Superconductivity in a Chern band: effect of time-reversal-symmetry breaking on superconductivity
Bernhard E. Lüscher, Mark H. Fischer · 2025
Read Superconductivity in a Chern band: effect of time-reversal-symmetry breaking on superconductivity by Bernhard E. Lüscher, Mark H. Fischer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-16508.txt.
Introduction
Breaking time symmetry is often thought to hurt superconductivity, the state where a metal carries current with no loss. Yet some new materials show both traits at once, which drew Bernhard Luscher and Mark Fischer to study the case in a 2025 paper. They use the Haldane model, a clean test case where loops of current flow in a set pattern. The pair ask which paired states can survive in such a band and what weakens them.
They find that paired states are not, as a rule, wiped out, and that the layout of sites in the crystal counts a great deal. Some paired states split into two forms once the flux is on. The pair also show how a heat flow test can tell plain states from states with a twist that gives them a Chern number.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bernhard E. Lüscher, Mark H. Fischer |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 61 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-16508
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Superconductivity in a Chern band: effect of time-reversal-symmetry breaking on superconductivity Bernhard E. Lüscher, Mark H. Fischer Abstract Time-reversal-symmetry breaking is generally understood to be detrimental for superconductivity. However, recent experiments found superconductivity emerging out of a normal state showing a finite anomalous Hall effect, indicative of time-reversal-symmetry breaking, in diverse systems from kagome metals, 1 T ′ 1T^{\prime} -WS 2 , to twisted MoTe 2 and rhombohedral graphene. Motivated by these findings, we study the stability of superconducting orders and the mechanisms that suppress superconductivity in the prototypical anomalous Hall system, the Haldane model, where complex hopping parameters result in loop-current order with a compensated flux pattern. We find that neither spin-singlet nor spin-triplet states are generically suppressed, but the real-space sublattice structure plays a crucial role in the stability of the orders. Interestingly, the nearest-neighbor chiral states of d ± i d d\pm id or p ± i p p\pm ip symmetry couple linearly to the flux, such that the two otherwise degenerate chiralities split under finite flux. As an experimental probe to distinguish the various orders in this system, we study the anomalous thermal Hall effect, κ x y / T \kappa_{xy}/T , which vanishes at zero temperature for topologically trivial superconducting states, but reaches a finite value corresponding to the Chern number in a topologically non-trivial superconducting state. Our results illustrate that broken time-reversal symmetry through a finite flux is neither generically destructive for superconductivity, nor does it imply non-trivial topological order of the emerging superconducting state. However, in the case of multiple competing pairing channels, the loop-current order can favor a chiral superconducting state. I Introduction Recently, several material platforms have shown superconductivity emerging out of a normal state exhibiting an anomalous Hall effect (AHE). In particular, such a situation was found in twisted MoTe 2 Xu et al. 2025 , as well as in rhombohedral graphene Han et al. 2025 . Furthermore, in the kagome metals of the AV 3 Sb 5 (A=K, Rb, Cs) family Guguchia et al. 2023 ; Mielke III et al. 2022 ; Xu et al. 2022 ; Khasanov et al. 2022 ; Feng et al. 2021 , superconductivity was found to coexist with an unconventional AHE Yang et al. 2020 without signs of magnetism Ortiz et al. 2019 . Finally, in 1 T^{\prime} -WS 2 under hydrostatic pressure, an anomalous Hall phase was found, out of which superconductivity emerges Hossain et al. 2025 . While both the rhombohedral graphene and twisted MoTe 2 are believed to have a valley- and spin-polarized normal state, in the kagome materials the signatures of time-reversal-symmetry breaking were interpreted as stemming from a loop-current or flux-density-wave order Jiang et al. 2021 ; Lin and Nandkishore 2021 ; Denner et al. 2021 ; Fu et al. 2024 ; Zhan et al. 2025 , which could give rise to non-trivial Chern bands Wang et al. 2024 . These findings have renewed attention to the implications of a normal state being a partially-filled topological band