Understanding the Theoretical Guarantees of DPM

Yara Schütt, Esfandiar Mohammadi · 2025

Read Understanding the Theoretical Guarantees of DPM by Yara Schütt, Esfandiar Mohammadi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-18685.txt.

Introduction

Schütt and Mohammadi examine in twenty twenty-five what a privacy-preserving clustering method can actually promise. The method splits data into groups while protecting individual privacy, and its designers proved it halts and often picks a good split. The pair ask what those proofs mean for realistic data, where group sizes and scoring weights vary.

Their analysis exposes limits on the smallest usable group size and on the scoring weight. Read through a popular quality score, even a best split can make the measured quality drop, which questions that score itself. They link the method to a separability concept from theory. The authors say the fuller picture helps users set parameters wisely on unknown data.

Catalog record

CREATORYara Schütt, Esfandiar Mohammadi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE118 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-18685

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Understanding the Theoretical Guarantees of DPM Yara Schütt, Esfandiar Mohammadi Abstract In this study, we conducted an in-depth examination of the utility analysis of the differentially private mechanism (DPM). The authors of DPM have already established the probability of a good split being selected and of DPM halting. In this study, we expanded the analysis of the stopping criterion and provided an interpretation of these guarantees in the context of realistic input distributions. Our findings revealed constraints on the minimum cluster size and the metric weight for the scoring function. Furthermore, we introduced an interpretation of the utility of DPM through the lens of the clustering metric, the silhouette score. Our findings indicate that even when an optimal DPM-based split is employed, the silhouette score of the resulting clustering may still decline. This observation calls into question the suitability of the silhouette score as a clustering metric. Finally, we examined the potential of the underlying concept of DPM by linking it to a more theoretical view, that of ( ξ , ρ ) (\xi,\rho) -separability. This extensive analysis of the theoretical guarantees of DPM allows a better understanding of its behaviour for arbitrary inputs. From these guarantees, we can analyse the impact of different hyperparameters and different input data sets, thereby promoting the application of DPM in practice for unknown settings and data sets. 1 Introduction There is recent work that introduces a clustering algorithm that is based on a robust strategy finding smart separators: DPM DPM . We show utility proofs for DPM. Theoretical bounds on the utility characterise the conditions under which an algorithmic result is useful. For sufficiently tight utility bounds, dependencies of hyperparameters and assumptions about the input data can be derived. Thus, when choosing appropriate hyperparameters and understanding the behaviour of an algorithm for different settings, such utility bounds can be of use. A substantial number of research papers employ empirical evaluations and ablation studies to elucidate the utility of algorithms. However, the experimental outcomes are constrained to the data sets that are evaluated and the evaluated combinations of values for the hyperparameters. Experimental evaluations can test some dependencies between hyperparameters and properties of the input, while sufficiently tight theoretical bounds precisely characterise these relations. However, relying on the experimental evaluation alone may result in the omission of potential relations between hyperparameters and inputs, leading to an incomplete characterisation of an algorithm’s behaviour regarding the utility. In this study, we present theoretical bounds for a DP clustering algorithm, DPM, which characterise its utility in diverse settings without assumptions on the input data. By adding assumptions on the settings and the input data, such as that there is always at least one central split or that the data points are drawn from a multiple Gaussian distributions, the utility bounds become more precise. The utility-privacy-tradeoff inherent to differentially private mechanisms is a fundamental aspect of their utility. A high level of privacy inevitably introduces a considerable amount of noise, which in turn reduces the potential for utility. Similarly, a high level of utility necessitates a lower level of noise, thereby only allowing for a smaller degree of privacy to be guaranteed. In Differential Privacy, the privacy parameters, denoted by the symbols \varepsilon and \delta , are used to