, Carlos Henrique de Lima, Daniel Stolarski |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-18964
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Novel Phases of a Baryon-Dense QCD-like Theory Yang Bai, Carlos Henrique de Lima, Daniel Stolarski Abstract We investigate the phases of a strongly coupled QCD-like theory at finite baryon chemical potential using s-confining supersymmetric QCD deformed by anomaly-mediated supersymmetry breaking. Focusing on the case of three colors and four flavors, we identify novel phases including spontaneous breaking of baryon number and/or parity. Both first-order and second-order phase transitions are observed as the baryon chemical potential is varied. These findings may offer insights into possible phases of real QCD at intermediate baryon densities. I Introduction Understanding quantum chromodynamics (QCD) at high baryon densities is a longstanding goal of high energy physics Rajagopal and Wilczek 2000 ; Alford 2001 . The inherent strong dynamics of QCD make the analysis of the phase diagram only controlled in the high-energy regime and consequently high densities. In this regime, a plethora of symmetry breaking patterns appear, depending on the number of flavors, such as color superconductivity, color-flavor locking, and dynamical breaking of baryon number Schäfer 2000 ; Alford et al. 2001 . At lower densities, extracting the phase diagram is significantly more challenging and usually relies on lattice Vovchenko et al. 2019 ; D’Elia and Lombardo 2003 ; de Forcrand and Kratochvila 2006 or phenomenological models Baym et al. 2018 ; Wu et al. 2021 . More importantly, obtaining results with massless fermions is intrinsically challenging for these approaches. In this work, we build upon recent results of deforming Supersymmetric QCD (SQCD) with anomaly mediated supersymmetry breaking (AMSB) to obtain the phase diagram of QCD with four massless flavors for energies below the confinement scale. SQCD provides a calculable framework to study strongly coupled QCD-like theories. Exact results in SQCD elucidate low-energy descriptions for arbitrary numbers of colors, N_{c} , and fundamental flavors, N_{f} , making it a powerful tool for exploring non-perturbative results in strongly coupled quantum field theory Seiberg 1994 ; Seiberg 1995 . The theory with N_{f}=N_{c}+1 is “s-confining”, meaning that the low energy theory can be described in terms of gauge invariant composites of baryons and mesons, exhibiting confinement but without chiral symmetry breaking at the origin of the moduli space. This makes it particularly closely related to its non-supersymmetric counterpart, QCD, which is also described at low energy by baryons and mesons. Coupling SQCD to a non-zero baryon chemical potential \mu_{B} makes the theory unstable Harnik et al. 2004 . The finite baryon density induces a tachyonic direction in the scalar potential, causing the theory to flow to a non-perturbative regime. This can be stabilized by adding masses to the theory, either a supersymmetric mass or a soft supersymmetry (SUSY) breaking mass. Even with those masses, the theory is still unstable for sufficiently large \mu_{B} . In this work, we explore SQCD coupled to anomaly mediated SUSY breaking Randall and Sundrum 1999 ; Giudice et al. 1998 ; Pomarol and Rattazzi 1999 ; Jung and Lee 2009 with non-zero baryon chemical potential. Anomaly mediation is extremely useful in analyzing strongly coupled quantum field theories as it is UV insensitive Murayama 2021 , so the soft terms can be calculated precisely in the low energy effective theory with no knowledge of how to map any operator from the UV to the IR. Recent work has explored the dynamics of several SQCD theories coupled to AMSB Murayama 2021 ; Csáki et al. 2022a ; Csáki et al. 2021 ; Bai and Stolarski 2022 ; Luzio and Xu 2022 ; Kondo et al. 2022 ; Csáki et al. 2022b ; de Lima and Stolarski 2023 ; Csáki et al. 2024 ; Leedom et al. 2025 ; Goh et al. 2025 ; Kondo et al. 2025 , including the s-confining regime. We focus specifically on s-confining SQCD coupled to anomaly mediation with a non-zero baryon chemical potential \mu_{B} . This model, particularly with the choice of three colors, closely resembles QCD with four massless quarks, where the additional states decouple as the SUSY breaking parameter is made large. The instabilities of the supersymmetric theory (and also with small SUSY breaking) at finite chemical potential were initially identified in Harnik et al. 2004 using a different soft SUSY breaking. 1 1 1 In principle, any results obtained from deforming SUSY to non-SUSY do not depend on the SUSY breaking scheme. However, since in most cases, the SUSY breaking parameter is not strictly infinite, each SUSY breaking approaches the non-SUSY regime in a different way. At the same time, some methods are more calculable than others for strongly coupled theories. In Harnik et al. 2004 , it was assumed that the symmetry-breaking pattern would remain the same as the given runaway direction. However, this is not necessarily the case since the vacuum becomes dominated by strong dynamics, which are incalculable even with the SUSY machinery. In this work, we highlight a stabilization mechanism that allows us to extract the phase diagram of the QCD-like theory. The stabilization comes from the interplay between strong dynamics and SUSY breaking. In the low energy hadronic phase, we adiabatically turn on a finite baryon chemical potential. The nonzero baryon chemical potential eventually creates a runaway instability, pushing the sbaryon vacuum expectation value (VEV) towards high energy where the theory is described by a quark and gluon phase. When the sbaryon VEV (the order parameter of this transition) starts to approach the confinement scale, higher order terms in the Kähler potential induced by the strong dynamics become important. We show how these operators can stabilize the theory below the confinement scale, keeping the theory in the hadron phase under perturbative control. With the theory stabilized, we can explore the vacuum structure as a function of the baryon chemical potential \mu_{B} as well as the size of the SUSY breaking. Because SUSY breaking is communicated via anomaly mediation, once the anomaly mediation scale m_{3/2} is specified, all other SUSY breaking soft terms are calculable. There are still low energy parameters in the supersymmetric theory that are not predicted, and we vary their values using a few different schemes. We find several possible vacua for this theory, some of which, as far as we know, are novel for the QCD literature. The Lagrangian of the supersymmetric theory contains a SU(4)_{L}\times SU(4)\times U(1)_{B}\times U(1)_{R} global symmetry. When coupled to AMSB, the U(1)_{R} is explicitly broken. The vacua we identify contain the following remnant global symmetries: • SU(4)_{L}\times SU(4)_{R}\times U(1)_{B} , • SU(4)_{V}\times U(1)_{B} , • SU(3)_{V}\times U(1)_{\rm res} , • SU(3)_{L/R}\times SU(4)_{R/L}\times U(1)_{\rm res} , • SU(3)_{L}\times SU(3)_{R} . The first two are the standard s-confining and QCD-like vacua, respectively. The others include vacua with spontaneous breaking of baryon number and/or parity, or a preserved left-right symmetry. The last vacuum can exhibit either parity preservation or spontaneous parity breaking, depending on the specific low energy constants. We also explore the order of phase transitions between these vacua, noting the presence of both first and second-order phase transitions depending on the specific value of the low energy constants. As we can access the dynamics of the hadronic phase in a controllable way, the symmetry breaking patterns highlighted in this work could be explored in an analogous nuclear system. The more immediate parallel would be the