Emission Impossible: privacy-preserving carbon emissions claims Conference: ; Dec 03, 2024; Glasgow, Scotland, UK
Jessica Man, Sadiq Jaffer, Patrick Ferris, Martin Kleppmann, Anil Madhavapeddy · 2025
Read Emission Impossible: privacy-preserving carbon emissions claims Conference: ; Dec 03, 2024; Glasgow, Scotland, UK by Jessica Man, Sadiq Jaffer, Patrick Ferris, Martin Kleppmann, Anil Madhavapeddy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-16347.txt.
Introduction
Carbon claims that can be checked without spilling secrets are designed by Jessica Man and co-authors in a 2025 arXiv paper. Data centers owe much of tech's carbon bill. Firms like to flatter their counts and hide their books. Hired checkers for each chain link would cost too much. The team's fix uses zero-knowledge proofs, math that proves a claim while the inputs stay shut.
Claims can then ride the whole supply chain, from power firms to cloud users. Users get counts they can trust for their own reports. Providers stay on the hook for true data.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jessica Man, Sadiq Jaffer, Patrick Ferris, Martin Kleppmann, Anil Madhavapeddy |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-16347
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Emission Impossible: privacy-preserving carbon emissions claims Conference: ; Dec 03, 2024; Glasgow, Scotland, UK Jessica Man, Sadiq Jaffer, Patrick Ferris, Martin Kleppmann, Anil Madhavapeddy Abstract . Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) have a significant climate impact, and data centres account for a large proportion of the carbon emissions from ICT. To achieve sustainability goals, it is important that all parties involved in ICT supply chains can track and share accurate carbon emissions data with their customers, investors, and the authorities. However, businesses have strong incentives to make their numbers look good, whilst less so to publish their accounting methods along with all the input data, due to the risk of revealing sensitive information. It would be uneconomical to use a trusted third party to verify the data for every report for each party in the chain. As a result, carbon emissions reporting in supply chains currently relies on unverified data. This paper proposes a methodology that applies cryptography and zero-knowledge proofs for carbon emissions claims that can be subsequently verified without the knowledge of the private input data. The proposed system is based on a zero-knowledge Succinct Non-interactive ARguments of Knowledge (zk-SNARK) protocol, which enables verifiable emissions reporting mechanisms across a chain of energy suppliers, cloud data centres, cloud services providers, and customers, without any company needing to disclose commercially sensitive information. This allows customers of cloud services to accurately account for the emissions generated by their activities, improving data quality for their own regulatory reporting. Cloud services providers would also be held accountable for producing accurate carbon emissions data. 1. Introduction Regulatory requirements and sustainability initiatives mean that companies are increasingly having to report their carbon emissions. Looking at ICT companies in particular, customers of online services, who are also obligated to report their emissions data or who might want to take carbon emissions into account when deciding which service to use, are currently hindered by a lack of reliable emissions data that are comparable across services. Calculating accurate carbon emissions across a cloud computing pipeline involves a number of stakeholders, none of whom are incentivised to accurately report their emissions for competitive reasons. In this paper, we explore mechanisms to support verifiable and confidentiality-preserving emissions reporting across a chain of energy suppliers, cloud data centres, virtual machine hosting service providers and cloud services providers, which are ultimately passed through to their customers. We believe that adding verifiable and composable emissions transparency to cloud computing architectures enables providers to compete on the basis of sustainability, resulting in demand-side pressure on cloud services to shift to renewable energy sources ( Calderon-Monge et al. 2020 ) . Our technique centres around zero-knowledge proofs (ZKPs) ( Goldwasser et al. 2019 ) . When applying ZKPs to the issue of untrusted carbon emissions claims, a stakeholder in a supply chain proves to a verifier (who can be anyone, such as a customer, investor, or regulator) that the emissions calculations were performed accurately, without revealing commercially sensitive data about their business operations. The verifier decides whether the claim can be accepted using only public knowledge and the cryptographic proof provided by the stakeholder. The proposed system applies zero-knowledge Succinct Non-interactive ARguments of Knowledge (zk-SNARK) as the protocol to allow proofs to be generated and subsequently verified without the requirement of disclosing all of the input data. In this paper, we present our argument on why conflicting incentives around carbon emissions reporting make existing systems unlikely to succeed (§ 2.2 ) and our contribution of applying ZKPs to allow more accurate reporting of carbon claims without compromising sensitive information (§ 4 ). 2. Background 2.1. Carbon Emissions Reporting In some countries, large companies must disclose their carbon emissions to comply with regulations. For example, the UK’s Streamlined Energy and Carbon Reporting (SECR) regulations require all UK quoted companies and large limited liability partnerships to report on their global energy use in addition to greenhouse gas emissions ( Gov.uk 2018 ) . The EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) came into force on 5 January 2023, which requires large companies and listed SMEs to report on sustainability, highlighting the urgent need for the disclosure of ‘relevant, comparable and reliable sustainability information’ and the significant increase in demand for sustainability information ( Union 2022 ) . Other than for regulatory reasons, companies publicising their plans towards net-zero could have a positive impact on their businesses. On the one hand, transparency on climate actions taken as part of the manufacturing and distribution process behind commercial products can directly influence consumer behaviours ( Calderon-Monge et al. 2020 ) . On the other hand, if companies have to disclose their confidential business data as part of the reporting, this could benefit competitors. Pressure from the media, investors, and customers could also have an effect on businesses. Amazon was given an ‘F’ grade (meaning no response) by CDP 1 1 1 A non-profit carbon disclosure company, formally known as the Carbon Disclosure Project until 2023 when they first submitted their report ( Evans 2022 ) . Shareholders of the company continue to request Amazon to provide additional information on climate-related impacts ( stakeholders 2018 ; Amazon 2024 ) . 2.2. Conflicting Incentives Behind CO 2e Claims An estimated 1.8% to 3.9% of global carbon emissions are attributable to Information and Communication Technology (ICT) ( ACM 2021 ) . Governments, investors and customers are therefore paying close attention to how cloud computing operators work towards net zero ( Azar et al. 2021 ; Sachs 2024 ; Gelenbe and Caseau 2015 ) . However, companies closely guard the metrics behind the computational resources used to provide particular services, as disclosing them would undermine their pricing and business model. Businesses have strong incentives to make only positive claims, which could involve hiding data or publishing misleading results with dubious evidence, a problem termed ‘greenwashing’ ( Nations 2024 ) . Therefore, it is difficult for an outsider to know whether a company’s emissions claims are true. There are now tightened regulations to tackle greenwashing in some countries, for example, the EU has proposed the ‘Green Claims Directive’ ( Commission 2023 ) to prevent companies making claims without providing clear evidence. The verification, however, relies on accredited verifiers. The UK’s CMA has also developed the ‘Green Claims Code’ to combat greenwashing 2 2 2 https://greenclaims.campaign.gov.uk , which focuses on a set of core principles based on existing consumer law, to protect businesses and consumers from misleading environmental claims. However, measurements of carbon emissions are continuous and frequent, and with input data varying at each measurement, it is not practical to have an independent auditor to verify every single claim for a supply chain with multiple companies involved. Consider three of the biggest data centre providers: Amazon, Google and Microsoft. They have all reported their decarbonisation goals publicly, but have also been accused of using creative accounting to hide facts about their carbon emissions ( Temple 2024 ) . Both Microsoft and Google admitted that their carbon emissions had increased in recent years, despite their climate commitments ( Mann 2024 ; Robinson 2024 ) , and Amazon’s self-reporting did not include emissions data for products sold by third-party vendors ( Evans 2022 ) . The major risks