structure without time-reversal symmetry on superconductivity. Superconductivity emerging out of topologically non-trivial bands has attracted most attention recently in the context of flat bands, such as multilayer graphene structures Peotta and Törmä 2015 . Concretely, most theoretical studies project the bandstructure to a single band, such that the properties of the band structure are captured by Berry-curvature and quantum-geometry effect. The question then is on the possibly unconventional pairing channels, which might be enforced by the non-trivial bandstructure, leading to topologically non-trivial superconductivity Murakami and Nagaosa 2003 ; Simon et al. 2022 ; Wolf et al. 2022 ; Wang et al. 2024 ; Wang et al. 2025 ; May-Mann et al. 2025 ; Peotta and Törmä 2015 . Finally, signatures of a time-reversal-symmetry-broken normal state in the superconducting phase were studied, such as in the Rashba system with a Zeeman field Ojanen and Kitagawa 2013 ; Sacramento et al. 2014 ; Chung and Roy 2014 . However, less focus was directed on how the fact that time-reversal symmetry (TRS) is broken in a Chern band affects the instability and the resulting ground state. TRS was early recognized to be a crucial symmetry for superconductivity Anderson 1959 . In particular, a finite magnetic field coupling to the electrons’ spin though the Zeeman term suppresses spin-singlet superconductivity, such that an unconventional superconducting order is expected in a system with finite magnetic moment Huxley 2015 . This then raises the question whether in the case of an anomalous Hall system, where the anomalous Hall effect derives from a finite Berry curvature, we generically should expect unconventional pairing, or whether the pairing could equally well be conventional. To answer these questions, we study superconductivity in the prototypical lattice model featuring an anomalous Hall effect, the Haldane model on the hexagonal lattice Haldane 1988 . In the Haldane model, the complex next-nearest-neighbor (NNN) hopping amplitudes lead to a (compensated) flux pattern and open a gap at the K and K^{\prime} points in the Brilluoin zone. In the metallic regime, the anomalous Hall conductivity is non-zero but not quantized. We then start from a tight-binding model on the hexagonal lattice and introduce interactions up to next-nearest neighbors and investigate the stability of the resulting states Brydon et al. 2019 ; Pangburn et al. 2023 ; Awoga et al. 2023 against introducing TRS breaking in the form of a finite flux. Given the simplicity of the model, we can treat the self-consistency equation using the full band-structure, with no need of projecting to a single-band description. The TRS breaking of the normal state is generally expected to imprint signatures on the superconducting state. As an experimental signature of the breaking of TRS in the superconducting state, we study the temperature-dependence of the anomalous thermal Hall effect. While the anomalous thermal Hall conductivity vanishes for all superconductors for T\rightarrow 0 due to the vanishing density of states at the Fermi energy, the temperature dependence can indicate nodal gap structure, and a finite slope indicates a topologically non-trivial pairing state. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II , we introduce the Haldane model, which features Chern bands and an anomalous (quantum) Hall effect. After introducing the mean-field framework for superconductivity and the possible pairing channels on the hexagonal lattice in Sec. III , we analyze the effect of the finite flux on the transition temperatures of all pairing channels including up to NNN local structures in Sec. IV . In Sec. V , we study the temperature evolution of the anomalous thermal Hall effect as an experimental probe of the underlying time-reversal-symmetry breaking and the topology of the different states before discussing our results and concluding in Sec. VI . II Haldane Model and Normal State II.1 Normal State Hamiltonian Figure 1 : Dispersion along high-symmetry lines for the Haldane model with t_{1}=1 , t_{2}=0.2 , and \phi=0 and \phi=0.5 respectively. The inset shows the hexagonal lattice with the mirrors \sigma_{v} , \sigma_{d} , and the lattice vectors \bm{a}_{i} and \bm{b}_{i} . The Haldane model describes electrons moving on a two-dimensional hexagonal lattice with nearest- and next-nearest-neighbor hopping. The next-nearest-neighbor hopping amplitudes are complex, t_{2}e^{i\phi} with t_{2}\in\mathbb{R} , leading to finite currents