Asymptotic TCL4 Generator for the Spin-Boson Model: Analytical Derivation and Benchmarking
Prem Kumar, K. P. Athulya, Sibasish Ghosh · 2025
Read Asymptotic TCL4 Generator for the Spin-Boson Model: Analytical Derivation and Benchmarking by Prem Kumar, K. P. Athulya, Sibasish Ghosh (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-17009.txt.
Introduction
Prem Kumar, Athulya, and Sibasish Ghosh present a 2025 physics paper on the spin-boson model. The model pairs a two-level quantum system with a bath of oscillators. It is the standard test bed for open quantum systems. Weak-coupling math fails as the link to the bath strengthens. The time-convolutionless approach builds generators order by order in that coupling. The authors derive the full fourth-order generator by hand, for a general model whose bath spectrum is an odd function of frequency.
Applied to a semiconductor double quantum dot, the new terms shift the predicted dynamics in notable ranges. Benchmarks check the formula against known results. Quantum engineers get exact corrections where numerics alone leave doubt. Higher-order generators matter because real devices rarely sit in the weak corner. An analytic form also shows which terms drive the corrections, guiding simpler device models.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Prem Kumar, K. P. Athulya, Sibasish Ghosh |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-17009
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Asymptotic TCL4 Generator for the Spin-Boson Model: Analytical Derivation and Benchmarking Prem Kumar, K. P. Athulya, Sibasish Ghosh Abstract The spin-boson model is a widely used model for understanding the properties of a two-level open quantum system. Accurately describing its dynamics often requires going beyond the weak system-environment coupling approximation. However, calculating the higher-order generators of such a dynamics, with a system-environment coupling that is not too weak, has been known to be challenging, both numerically and analytically. This work presents the analytical derivation of the complete fourth-order time-convolutionless (TCL) generator for a generic spin-boson model, accurate up to 4th order in the system-environment coupling parameter, under the assumption that the environmental spectral density is an odd function of frequency. In the case of a semiconductor double-quantum-dot system, our results reveal corrections to the dynamics that may become physically significant in some parameter regimes. Furthermore, we report that the widely used second-order TCL master equation tends to overestimate the non-Markovianity of a dynamics over a large parameter regime. Within the regime of its applicability, our results provide a computational advantage over numerically exact techniques. The accuracy of the fourth-order TCL generator is rigorously benchmarked against specialized analytical calculations done for the Ohmic spectral density with Drude cutoff and against the numerically exact Hierarchical Equations of Motion technique. I Introduction The spin-boson model (SBM) serves as a fundamental paradigm in the study of open quantum systems, finding applications in diverse fields ranging from quantum chemistry and biology to quantum thermodynamics and information processing gilmore2006criteria ; Gilmore_2005 ; gilmore2008quantum ; porras2008mesoscopic ; cheche2001dynamics ; merkli2013electron ; magazzu2018probing . Understanding the dynamics of the SBM is hence of great importance. Numerically exact techniques to solve for the open system dynamics, like Hierarchical Equations of Motion (HEOM) tanimura2020numerically and Tensor Networks strathearn2018efficient , have therefore proven to be crucial in the study of such systems. In the weak coupling limit, the Time-Convolutionless (TCL) Master Equation (ME) provides a perturbative approach in the system-environment (SE) coupling strength to solve for the open system dynamics, and can provide great numerical and conceptual advantage over these numerically exact techniques chen2025benchmarking ; breuer2001time ; breuer2002theory . The TCL2-ME (second-order TCL), equivalent to the Bloch-Redfield ME, has been widely adopted in the literature. However, the TCL2-ME has obvious limitations at higher SE coupling because the corresponding dynamics has O(\lambda^{2}) errors, where \lambda denotes a dimensionless SE coupling parameter. Consequently, it predicts steady-state (SS) populations correctly only up to zeroth-order ( O(1) ) in \lambda , and coherences up to O(\lambda^{2}) PhysRevB.71.035318 ; thingna2012generalized ; PhysRevLett.121.070401 ; thingna2012generalized . To capture higher-order corrections, that is, the O(\lambda^{2}) corrections to SS populations and O(\lambda^{4}) corrections to SS coherences, one must resort to higher-order MEs like the TCL4-ME. Both numerical and analytical evaluation of the higher order TCL 2n generator is considered analytically cumbersome because of the existence of 2n-1 time-like and n frequency-like integrals, although some progress has been made to calculate these higher-order TCL generators PhysRevB.71.035318 ; crowder2024invalidation ; PhysRevB.111.115423 ; PhysRevA.111.042214 ; chen2025benchmarking . For example, Crowder et al. crowder2024invalidation have greatly reduced the numerical cost of evaluating the TCL4 generator for an arbitrary N -dimensional system. In