quantify the privacy guarantees of a mechanism. For instance, in the case of the differentially private mechanism proposed in DPM , the added noise for a fixed privacy budget depends on both the input data set and some hyperparameters. The bounds on the utility of a mechanism depend on the hyperparameters of the mechanism, which also include the privacy parameters. Firstly, we introduce the concept of Differential Privacy, which is employed by state-of-the-art privacy-preserving algorithms. As we analyse the utility guarantees of DPM, we utilise the identical definitions of privacy as in DPM . Prior to presenting the clustering algorithm DPM and the remaining question regarding theoretical analysis, we provide some background on the field of clustering in general. Finally, we discuss pertinent related work. 1.1 Differential Privacy The privacy notion Differential Privacy (DP) is based on the assumption that the input data sets consist of data contributed by different individuals, some of which may be sensitive. Consequently, each individual can potentially influence the behaviour of a mechanism and its output. Despite the necessity of the mechanism to utilise the data from the individuals for optimal performance, the privacy of any individual must be preserved. This necessitates that the output should be robust to small changes (one individual’s data) in the input data set. Consequently, in order to analyse the DP guarantees of a mechanism, it is necessary to determine the largest impact that one individual can have on the output. To determine this impact, we consider neighbouring data sets, which are data sets that only differ by the data of one individual. A data set consists of n d -dimensional data points (individuals) D=\{x_{0},\dots,x_{n-1}\}\in\mathbb{R}^{d\times n} . The conjunction of all possible data sets is the set of all data sets \mathcal{D}=\{D\in\mathbb{R}^{d\times n}|\penalty\ d,n\in\mathbb{N}_{+}\} . Definition 1 (Neighbouring data sets) . Given two data sets D_{0},D_{1}\in\mathcal{D} , we say D_{0} and D_{1} are neighbouring if D_{1}=D_{0}\cup\{x\} or D_{0}=D_{1}\cup\{x\} for a data point x\in\mathbb{R}^{d} . We will denote neighbouring data sets as D_{0}\sim D_{1} . In Differential Privacy, we consider the maximum leakage for a data point, i.e. for all neighbouring data sets, we consider the pair that results in the largest difference in the output of a mechanism. This difference is called the sensitivity of a mechanism. Definition 2 (Sensitivity (Def. 2.2 DPM )) . Given two neighbouring data sets D_{0},D_{1} and some set X . A function f:\mathcal{D}\times X\rightarrow\mathbb{R} has sensitivity \Delta_{f} iff. \Delta_{f}\geq\max_{D_{0}\sim D_{1}}|f(D_{0})-f(D_{1})| . A function f with sensitivity \Delta_{f}\in\mathbb{R} is a \Delta_{f} -bounded query. For all neighbouring data sets, we have to consider the pair that results in the largest difference in the output of a mechanism. The bound of this difference directly gives us the privacy parameters \varepsilon and \delta . Definition 3 ( (\varepsilon,\delta) -DP) . A mechanism M with M:\mathcal{D}\rightarrow A preserves (\varepsilon,\delta) -Differential Privacy (short: (\varepsilon,\delta) -DP) for some \varepsilon\in\mathbb{R}_{>0} and 0\leq\delta\leq 1 if for all neighbouring data sets D_{0},D_{1}\in\mathcal{D} with D_{0}\sim D_{1} and all possible observations O\subseteq A : \textstyle\Pr[{M(D_{0})\in O}]\leq\exp(\varepsilon)\textstyle\Pr[{M(D_{1})\in O}]+\delta\text{.} Algorithms that preserve DP are often compositions of multiple mechanisms that each preserve DP. Sequentially composing \ell mechanisms that each preserve (\varepsilon,\delta) -DP results in an algorithm that preserves (\ell\varepsilon,\ell\delta) -DP. Composing mechanisms that preserve (\varepsilon,\delta) -DP and each take disjoint subsets of the input data set as input result in an algorithm that preserves (\varepsilon,\delta) -DP. The noisy argmax algorithm, the Exponential Mechanism is an important building block of DPM. The bounds on the utility guarantees of the Exponential Mechanism, determine the behaviour of DPM and thus affect the utility guarantees. Definition 4 (Exponential Mechanism (Def. 2.5 DPM )) . Given S\in\mathcal{D} and \varepsilon>0 , a \Delta_{f} -bounded function f : \Delta_{f}\geq\max_{S\sim S^{\prime},s\in W_{S}\cup W_{S^{\prime}}}|f(S,s)-f(S^{\prime},s)| , where W_{S}:=dom(f(S,\cdot)) is the domain of the second input of f . Then the Exponential Mechanism M_{E} takes S,f,\varepsilon as input and draws an element s\in W with probability \mathrm{pmf}_{M_{E}(S,f,\varepsilon)}(s)=\frac{\exp(\varepsilon f(S,s)/\Delta_{f})}{\sum_{s^{\prime}\in W_{S}}\exp(\varepsilon f(S,s^{\prime})/\Delta_{f})}\text{.} 1.2 Clustering The objective of clustering algorithms is

Read the complete text