The completeness of the open cluster census towards the Galactic anticentre

Emily L. Hunt, Tristan Cantat-Gaudin, Friedrich Anders, Lorenzo Spina, Lorenzo Cavallo, Alfred Castro-Ginard, Vasily Belokurov, Anthony G. A. Brown, Andrew R. Casey, Ronald Drimmel, Morgan Fouesneau, Sabine Reffert · 2025

Read The completeness of the open cluster census towards the Galactic anticentre by Emily L. Hunt, Tristan Cantat-Gaudin, Friedrich Anders, Lorenzo Spina, Lorenzo Cavallo, Alfred Castro-Ginard, Vasily Belokurov, Anthony G. A. Brown, Andrew R. Casey, Ronald Drimmel, Morgan Fouesneau, Sabine Reffert (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-18708.txt.

Introduction

Emily Hunt and eleven co-authors measure how many star clusters the Gaia telescope's census is missing toward the galaxy's anticentre, in this 2025 paper. Open clusters trace the Milky Way's structure, but counts mean little without knowing the census's blind spots. The outer galaxy is the test case, where old and young clusters spread out differently.

The team built fake clusters, folded in Gaia's limits and measurement errors, hid the fakes in real data, and tried to find them again blindly. Mass, dust extinction, and distance governed whether a cluster surfaced; age mattered too, since older clusters shine fainter, while fast sky motion helped. After correcting for all that, old clusters proved nearly three times commoner far from the center than near the Sun, beyond what bias explains. Either young clusters are not forming out there, or migration and gentler destruction stack the outskirts with old ones.

Catalog record

CREATOREmily L. Hunt, Tristan Cantat-Gaudin, Friedrich Anders, Lorenzo Spina, Lorenzo Cavallo, Alfred Castro-Ginard, Vasily Belokurov, Anthony G. A. Brown, Andrew R. Casey, Ronald Drimmel, Morgan Fouesneau, Sabine Reffert
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE82 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-18708

