Planetary Obliquity Excitation Through Pre-Main Sequence Stellar Evolution

Sidhant Kumar Suar, Sarah C. Millholland · 2025

Read Planetary Obliquity Excitation Through Pre-Main Sequence Stellar Evolution by Sidhant Kumar Suar, Sarah C. Millholland (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-17843.txt.

Introduction

Sidhant Kumar Suar and Sarah C. Millholland study planet tilt in a 2025 paper. Tilt shapes a planet's air and its chance to host life. They ask how a young star's own change can push a planet's tilt to large values early on.

A young star is wide and spins fast, so its gravity tugs the planet's orbit in a slow drift. As the star shrinks and slows, that drift rate falls and can meet the planet's spin drift. When the two meet, the planet can be caught and its tilt grows. Planets within one AU are most at risk, though disks, other planets, and tides can shift the outcome.

Catalog record

CREATORSidhant Kumar Suar, Sarah C. Millholland
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-17843

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Planetary Obliquity Excitation Through Pre-Main Sequence Stellar Evolution Sidhant Kumar Suar, Sarah C. Millholland Abstract A planet’s axial tilt (“obliquity”) substantially affects its atmosphere and habitability. It is thus essential to comprehend the various mechanisms that can excite planetary obliquities, particularly at the primordial stage. Here, we explore planetary obliquity excitation induced by the early evolution of the host star. A young, distended star spins rapidly, resulting in a large gravitational quadrupole moment that induces nodal recession of the planet’s orbit. As the star contracts and spins down, the nodal recession frequency decreases and can cross the planet’s spin axis precession frequency. An adiabatic encounter results in the planet’s capture into a secular spin-orbit resonance and excites the obliquity to large values. We find planets within a ≲ 1 ​ AU a\lesssim 1\ \mathrm{AU} are most affected, but adiabatic capture depends on the initial stellar radius and spin rate. The overall picture is complicated by other sources of perturbation, including the disk, multiple planets, and tidal dissipation. Tides make it such that stellar oblateness-induced obliquity excitation is transient since tidal perturbations cause the resonance to break once high obliquities are reached. However, this early transient excitation is important because it can prime planets for long-term capture in a secular spin-orbit resonance induced by planet-planet interactions. Thus, although stellar oblateness-induced resonances are short-lived, they facilitate the prevalence of long-lived non-zero obliquities in exoplanets. I Introduction The dynamics of a planet’s spin vector influence many of its properties, including atmospheric circulation, tidal evolution, and potential habitability ( K. Atobe et al. 2004 ; D. S. Spiegel et al. 2009 ; R. Heller et al. 2011 ; J. Jernigan et al. 2023 , e.g.) . Spin dynamics pertain to a planet’s rotation rate and obliquity, defined as the angle between the planet’s spin and orbital axes. Exoplanet obliquities are not yet widely observable, although some progress has been made. A few directly-imaged planets or brown dwarfs now have constraints on their obliquities through combining photometric, spectroscopic, and imaging data ( M. L. Bryan et al. 2020 ; M. L. Bryan et al. 2021 ; M. Poon et al. 2024 ) . For transiting planets, the obliquity may be constrained by measuring the deviation in the transit light curve due to the planet’s rotationally-induced oblateness ( S. Seager & L. Hui 2002 ; J. W. Barnes & J. J. Fortney 2003 ; J. A. Carter & J. N. Winn 2010 ; J. Biersteker & H. Schlichting 2017 ; B. Akinsanmi et al. 2020 ) . Recent studies, including some using JWST data, have used this method to place degenerate limits on the oblateness parameter, obliquity, and spin rate ( C. Lammers & J. N. Winn 2024 ; Q. Liu et al. 2024 ; E. M. Price et al. 2025 ) , but more precise constraints require further data. While we await more observational constraints on obliquities, we rely on theory to probe spin dynamics and make predictions that future observations can test. In this paper, we focus on obliquities. Planetary obliquities can be excited by several known mechanisms, almost all of which were originally discussed in the context of the Solar System ( S. Tremaine 1991 ; W. R. Ward & D. P. Hamilton 2004 ; M. H. Lee et al. 2007 , e.g.) . Recent studies have begun extending them to exoplanets. Giant impacts and mergers between proto-planets can produce large obliquities early on during the system’s evolution ( J. Li & D. Lai 2020 ) . For example, it is thought that the 98^{\circ} tilt of Uranus was a result of one or more giant impacts during its formation ( D. G. Korycansky et al. 1990 ; A. Morbidelli et al. 2012 ; J. A. Kegerreis et al. 2018 ) . Other mechanisms include planet-planet scattering ( G. Li 2021 ; Y.-C. Hong et al. 2021 ) , disk fragmentation ( R. M. Jennings & E. Chiang 2021 ) , and interactions with tilted circumplanetary disks ( R. G. Martin & P. J. Armitage 2021 ) . In this work, we focus on a widely-studied mechanism called secular spin-orbit resonance, in which the frequencies of a planet’s orbit nodal precession and its spin axis precession evolve and become commensurable, resulting in potentially significant obliquity excitation ( J. Laskar & P. Robutel 1993 ; W. R. Ward & D. P. Hamilton 2004 ; D. P. Hamilton & W. R. Ward 2004 ; A. C. M. Correia 2015 ; S. Millholland & G. Laughlin 2019 ; Y. Su & D. Lai 2020 ; H. Yuan et al. 2024 ) . Secular spin-orbit resonances may be encountered through various mechanisms that change the orbital and/or spin axis precession frequencies over time. One such mechanism is orbital migration; for instance, it has been shown that planets migrating into mean-motion resonances can also cross secular spin-orbit resonances along the way ( R. Brasser & M. H. Lee 2015 ; D. Vokrouhlický & D. Nesvorný 2015 ; S. Millholland & G. Laughlin 2019 ; S. C. Millholland et al. 2024 ) . Another mechanism is tidal evolution. Short-period planets have a fast tidal damping timescale of the spin axis and can evolve directly into the resonance ( W. R. Ward 1975 ; S. C. Millholland & C. Spalding 2020 ; Y. Su & D. Lai 2022 ) . At longer periods, the tidal evolution of a planetary moon can change the spin axis precession frequency and excite the planet into the resonance ( J. Wisdom et al. 2022 ; M. Saillenfest et al. 2023 ) . Finally, secular spin-orbit resonance can also occur when the planet is still embedded in the protoplanetary disk. The disk induces the planet’s orbital precession at a frequency that decreases as the disk dissipates, and if it becomes commensurable with the spin axis precession frequency, it can capture into resonance ( S. Millholland & K. Batygin 2019 ; Y. Su & D. Lai 2020 ) . The disk dissipation just described is not the only influence that can affect planets early on in the system’s lifetime. Any other external perturbation that causes a deviation from the 1/r central potential will also lead to orbit nodal recession. A pre-main sequence (PMS) star has a large radius and rapid rotation ( F. H. Shu et al. 1987 ) , which creates a significant gravitational quadrupole potential and drives regression of the planet’s longitude of ascending node ( C. D. Murray & S. F. Dermott 1999 ) . The precession frequency decreases as the star spins down and contracts ( J. Bouvier et al. 2014 ) . The consequences of this process have been studied in a variety of extrasolar contexts, in particular as a mechanism to tilt orbits ( K. Batygin & F. C. Adams 2013 ; C. Spalding & K. Batygin 2016 ; C. Spalding & K. Batygin 2017 ; G. Li et al. 2020 ; C. Spalding & S. C. Millholland 2020 ; J. Becker et al. 2020 ; K. Schultz et al. 2021 ; C. Chen et al. 2022 ; T. H. Faridani et al. 2023 ; T. H. Faridani et al. 2025 ) . However, a comprehensive study of the role

Read the complete text