Can an Extra Degree of Freedom in Scalar-Tensor Non-Metricity Gravity Account for the Evolution of the Universe?

Ghulam Murtaza, Avik De, Andronikos Paliathanasis, Tee-How Loo · 2025

Read Can an Extra Degree of Freedom in Scalar-Tensor Non-Metricity Gravity Account for the Evolution of the Universe? by Ghulam Murtaza, Avik De, Andronikos Paliathanasis, Tee-How Loo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-17099.txt.

Introduction

Ghulam Murtaza and co-authors test an alternate gravity theory against the history of the universe in a 2025 paper. Their theory adds a scalar field to gravity built on non-metricity, the failure of lengths to stay fixed under transport. One class of connections in the theory adds a time-varying function, an extra degree of freedom. The question is whether that freedom can drive cosmic expansion.

They recast the equations for a flat, expanding universe as a self-running system in scaled variables. Four cases were mapped in full. The phase space holds the expected stops: matter rule, stiff fluid rule, and a steady de Sitter end state. With the right settings, the standard model of cosmic history returns. New late-time and high-curvature paths also appear, ending in crunch or rip fates. The authors compare rival scalar theories and name tests future surveys could run.

Catalog record

CREATORGhulam Murtaza, Avik De, Andronikos Paliathanasis, Tee-How Loo
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE55 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-17099