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The completeness of the open cluster census towards the Galactic anticentre Emily L. Hunt, Tristan Cantat-Gaudin, Friedrich Anders, Lorenzo Spina, Lorenzo Cavallo, Alfred Castro-Ginard, Vasily Belokurov, Anthony G. A. Brown, Andrew R. Casey, Ronald Drimmel, Morgan Fouesneau, Sabine Reffert Abstract Context. Open clusters have long been used as tracers of Galactic structure. However, without a selection function to describe the completeness of the cluster census, it is difficult to quantitatively interpret their distribution. Aims. We create a method to empirically determine the selection function of a Galactic cluster catalogue. We test it by investigating the completeness of the cluster census in the outer Milky Way, where old and young clusters exhibit different spatial distributions. Methods. We develop a method to generate realistic mock clusters as a function of their parameters, in addition to accounting for Gaia ’s selection function and astrometric errors. We then inject mock clusters into Gaia DR3 data, and attempt to recover them in a blind search using HDBSCAN. Results. We find that the main parameters influencing cluster detectability are mass, extinction, and distance. Age also plays an important role, making older clusters harder to detect due to their fainter luminosity function. High proper motions also improve detectability. After correcting for these selection effects, we find that old clusters are 2.97 ± 0.11 2.97\pm 0.11 times more common at a Galactocentric radius of 13 kpc than in the solar neighbourhood – despite positive detection biases in their favour, such as hotter orbits or a higher scale height. Conclusions. The larger fraction of older clusters in the outer Galaxy cannot be explained by an observational bias, and must be a physical property of the Milky Way: young outer-disc clusters are not forming in the outer Galaxy, or at least not with sufficient masses to be identified as clusters in Gaia DR3. We predict that in this region, more old clusters than young ones remain to be discovered. The current presence of old, massive outer-disc clusters could be explained by radial heating and migration, or alternatively by a lower cluster destruction rate in the anticentre. 1 Introduction Figure 1: Spatial distribution of high-certainty clusters ( CST > 4) from Hunt & Reffert 2023 . Ages are taken from Cavallo et al. 2024 as they are more accurate for old clusters (see Sect. 2 for discussion). Top left : Histogram of cluster galactocentric radii divided into young ( \log t<8.5 , blue) and old ( \log t>8.5 , red) clusters and with a 200 pc bin width. Bottom left : Distribution of the same young and old clusters but in terms of altitude Z and Galactocentric radius R_{\mathrm{GC}} , assuming R_{\mathrm{GC},\odot} =8.2 kpc. Bottom right : Projection of these clusters in heliocentric Galactic co-ordinates, with the Sun located at ( X , Y )=(0,0). The dotted lines indicate Galactocentric radii from 10 to 18 kpc. The shaded area is the region investigated in this study ( 140^{\circ}\leq\ell\leq 240^{\circ} starting 2 kpc from the Sun) . In both lower panels, the cross indicates the cluster Saurer 1, visible in Gaia data but not recovered in the blind search of Hunt & Reffert 2023 . Star clusters are groups of a dozen to hundreds of thousands of coeval stars, born from the collapse of the same parent molecular cloud ( Portegies Zwart et al. 2010 ) . Stars in a cluster can remain gravitationally bound to their siblings for billions of years. Systematic searches for star clusters were a popular activity in early modern astronomy ( Messier 1781 ; Herschel 1786 ; Herschel 1789 , e.g.) . Since their main parameters (in particular age and distance) can be estimated more reliably than for individual stars, they have long been used as tracers of the structure and overall properties of the Milky Way ( Trumpler 1930 ; Janes & Adler 1982 , e.g.) . Open clusters (OCs) are the most common type of star cluster in the Milky Way, with typical ages no greater than a few hundred million years ( Cantat-Gaudin 2022 ) and masses ranging from less than a hundred to no larger than a few thousand solar masses ( Almeida et al. 2023 ; Hunt & Reffert 2024 ; Almeida et al. 2025 ) . Catalogues of stellar proper motions have enabled the identification of OCs as co-moving groups ( Alessi et al. 2003 ; Kharchenko et al. 2005 ; Froebrich et al. 2007 ) , but we remark that until recently the vast majority of the objects listed in the most widely used cluster databases ( Dias et al. 2002 ; Netopil et al. 2012 ; Kharchenko et al. 2013 ) were discovered as simple spatial overdensities in on-sky positions. The ESA Gaia mission ( Gaia Collaboration et al. 2016 ) has transformed our ability to study stellar populations in the Milky Way ( Brown 2021 ) , and its second ( Gaia Collaboration et al. 2018 ) and third data releases ( Gaia Collaboration et al. 2021b ) have enabled the discovery of thousands of new OCs 1 1 1 We refer the reader to Cantat-Gaudin 2022 and Perren et al. 2023 for in-depth reviews of the Gaia contribution to the cluster census. in the 5D space of positions, proper motions, and parallaxes, in addition to validation with Gaia ’s three-colour photometry ( Castro-Ginard et al. 2018 ; Cantat-Gaudin et al. 2019 ; Castro-Ginard et al. 2020 ; Hunt & Reffert 2023 , e.g.) . While the most recent cluster catalogues feature unprecedented numbers of objects characterised to a high level of precision, we still have a poor understanding of the completeness of the cluster census. It feels intuitive that massive and nearby clusters are easier to detect than small and distant objects. All-sky blind searches performed on the Gaia catalogue are also likely to be biased in favour of clusters with proper motions different to their background field, and to be more efficient at recovering clusters in sparser regions of the sky than in crowded fields. The issue of completeness dropping with distance is often sidestepped in astronomy by restricting studies to a volume within which the authors consider the sample is near 100% complete ( Koposov et al. 2008 ; Kharchenko et al. 2013 ; Hunt & Reffert 2024 , e.g.) . This approach is in general highly sub-optimal ( Rix et al. 2021 ) . Rather than artificially restricting catalogues to create volume-complete samples, we should strive to construct their selection function: a quantitative description of completeness as a function of location and other relevant parameters. A selection function allows one to account for selection effects in the incomplete regime, thus enabling studies of the Milky Way on a much larger scale. Even assuming that catalogues are complete within a certain volume, the selection function is a critical piece of information to extend studies beyond the solar neighbourhood, or to compare the Milky Way to other galaxies in an unbiased way. To our knowledge, the only study attempting to establish a selection function for the cluster census was performed by Anders et al. 2021 for the Gaia DR2 cluster catalogue of Cantat-Gaudin et al. 2020 , which itself exploited a completeness experiment conducted by Castro-Ginard

Read the complete text