Evaluating the Impact of Model Accuracy for Optimizing Battery Energy Storage Systems
Martin Cornejo, Melina Graner, Holger Hesse, Andreas Jossen, [0.1cm] Technical University of Munich, Germany; TUM School of Engineering, DesignDepartment of Energy and Process Engineering, Chair of Electrical Energy Storage Technology, [0.1cm] Kempten University of Applied Sciences, Germany; Institu · 2025
Read Evaluating the Impact of Model Accuracy for Optimizing Battery Energy Storage Systems by Martin Cornejo, Melina Graner, Holger Hesse, Andreas Jossen, [0.1cm] Technical University of Munich, Germany; TUM School of Engineering, DesignDepartment of Energy and Process Engineering, Chair of Electrical Energy Storage Technology, [0.1cm] Kempten University of Applied Sciences, Germany; Institu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-17059.txt.
Introduction
Martin Cornejo, Melina Graner, Holger Hesse, and Andreas Jossen ask how much model accuracy is worth when optimizing a battery storage system that trades energy within a day. The battery buys power when it is cheap and sells when prices rise, steered by a predictive controller. A simple linear model is easy to run but mispredicts losses and limits.
A detailed circuit-based model, though nonlinear and heavier, forecasts losses and capability more faithfully. Across scenarios spanning the battery's life, the detailed model earned more and wasted less energy. The edge grew for second-life batteries with high internal resistance. The catch is that the detailed model only pays if its parameters are identified well.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Martin Cornejo, Melina Graner, Holger Hesse, Andreas Jossen, [0.1cm] Technical University of Munich, Germany; TUM School of Engineering, DesignDepartment of Energy and Process Engineering, Chair of Electrical Energy Storage Technology, [0.1cm] Kempten University of Applied Sciences, Germany; Institu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 21 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-17059
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Evaluating the Impact of Model Accuracy for Optimizing Battery Energy Storage Systems Thanks: This work was funded by the Bavarian Research Foundation under the research project KI-M-Bat (reference number AZ-1563-22). Martin Cornejo, Melina Graner, Holger Hesse, Andreas Jossen, [0.1cm] Technical University of Munich, Germany; TUM School of Engineering, DesignDepartment of Energy and Process Engineering, Chair of Electrical Energy Storage Technology, [0.1cm] Kempten University of Applied Sciences, Germany; Institute for Energy, Propulsion Technology[-0.5cm] Abstract This study investigates two models of varying complexity for optimizing intraday arbitrage energy trading of a battery energy storage system using a model predictive control approach. Scenarios reflecting different stages of the system’s lifetime are analyzed. The findings demonstrate that the equivalent-circuit-model-based non-linear optimization model outperforms the simpler linear model by delivering more accurate predictions of energy losses and system capabilities. This enhanced accuracy enables improved operational strategies, resulting in increased roundtrip efficiency and revenue, particularly in systems with batteries exhibiting high internal resistance, such as second-life batteries. However, to fully leverage the model’s benefits, it is essential to identify the correct parameters. I Introduction Battery energy storage systems (BESS) are essential for providing the flexibility needed to continue expanding renewable power generation while maintaining grid stability. The flexible nature of BESS also creates a need for effective energy management to fully leverage the system’s capabilities. While several heuristic and machine learning methods have been explored as algorithmic foundations for developing operational strategies, mathematical optimization remains the most commonly used approach in this field [ 1 ] . BESS optimization models aim to determine the best power schedule to maximize an objective while considering technical constraints, like power and state-of-charge (SOC) limits. This approach provides a model-based framework that is physically interpretable and easily transferable to new systems and applications. Similar to battery simulation models, battery optimization models range from simplified representations to complex physicochemical models, each designed for specific applications and use cases [ 2 ] . However, the vast majority of optimization models in the literature use linear programming (LP) formulations [ 1 ] . LP models take a simplified approach and construct an optimization model with constraints and objectives represented with linear relationships. As a result, the optimization process is very fast, making LP models particularly useful for applications that require high scalability and extended optimization horizons, such as optimal system sizing [ 3 , 4 ] and transmission expansion planning [ 5 ] . While LP models provide globally optimal solutions within their feasible region, their simplified assumptions limit their ability to capture real-world behavior, potentially leading to suboptimal or infeasible schedules in actual systems. Notably, LP models typically represent losses using a constant efficiency, whereas, in