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Can an Extra Degree of Freedom in Scalar-Tensor Non-Metricity Gravity Account for the Evolution of the Universe? Ghulam Murtaza, Avik De, Andronikos Paliathanasis, Tee-How Loo Abstract We investigate whether the extra scalar degree of freedom that arises in the second connection class of scalar-tensor non-metricity gravity can accurately replicate and potentially enrich the cosmic expansion history. Focusing on a spatially flat FLRW background, we introduce Hubble-normalized variables and recast the field equations into an autonomous dynamical system. Four representative scenarios are analyzed comprehensively. Phase-space research reveals a rich hierarchy of critical points: matter-dominated, stiff-fluid, and de Sitter solutions, together with asymptotic trajectories leading to Big-Crunch/Rip singularities and transient, unstable matter epochs. With suitable parameter choices, the standard Λ \Lambda CDM sequence is reinstated; however, novel late-time and high-curvature regimes arise exclusively from the non-metricity sector. A systematic comparison of metric scalar-tensor and teleparallel scalar-torsion theories reveals unique stability characteristics and potential observational discriminants. Our findings indicate that the additional time-dependent function inherent to scalar-tensor non-metricity gravity can effectively explain the Universe’s evolution while providing new phenomenology that can be tested by upcoming surveys. 0 0 footnotetext: The research has been carried out under Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman Research Fund project IPSR/RMC/UTARRF/2023-C1/A09 provided by Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman. AP thanks the support of VRIDT through Resolución VRIDT No. 096/2022 and Resolución VRIDT No. 098/2022. AP was Financially supported by FONDECYT 1240514 ETAPA 2025. Introduction The mystery of the dark energy, which is supposed to be responsible for the current accelerated expansion of the universe, is still unsettled, especially as the standard model of \Lambda CDM faces severe tensions with cosmological data Perivolaropoulos2022 ; white ; Carloni:2024zpl , forces to think beyond the theory of general relativity (GR) Heisenberg2019 ; Ferrari:2025egk ; Wang:2025bkk ; Ye:2025ark ; Yang:2025mws ; Alfano:2024fzv ; Paliathanasis:2025dcr ; Cai:2025mas ; Silva:2025hxw ; Duchaniya:2025oeh . One of the simplest and often investigated scalar-tensor extension of GR is achieved by introducing a scalar field non-minimally coupled to the standard tensor degree of freedom Bezrukov2008 ; Akrami2020 ; Perrotta1999 ; Boisseau2000 ; Ballardinii2020 . On the other hand, the dynamics of GR can be derived through approaches other than the Einstein-Hilbert Lagrangian involving the Levi-Civita curvature scalar \mathring{R} Beltran2019 . It is possible to achieve a teleparallel framework, defined by a zero curvature tensor, by incorporating torsion or non-metricity into the connection. In the first scenario, a flat spacetime with torsion and a metric-compatible affine connection replaces the standard torsion-free, metric-compatible Levi-Civita connection used in GR. Einstein himself introduced this theory 1 , which is referred to as the metric teleparallel theory. In the latter case, the symmetric teleparallel theory arises, built upon an affine connection with zero curvature and torsion Nester . In these theories, torsion scalar \mathbb{T} and non-metricity scalar Q are built respectively from the torsion tensor T^{\mu}_{\,\,\,\nu\sigma} and non-metricity tensor Q_{\mu\nu\sigma} . By adopting \mathcal{L}=\sqrt{-g}\,\mathbb{T} for the former and \mathcal{L}=\sqrt{-g}Q for the latter, one derives the field equations. Since both metric and symmetric teleparallel theories are equivalent to GR, they naturally share its challenges regarding the dark sector, requiring either extensions to the Standard Model of particle physics or the presence of an unknown negative energy component to account for cosmic acceleration. To address this problem, modified gravity theories such as f(\mathbb{T}) fT1 and f(Q) coincident ; Heisenberg:2023lru have been proposed, analogous to how f(\mathring{R}) gravity extends GR fR . These extensions stand apart from their curvature-based GR counterparts, making them particularly intriguing for exploring novel physical phenomena. Affine connection components are independent from the metric tensor in these theories, further introducing intricate geometries in the formulations. In spatially flat, homogeneous, and isotropic FLRW cosmology, metric teleparallelism allows limited connection families without new functions Hohmann20199 ; Hohmann2021 , while symmetric teleparallelism permits three families, each involving an extra time-dependent function, leading to distinct field equations and dynamics Hohmannnn2021 ; fQfT1 . While f(Q) theories offer an interesting runway to take off in terms of gravity research Carloni:2025kev ; Koussour:2024wtt ; Narawade:2024pxb ; Jensko:2024bee ; Alwan:2024lng ; Yadav:2024vmt ; Ayuso:2021vtj ; DAmbrosio:2021zpm ; Ferreira:2023awf ; Dimakis:2025jrl ; Dialektopoulos:2025ihc ; Ayuso:2025vkc , completely uncharted territory has been introduced in intro1 by non-minimally coupling a scalar field \phi to the non-metricity scalar Q and01 . The motivation is clearly drawn from the scalar-tensor extension of GR, in which the Ricci scalar was coupled to the scalar field scalartensor ; quiros , and the scalar-torsion theory, in which the torsion scalar was coupled to the scalar field saridakisST ; phiT . The cosmological stability aspects of this new theory corresponding to the three possible connection classes were studied, and it was shown that the time-dependent function decouples completely from the cosmological field equations in case of the first connection, reducing the theory to the familiar scalar-torsion model in metric teleparallelism pati . The remaining two classes retain the time-dependent function within their dynamical equations, indicating the presence of an extra degree of freedom. In this work, we analyze the contribution of this time-dependent arbitrary function by the cosmological dynamical system analysis technique. In the context of cosmology, the field equations are typically presented as a system of coupled, non-linear ordinary differential equations. Since non-linear differential equations lack general solution methods, dynamical system analysis (DSA) provides a powerful method for understanding their qualitative behavior. To construct a dynamical system, one first introduces appropriate dimensionless normalized variables that transform the field equations into a closed system of coupled first-order non-linear differential equations. The universe’s evolution through various epochs can be traced using trajectories in phase space. Cosmological epochs like inflation, matter/radiation dominance, and dark energy-driven expansion are often reflected as stationery points in the phase space. To gain insights into the evolution of the universe and its behavior in cosmological models, DSA gained prominence as a valuable approach Bahamonde2018b ; Wainwright1997 ; Coley2013 ; Das2019 ; Grandaa2018 ; DAgostino:2021vvv ; Bargach2019 ; Mandal2023 ; Dimakis2024 ; Matsumoto2018 ; Hrycyna2015 ; Cid2018 ; Odintsov2017a ; Roy2024 ; Chaterje2024 ; Louw2024 ; Carloni:2024ybx . In f(Q) gravity, a series of interesting DSA works was done Paliathanasis:2023raj ; 73 ; 74 ; Channuie2024 ; solanki2024 ; narawade2023 ; 4 ; fQBI ; shabani2024a . Utilizing three different classes of affine connections on a FLRW universe, the DSA in f(Q) was carried out in Shabani2023a ; shabani2023b . The complete phase space of f(Q) -cosmology for all the families of connections investigated in andfq ; Paliathanasis:2023raj . The boundary term’s contribution in non-metricity gravity was examined using DSA techniques recently in Paliathanasis:2024yea ; Lohakare2024 ; Murtaza2025 ; shabanifQC . Very recently, the phase space evolution was explored in the currently studied scalar non-metricity theory with a Chameleon mechanism Paliathanasiss2024 . In the present article, we conduct the dynamical system analysis using the Hubble normalization method to study the dynamics and asymptotic solutions of scalar-tensor theory in the non-metricity approach, specifically for the second connection class. This allows us to rewrite the field equations as an equivalent system of algebraic differential equations. We identify the fixed points and examine the physical characteristics of the asymptotic solutions associated with them. The present article is organized as follows: After the Introduction in Section I , we provide a brief overview

Read the complete text