A class of high-beta, large-aspect-ratio quasiaxisymmetric Palumbo-like configurations
Andrew Brown \aff 1 \aff 2 \corresp, Wrick Sengupta \aff 1, Nikita Nikulsin \aff 3, Amitava Bhattacharjee \aff 1 · 2025
Read A class of high-beta, large-aspect-ratio quasiaxisymmetric Palumbo-like configurations by Andrew Brown \aff 1 \aff 2 \corresp, Wrick Sengupta \aff 1, Nikita Nikulsin \aff 3, Amitava Bhattacharjee \aff 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-17528.txt.
Introduction
Andrew Brown and co-authors chart a family of stellarator shapes in the style of Palumbo in this 2025 paper. Stellarators confine fusion plasma with twisted external magnets. Quasiaxisymmetric shapes promise good confinement with a simpler symmetry.
Their inverse method starts from a simple polynomial guess for the flux function. Solving the resulting equations yields plasma shapes at high pressure ratio. Some shapes bulge one way, others pinch into cusps, and an extreme case grows a current spike. A cubic guess also works, but higher degrees overdetermine the system. The chart shows designers which elegant shapes are even possible. Fusion teams can aim magnets at the reachable part of the map.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Andrew Brown \aff 1 \aff 2 \corresp, Wrick Sengupta \aff 1, Nikita Nikulsin \aff 3, Amitava Bhattacharjee \aff 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-17528
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A class of high-beta, large-aspect-ratio quasiaxisymmetric Palumbo-like configurations Andrew Brown \aff 1 \aff 2 \corresp, Wrick Sengupta \aff 1, Nikita Nikulsin \aff 3, Amitava Bhattacharjee \aff 1 Abstract The space of high-beta, approximately quasiaxisymmetric, large-aspect-ratio stellarator configurations is explored using an inverse coordinate approach and a quadratic polynomial ansatz for the flux function, following the method of Palumbo, extended by Hernandes and Clemente. This approach yields a system of nonlinear ODEs that, when solved, give equilibria exhibiting positive or negative triangularity, cusps, and (in an extreme limit) current singularities. It is shown that a cubic ansatz may also be used, but that polynomials of degree four or higher will lead to overdetermination. 1 Introduction Omnigeneity, zero-average radial drift of the guiding center orbits, is essential for particle confinement in three-dimensional (3D) magnetic fields ( Helander 2014 ) . One route to omnigeneity is quasisymmetry (QS), in which contours of the magnetic field strength are flat in a special coordinate system known as Boozer angles . QS with magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) force balance is known to be an overdetermined system ( Garren & Boozer 1991 ) . However, recent strides have shown that extremely precise QS can be obtained by numerical optimization ( Landreman & Paul 2022 ) , reinforcing the confidence that QS is a practical approach to plasma confinement. Because quasisymmetric equilibria have been found only numerically, our understanding of the qualitative behavior of quasisymmetric equilibria is still inchoate. Considerable effort has been applied to the near-axis theory of QS ( Rodríguez & Bhattacharjee 2021 ; Rodríguez & Bhattacharjee 2021 ) and to weakly nonaxisymmetric equilibria at finite aspect ratio ( Plunk & Helander 2018 ; Henneberg et al. 2019 ; Plunk 2020 ) . Relatively little work has been done to understand QS analytically far from the axis. One reason for this gap is the lack of a standard Grad-Shafranov equation (of the elliptic type) well known for axisymmetric equilibria. In 3D, even assuming the existence of nested surfaces, the Grad-Shafranov equation is non-standard and has mixed characteristics. In this work, we consider the limit of large aspect ratio and weak perturbations away from axisymmetry to extract a tractable, semi-analytical model that reproduces many of the qualitative features of numerically optimized QA configurations. The regime explored here is inaccessible by near-axis theory and difficult to analyze using VMEC or similar tools because of sharp features in the plasma boundary. We therefore stress the complementary role that analytical theory must play in enhancing, explaining, and providing new directions for purely numerical optimization. Our approach is stimulated by a recent 3D quasisymmetric, high-beta stellarator (QS-HBS) model developed in Sengupta et al. 2024b and extended in Nikulsin et al. 2024 , which obtains a Grad-Shafranov equation (of the elliptic type) by imposing asymptotic ordering. In section 2 , we use this model to explore an interesting class of global solutions using a modified form of a method pioneered by Palumbo ( Palumbo 1968 ) and extended in Bishop & Taylor 1986 ; Hernandes & Clemente 2009 to construct isodynamic axisymmetric solutions for which magnetic surfaces and constant- |\bm{B}| contours coincide. In section 3 , we show that the resulting quasi-axisymmetric configurations exhibit many of the qualitative features observed in finite-aspect-ratio systems such as those found numerically by Landreman and Paul ( Henneberg et al. 2019 ; Landreman & Paul 2022 ) . These include very low magnetic shear, D-shaped equilibria for small \iota , and inboard cusp formation as the maximum plasma volume is approached. In section 4 , we exploit the decoupled axis and plasma shaping to show that non-negligible rotational transform may be generated from weak axis perturbations, and we use VMEC to verify the asymptotic behavior of the QA error. We conclude by considering some possible applications of this work to quasi-axisymmetric stellarator design. 