reality, system losses typically grow quadratically with output power and depend on operational conditions such as SOC and battery temperature. Previous studies have focused on developing optimization models that more accurately reflect this behavior, for example through convex relaxations [ 6 ] and piecewise linear approximations [ 7 , 8 ] . Additionally, most BESS optimization models focus solely on power and energy, while batteries are more accurately described with equations governing voltage, current and charge. Previous studies have shown that using an equivalent circuit model (ECM) for optimization results in a formulation with non-linear (NL) equations, which is more computationally intensive to solve. However, compared to LP models, this approach can better estimate system energy losses and help avoid schedules that lead to technical violations in the actual system [ 9 , 10 ] . In this context, this paper aims to evaluate the advantages of using a high-fidelity non-linear (NL) model over a simplified linear programming (LP) model for optimizing BESS operations. Additionally, it seeks to quantify the performance loss that occurs due to discrepancies between model parameters and the actual system. To illustrate these points, a case study is presented that focuses on the closed-loop optimization of a BESS to maximize revenues in intraday energy trading. II Optimization models II-A Linear model The main decision variables of the linear model are system power p_{t} and SOC soc_{t} for each timestep in the optimization horizon t\in T . The SOC updates based on the system power, the timestep length \Delta t , the system’s nominal energy capacity E_{N} , and considers charge and discharge losses modeled from a constant efficiency factor \eta . soc_{t}=soc_{t-1}+\frac{\Delta t}{E_{N}}\,\left(p^{ch}_{t}\,\eta-p^{dch}_{t}\,\frac{1}{\eta}\right)\quad\forall t\in T (1) The power is a combination from charging power p^{ch}_{t} and discharging power p^{dch}_{t} variables. Although the model does not enforce mutual exclusivity between charge and discharge power, it discourages simultaneous charging and discharging as the additional energy losses would result in a suboptimal solution. p_{t}=p^{ch}_{t}-p^{dch}_{t}\qquad\forall t\in T (2) The power variables are limited by the system’s rated power, while the SOC is also constrained to defined lower and upper limits. \displaystyle 0 \displaystyle\leq p^{ch}_{t}\leq p^{max} \displaystyle\forall t\in T (3) \displaystyle 0 \displaystyle\leq p^{dch}_{t}\leq p^{max} \displaystyle\forall t\in T (4) \displaystyle soc^{min} \displaystyle\leq soc_{t}\leq soc^{max} \displaystyle\forall t\in T (5) II-B Non-linear model The non-linear model employs a simple ECM to model the battery. The SOC is charge based instead of energy based, it is updated from current i and nominal charge capacity Q_{N} . soc_{t}=soc_{t-1}+\frac{\Delta t}{Q_{N}}\,i_{t}\qquad\forall t\in T (6) The battery power p^{dc}_{t} is the product from terminal voltage and current. The terminal voltage emerges from the battery’s open-circuit voltage (OCV) and the voltage drop caused by the battery’s internal resistance R . The OCV is a function of SOC and can be modeled, for example, through a polynomial curve or cubic splines [ 2 ] . \displaystyle p^{dc}_{t} \displaystyle=v_{t}\;i_{t} \displaystyle\forall t\in T (7) \displaystyle v_{t} \displaystyle=ocv_{t}+i_{t}\;R \displaystyle\forall t\in T (8) Equations ( 7 ) and ( 8 ) inherently account for quadratically increasing losses with battery output power, which arise from ohmic losses i^{2}\,R . Additionally, the SOC also influences these losses, as a higher SOC corresponds to a higher OCV, which in turn results in a higher efficiency since less current is required to provide the same amount of power. The battery power is constrained by its voltage and current limits, and the SOC also has defined boundaries. \displaystyle-i^{max} \displaystyle\leq i_{t}\leq i^{max} \displaystyle\forall t\in T (9) \displaystyle v^{min} \displaystyle\leq v_{t}\leq v^{max} \displaystyle\forall t\in T (10) \displaystyle soc^{min} \displaystyle\leq soc_{t}\leq soc^{max} \displaystyle\forall t\in T (11) To achieve the desired voltage and energy, cells are connected in s series and p parallel configurations. Consequently, the battery parameters, typically available at the cell level, must be scaled accordingly. \displaystyle Q_{N} \displaystyle=Q_{cell}\cdot p \displaystyle i \displaystyle=i_{cell}\cdot p (12) \displaystyle v \displaystyle=v_{cell}\cdot s \displaystyle R \displaystyle=R_{cell}\cdot s/p (13) In addition to the battery, the converter losses are also incorporated. A simplified approach is to model them through a constant efficiency \eta^{conv} . The converter power is constrained to its rated power as in equations ( 2 )-( 4 ). p^{dc}_{t}=p^{ch}_{t}\,\eta^{conv}-p^{dch}_{t}\,\frac{1}{\eta^{conv}}\qquad\forall t\in T (14) III Case study III-A System and scenarios description Figure 1: System efficiency as a function of output power (discharge direction) and SOC under increasing battery resistance conditions. The top section displays efficiency curves at the component level – converter, battery, and overall system – at SOC values of 10\text{\,}\% , 50\text{\,}\% , and 90\text{\,}\% . The bottom section presents a 2D contour map of the system efficiency across