Local classical correlations between physical electrons in the Hubbard model
Gabriele Bellomia, Adriano Amaricci, Massimo Capone · 2025
Read Local classical correlations between physical electrons in the Hubbard model by Gabriele Bellomia, Adriano Amaricci, Massimo Capone (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-18709.txt.
Introduction
Gabriele Bellomia and co-authors prove that local electron correlations in Hubbard systems are purely classical in a 2025 paper. The Hubbard model is the workhorse for strongly interacting electrons on a lattice. A measure called local nonfreeness gauges how correlated two electrons at one site truly are.
The team shows this measure equals the mutual information between the site's natural spin orbitals. From that bridge they prove a general theorem: when a Hubbard-type model conserves electron counts per orbital and spin, the local state splits cleanly in its natural basis. No quantum correlation beyond entanglement hides at the single-site level. Comparing magnetic and nonmagnetic descriptions then shows how strongly distant processes steer these local classical links. The result ties a lab-measurable quantity to deep correlation structure.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gabriele Bellomia, Adriano Amaricci, Massimo Capone |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 28 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-18709
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Local classical correlations between physical electrons in the Hubbard model Gabriele Bellomia, Adriano Amaricci, Massimo Capone Abstract We demonstrate that the local nonfreeness , an unbiased measure of correlation between electrons at a single lattice site, can be computed as the mutual information between local natural spin orbitals. Using this concept, we prove that local electron correlations in the Hubbard model are fully classical: in the natural basis the local reduced density matrix is separable and no quantum correlations beyond entanglement are present. Finally, we compare different theoretical descriptions of magnetic and nonmagnetic states, showing that local classical correlations are drastically influenced by nonlocal processes. Our results confirm the relation between local classical correlations within an open system and the nonlocal correlations with its quantum environment. Introduction The concept of strongly correlated electrons is widely used to identify a broad class of systems that display a variety of phases and regimes arising from the electron-electron interactions. Given their rich and tunable phenomenology, strongly correlated electron systems have been identified as promising platforms for quantum technologies, which have assumed a central role in the second quantum revolution. However, a quantitative measure of strong particle correlations that can differentiate the quantum and classical contributions is still elusive, and different estimates can be used in different frameworks. Some of these estimates are not uniquely defined as one can use different reference states or orbital bases. For instance, in variational methods like density-functional theory or quantum Monte Carlo, the correlation energy (energy difference with respect to a Slater determinant) is a natural candidate Wigner 1934 ; Parr and Yang 1995 ; Nekovee et al. 2001 ; Quintanilla and Hooley 2009 . whereas configuration interaction schemes naturally ascribe correlations to the number of necessary Slater determinants Mejuto-Zaera et al. 2019 ; Werner et al. 2023 ; Ganoe and Shee 2024 . In diagrammatic methods one can define the functional distance between the self-energy and/or two-particle vertex and their uncorrelated mean-field (Hartree-Fock) counterparts Amaricci et al. 2015 ; Nowadnick et al. 2015 ; Dong et al. 2022 ; Chalupa et al. 2018 ; Yu et al. 2024 . Finally tensor network methods rely on the notion of bond dimension Cirac et al. 2021 ; Carisch and Zilberberg 2023 . The latter is deeply rooted in the framework of quantum information theory in Fock space, which we will refer to as orbital information theory in the following, as it is concerned with correlations and entanglement between (groups of) single-particle states (orbitals), rather than correlations between physical particles Amico et al. 2008 ; Laflorencie 2016 ; Henderson and Vedral 2001 ; Bañuls et al. 2007 ; Ding et al. 2022 . Building on ideas recently introduced in different communities Bellomia 2024 ; Aliverti-Piuri et al. 2024 , in this work we propose an unbiased measure of the correlations contained in a single electronic orbital (or intra-orbital correlations) as the mutual information between the two natural spin orbitals (up and down), i.e. the uniquely defined bipartition of the single-orbital density matrix into eigenstates of the single-electron density matrix. We start by showing that, for a state that conserves the total charge and magnetization 1 1 1 More in general, for a multi-band state we require the charge and magnetization in each band to be conserved independently , all local intra-orbital correlations are effectively classical , as neither entanglement Henderson and Vedral 2001 ; Vedral 2002 ; Nielsen and Chuang 2012 ; Peres 1996 ; Horodecki 1997 ; Horodecki et al. 2009 ; Amico et al. 2008 ; Laflorencie 2016 ; Gühne and Tóth 2009 ; Plenio and Virmani 2007 nor quantum discord Ollivier and Zurek 2001 ; Luo 2008 ; Dakić et al. 2010 ; Modi et al. 2010 ; Zurek 2003 ; Horodecki et al. 2005 between natural spin orbitals is contained in the local Reduced Density Matrix (RDM). Then we prove that our measure of local classical correlations vanishes for any Hartree-Fock state and ultimately corresponds to the local nonfreeness , a well-known quantitative measure of correlations between physical electrons Gottlieb and Mauser 2005 ; Gottlieb and Mauser 2007 ; Held and Mauser 2013 ; Byczuk et al. 2012 . We follow this perspective to reanalyze paramagnetic (PM) and antiferromagnetic (AFM) solutions of the half-filled single-band Hubbard model on the square and honeycomb lattices. Comparing local embedding methods with numerically exact approaches formulated on the original lattice, we show that the classical intra-orbital correlations capture the physics of strong correlations in an unbiased way and, remarkably, they are sensitive also to nonlocal quantum effects Zurek 2003 ; Artiaco et al. 2025 . Local spin-orbital correlations Let us consider a lattice model of itinerant spin- \frac{1}{2} fermions, in which the total charge and magnetization are conserved, as realized in the single-band Hubbard model Hubbard 1963 . In virtue of the abelian nature of such symmetries, we can write the RDM describing a single orbital on site i so as to commute with the local charge and magnetization. As a result the RDM describing a single local orbital takes the following diagonal form Su et al. 2013 ; Walsh et al. 2019 ; Walsh et al. 2020 ; Walsh et al. 2021 ; Roósz et al. 2023 : \rho_{i}=\sum_{\ell=\varnothing,\uparrow,\downarrow,\uparrow\downarrow}p_{\ell}\outerproduct{\ell}{\ell}, (1) where the p_{\ell} coefficients define a classical probability distribution for the four local states \ket{\varnothing}=\ket{0}\otimes\ket{0} , \ket{\up}=\ket{1}\otimes\ket{0} , \ket{\dw}=\ket{0}\otimes\ket{1} and \ket{\up\dw}=\ket{1}\otimes\ket{1} , expressed in the number occupation basis \ket{n_\up}\otimes\ket{n_\dw} of any arbitrary spin projection, e.g. the S_{z} basis 2 2 2 In the case of a lowered spin symmetry, such as for anisotropic magnetic states, the natural spin orbitals will be uniquely defined as the eigenstates of the single-electron density matrix \langle c^{\dagger}_{i,\sigma}c_{j,\sigma^{\prime}}\rangle . We can explicitly express \rho_{i} in terms of the local doping fraction, magnetization and double occupancy, respectively \delta_{i}=1-\expectationvalue{n_{i,\up}}-\expectationvalue{n_{i,\dw}} , \mathcal{m}_{i}=\expectationvalue{n_{i,\up}}-\expectationvalue{n_{i,\dw}} and \mathcal{D}_{i}=\expectationvalue{n_{i,\up} n_{i,\dw}} : \rho_{i}=\mathrm{diag}\!\left(\delta_{i}\!+\!\mathcal{D}_{i},\frac{1\!-\!\delta_{i}\!+\!\mathcal{m}_{i}}{2}\!-\!\mathcal{D}_{i},\frac{1\!-\!\delta_{i}\!-\!\mathcal{m}_{i}}{2}\!-\!\mathcal{D}_{i},\mathcal{D}_{i}\right)\!. (2) Since Eq. ( 1 ) describes a classical mixture of product states, hence a separable state with respect to the bipartition into the two spin orbitals, these latter are not entangled for any value of the parameters Nielsen and Chuang 2012 ; Peres 1996 ; Horodecki 1997 ; Horodecki et al. 2009 . Furthermore, the diagonal structure of Eq. ( 1 ) in the natural basis guarantees that all bipartite correlations between the two spin orbitals are only due to the probability distribution \{p_{\ell}\} . Hence they should be considered classical as there is no quantum discord Ollivier and Zurek 2001 ; Luo 2008 ; Dakić et al. 2010 ; Modi et al. 2010 ; Zurek 2003 ; Horodecki et al. 2005 . Hence, local classical correlations are quantified by the intra-orbital mutual information between the selected local spin orbitals Bellomia 2024 ( i.e. between the \uparrow and \downarrow single-electron states on the same site): I(\,\uparrow\,:\,\downarrow\,)~=~s(\rho_{i,\uparrow})+s(\rho_{i,\downarrow})-s(\rho_{i})\,, (3) where s(\rho)=-\tr\rho\log(\rho) is the von Neumann entropy of a state \rho , and \rho_{i,\uparrow} and \rho_{i,\downarrow} are the two local spin orbital density matrices, defined by the partial traces: \displaystyle\rho_{i,\uparrow}=\tr_{\downarrow}\rho_{i}=\mathrm{diag}\!\left(\frac{1+\delta_{i}-\mathcal{m}_{i}}{2},\frac{1-\delta_{i}+\mathcal{m}_{i}}{2}\right), (4) \displaystyle\rho_{i,\downarrow}=\tr_{\uparrow}\rho_{i}=\mathrm{diag}\!\left(\displaystyle\frac{1+\delta_{i}+\mathcal{m}_{i}}{2},\frac{1-\delta_{i}-\mathcal{m}_{i}}{2}\right). The mutual information I(\,\uparrow\,:\,\downarrow\,) in Eq. ( 3 ) is in fact an upper bound for all correlation functions between the two spin orbitals Wolf et al. 2008 : I(\,\uparrow\,:\,\downarrow\,)\geq\frac{\left(\expectationvalue{\mathcal{O}_\up\otimes\mathcal{O}_\dw}_{\rho_{i}}-\expectationvalue{\mathcal{O}_\up}_{\rho_{i,\uparrow}}\expectationvalue{\mathcal{O}_\dw}_{\rho_{i,\downarrow}}\right)^{2}}{2\norm{\mathcal{O}_\up}^{2}\norm{\mathcal{O}_\dw}^{2}}, (5) for any pair \mathcal{O}_{\uparrow} , \mathcal{O}_{\downarrow} of generic operators