2 Analytic solutions of the Quasisymmetric Grad-Shafranov Equation: An extended Palumbo approach Throughout this work, we use standard cylindrical coordinates (R,\phi,Z) and local Cartesian coordinates (x,\xi) centered on the magnetic axis (R_{0}(\phi),Z_{0}(\phi)) such that x=R-R_{0}(\phi) and \xi=Z-Z_{0}(\phi) . The quasisymmetric Grad-Shafranov equation (QS-GSE) of the QS-HBS model takes the form (in normalized units) \nabla_{\perp}^{2}\Psi+2x\frac{d\beta}{d\Psi}+\frac{dH}{d\Psi}=0 (2.1) and the toroidal current, in terms of the profiles \beta(\Psi) and H(\Psi) , is \frac{\mathbf{J_{\phi}}}{B_{0}}=-\epsilon\left(2x\frac{d\beta}{d\Psi}+\frac{dH}{d\Psi}\right). (2.2) We shall now employ an alternative approach based on an extension ( Hernandes & Clemente 2009 ; Bishop & Taylor 1986 ) of Palumbo’s work on isodynamic equilibrium ( Palumbo 1968 ) to obtain exact solutions to the QS-GSE equation ( 2.1 ). Our approach uses (x,\Psi) as independent variables and solves for \xi(x,\Psi) . Therefore, it is an inverse coordinate approach to solve the QS-GSE. The primary advantage of the inverse-coordinate approach stems from the fact that \xi enters the QS-GSE only through the \nabla_{\perp}^{2} term since the pressure term and the current terms are only functions of (x,\Psi) . Moreover, this approach shows that the MHD profile functions cannot be arbitrary if we impose QS. 2.1 An inverse-coordinate approach to solve the QS-GSE Using an ingenious method, Palumbo ( Palumbo 1968 ) obtained MHD equilibria with isodynamic magnetic fields, where the magnetic field strength is a constant on a flux surface, i.e., |\bm{B}|=B(\psi) . Extensions of Palumbo’s approach were carried out by Bishop & Taylor 1986 , Hernandes & Clemente 2009 and Hernandes & Nogueira 2013 . Following the approach outlined in Hernandes & Clemente 2009 , we now carry out the inverse-coordinate analysis starting with the variable transform from (x,\xi) to (x,\Psi) using the identities \displaystyle\and{\partial_{x}}{y}=\and{\partial_{x}}{\Psi}+u\;\partial_{\Psi},\quad\and{\partial_{\xi}}{x}=v\;\partial_{\Psi},\quad u\equiv\Psi_{,x},\quad v\equiv\Psi_{,\xi}. (2.3) Since (u,v) are components of \bm{\nabla_{\perp}}\Psi , they must satisfy the consistency condition \partial_{\xi}u=\partial_{x}v , which can be written in the following equivalent forms ( Hernandes & Clemente 2009 ) : \displaystyle\left(\partial_{x}+u\;\partial_{\Psi}\right)v^{2}=2v^{2}\partial_{\Psi}u\quad\Leftrightarrow\quad\partial_{x}\left(\frac{1}{v}\right)+\partial_{\Psi}\left(\frac{u}{v}\right)=0. (2.4) The QS-GSE ( 2.1 ) in terms of u,v reads \displaystyle\partial_{x}u+\partial_{\Psi}\Lambda=0 (2.5) where, we have defined \displaystyle\Lambda\equiv\frac{1}{2}\eta+2x\beta(\Psi)+H(\Psi),\quad\eta(x,\Psi)\equiv u^{2}+v^{2}. (2.6) Once the QS-GSE equation ( 2.5 ) is solved subject to the consistency condition ( 2.4 ), we obtain \xi through \displaystyle\xi=-\int\frac{u}{v}\;dx,\quad\text{or equivalently }\quad\xi=\int\frac{1}{v}\;d\Psi. (2.7) The two integrals are equal to each other, as can be seen from the second form of the consistency condition ( 2.4 ). The system ( 2.5 )-( 2.6 ) is a highly nonlinear system of PDEs for (u,v) . Fortunately, analytical progress can be made based on the following observation. Integrating ( 2.5 ) in x , we get \displaystyle u(x,\Psi)=u_{0}(\Psi)-xH^{\prime}(\Psi)-x^{2}\beta^{\prime}(\Psi)-\frac{1}{2}\int dx\;\partial_{\Psi}\eta(x,\Psi). (2.8) The form of u as given in ( 2.8 ) suggests that one could seek a solution where |\bm{\nabla_{\perp}}\Psi|^{2}=\eta(x,\Psi) is a polynomial in x with coefficients that are functions of \Psi , as done in Hernandes & Clemente 2009 . For the cases that Palumbo 1968 and Bishop & Taylor 1986 considered, the polynomial nature of \eta is a direct consequence of the property of |\bm{B}| . We shall now seek a solution where |\bm{\nabla_{\perp}}\Psi|^{2}=\eta is a quadratic polynomial in x , \displaystyle\eta(x,\Psi)=\eta_{0}(\Psi)+x\;\eta_{1}(\Psi)+x^{2}\eta_{2}. (2.9) Here \eta_{i},i=0,1,2 are functions of \Psi to be determined by solving the nonlinear system ( 2.5 )-( 2.4 ). The quadratic nature of \eta is suggested by the fact that in ( 2.8 ) the non-trivial terms that involve \beta^{\prime},H^{\prime} are, at most, quadratic in x . Substituting ( 2.9 ) into ( 2.8 ) we get