our previous work PhysRevB.111.115423 , two specific matrix elements of the asymptotic TCL4 generator were analytically calculated for a generic SBM for all odd spectral densities. This allowed us to determine the O(\lambda^{2}) corrections to the SS populations and demonstrate their equivalence with the corresponding terms in the generalized Gibbs state of the system. The present work significantly extends our earlier results by presenting the derivation of the full asymptotic TCL4 generator for the generic SBM, subject to the same assumption of an odd spectral density. We have been able to reduce the final expression for the coefficients of the TCL4 generator to, at most, a double integral over frequency variables, which, without knowing the specific form of the spectral density, cannot be further simplified. This has greatly facilitated both symbolic analysis and numerical evaluation of the TCL4 dynamics and SS. For example, our results have enabled us to analytically evaluate the 4th-order corrections to the SS coherences of the system. As an application, we study the corrections that TCL4 provides to the dynamics and SS of a semiconductor double-quantum-dot (DQD) system. We also study the corrections to non-Markovianity induced by TCL4 in the dynamics of TCL2-ME, quantified by the BLP measure. We report that for the majority of the parameter regime considered, TCL2 tends to overestimate the non-Markovianity of a dynamics. The accuracy of the TCL4 generator is rigorously benchmarked against specialized analytical calculations done for the Ohmic spectral density with Drude cutoff and against the HEOM. Finally, all the results mentioned in this work, including symbolic derivations, final expressions, numerical evaluation for specific parameters, and plots, etc, in their complete form, have been made publicly available as the accompanying supplementary material SupplementaryMaterial . The remainder of this paper is organised as follows. Section II introduces the SBM and the TCL ME formalism and notations. Section III presents our main results. Section IV details the numerical checks and benchmarks performed to validate our TCL4 generator. Finally, section V provides discussion, conclusion, and future directions. II Theoretical Framework This section introduces the basic notations, which are reproduced here from PhysRevB.111.115423 for the convenience of the readers. II.1 The Spin-Boson Model The spin-boson model describes a two-level open quantum system interacting with a large number of uncoupled thermal Bosonic oscillators. The total Hamiltonian, \hat{H}_{SE} , \displaystyle\hat{H}_{SE} \displaystyle=\hat{H}_{S}+\hat{H}_{E}+\hat{H}_{I}, (1) is composed of three parts: the system ( \hat{H}_{S} ), environment ( \hat{H}_{E} ) and the interaction Hamiltonian ( \hat{H}_{I} ). The SE interaction is assumed to have the form: \displaystyle\hat{H}_{I} \displaystyle=\lambda\hat{A}\otimes\hat{B}. (2) Here, \hat{A} and \hat{B} are the system and the environment operators, respectively. For the current work, we assume the following specific forms for all of these operators breuer2002theory ; weiss2012quantum \displaystyle\hat{H}_{S} \displaystyle\equiv\frac{\Omega}{2}\hat{\sigma}_{3}, (3) \displaystyle\hat{H}_{E} \displaystyle=\sum_{k}\left[\frac{\hat{p}_{k}^{2}}{2m_{k}}+\frac{1}{2}m_{k}\omega_{k}^{2}\hat{q}_{k}^{2}\right], (4) \displaystyle\hat{A} \displaystyle=a_{3}\hat{\sigma}_{3}-a_{1}\hat{\sigma}_{1}, (5) \displaystyle\hat{B} \displaystyle=\sum_{k}c_{k}\hat{q}_{k}. (6) Here \hat{\sigma}_{i} represents the Pauli matrices. For the k -th environment oscillator, \hat{p}_{k} and \hat{q}_{k} are the momentum and position operators, respectively, with m_{k} being its mass and \omega_{k} its frequency. The term c_{k} represents the strength of the coupling between the system and the k -th oscillator in the environment. Throughout this work, unless otherwise mentioned, we have chosen a_{1}=\sin(\theta) and a_{3}=\cos(\theta) . The corresponding spectral density is defined as \displaystyle J(\omega) \displaystyle=\sum_{k}\frac{c_{k}^{2}}{m_{k}\omega_{k}}\delta(\omega-\omega_{k}). (7) The dynamics of the system is determined by the two-point correlation functions of the environment operator \hat{B} , defined as \displaystyle\eta(t) \displaystyle\equiv\text{Im}\{\braket{\hat{B},\hat{B}(-t)}\}, (8) \displaystyle\nu(t) \displaystyle\equiv\text{Re}\{\braket{\hat{B},\hat{B}(-t)}\}, (9) These correlation functions can be calculated directly from the spectral density as breuer2002theory \displaystyle\eta(t) \displaystyle=-\int_{0}^{\infty}d\omega J(\omega)\sin(t\omega), (10) \displaystyle\nu(t) \displaystyle=\int_{0}^{\infty}d\omega f(\omega)\cos(t\omega). (11) Here we have defined \displaystyle f(\omega) \displaystyle\equiv J(\omega)\coth(\beta\omega/2), (12) where \beta is the inverse temperature of the environment. II.2 TCL Master Equation To facilitate the master equation calculations, we adopt a vectorized representation for the system’s quantum state. The components of this state vector are defined by the expectation values of the Pauli operators, as follows: \displaystyle v_{i}(t) \displaystyle=\operatorname{Tr}\{\hat{\sigma}_{i}\hat{\rho}_{S}(t)\}, (13) where \hat{\sigma}_{0} represents the identity matrix. The TCL-ME offers a perturbative approach, in the SE coupling strength \lambda , to the open quantum system dynamics breuer2002theory .