Eckhard

Platen · 2025

Read Eckhard by Platen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-16264.txt.

Introduction

Eckhard Platen sums up the benchmark approach to pricing financial contracts, with focus on benchmark-neutral pricing, in a 2025 paper. The approach prices claims against the best-performing portfolio, the growth optimal portfolio, rather than against a risk-free account. A broad stock index portfolio stands in for that ideal, modeled with a drifted, time-changed squared Bessel process of dimension four.

Platen applies the machinery to an extreme case: a European put option on the index with a very long time to expiry. The benchmark-neutral price comes out as the lowest price theory allows. The standard risk-neutral price for the same put is far higher. The gap matters for anyone pricing very long-dated guarantees, where the choice of pricing rule changes the bill by a wide margin.

Catalog record

CREATORPlaten
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE43 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-16264

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Eckhard Platen Abstract Pricing under the Benchmark Approach The paper summarizes key results of the benchmark approach with a focus on the concept of benchmark-neutral pricing. It applies these results to the pricing of an extreme-maturity European put option on a well-diversified stock index. The growth optimal portfolio of the stocks is approximated by a well-diversified stock portfolio and modeled by a drifted time-transformed squared Bessel process of dimension four. It is shown that the benchmark-neutral price of a European put option is theoretically the minimal possible price and the respective risk-neutral put price turns out to be significantly more expensive. JEL Classification: G10, G11 Mathematics Subject Classification: 62P05, 60G35, 62P20 Key words and phrases: benchmark approach, benchmark-neutral pricing, growth optimal portfolio, squared Bessel process, European put option. 1 Introduction After some work on pricing of options under stochastic volatility, see, e.g., ? ), by applying the classical risk-neutral pricing methodology, the author concluded that risk-neutral extreme-maturity put option prices on a stock index, with decades to maturity, appeared to be overpriced. This insight motivated the development of the benchmark approach; see ? ), ? ), and ? ). By removing assumptions of the classical mathematical finance theory, presented, e.g., in ? ), the benchmark approach gives access to a wider modeling world. With its concept of real-world pricing , the benchmark approach employs the growth optimal portfolio (GOP) as a numéraire and the real-world probability measure as the respective pricing measure. The GOP is interchangeably called the Kelly portfolio, expected logarithmic utility-maximizing portfolio, or numéraire portfolio; see ? ), ? ), ? ), ? ), ? ), ? ), ? ), and ? ). It maximizes the growth rate and is the best-performing portfolio in the long run. The main assumptions for obtaining the real-world price of a contingent claim are extremely weak and consist of the existence of the GOP and the existence of the real-world conditional expectation of the contingent claim when denominated in the GOP; see ? ) and ? ). Real-world pricing provides theoretically the minimal possible prices for a replicable contingent claim. In practice, it is not easy to implement real-world pricing because the GOP of the entire financial market is a highly leveraged portfolio and is difficult to approximate by a guaranteed strictly positive portfolio. Due to this difficulty, in ? ) the concept of benchmark-neutral (BN) pricing was proposed. It employs the GOP of the market formed by the stocks (without the savings account) as a numéraire. If the respective BN pricing measure is an equivalent probability measure, then the BN pricing formula provides the same minimal possible prices as the real-word pricing formula. In ? ) it has been illustrated that for a realistic stock index model extreme maturity bonds are significantly less expensive than those obtained by risk-neutral pricing. Extreme maturity bonds are the typical building blocks of pension and life insurance products. Therefore, it matters for many people whether these prices are more expensive than necessary. The assumed existence of the GOP represents an extremely weak and easily verifiable assumption that the benchmark approach makes. It represents a no-arbitrage condition because ? ) and ? ) have shown that the existence of the GOP is equivalent to their No Unbounded Profit with Bounded Risk (NUPBR) no-arbitrage condition. This no-arbitrage condition is weaker than the No Free Lunch with Vanishing Risk (NFLVR) no-arbitrage condition of ? ), which is underpinning the classical mathematical finance theory; see, e.g., ? ). The current paper illustrates BN pricing for an extreme maturity put option on a well-diversified stock portfolio. It summarizes at first theoretical results that underpin the benchmark approach and BN pricing provided in ? ), ? ), ? ), and ? ). Later it employs the minimal market model (MMM), see ? ), by assuming that a well-diversified stock portfolio follows a time-transformed squared Bessel process of dimension four in some flexible activity time. The resulting BN price of an extreme-maturity European put option on a well-diversified stock portfolio is derived and illustrated using historical data. This price turns out to be significantly less expensive than the respective formally calculated risk-neutral price. The paper is organized as follows: Section 2 introduces the market setting and summarizes statements of the benchmark approach that will be applied later. Section 3 presents the concept of BN pricing. Finally, Section 4 prices a European put option under the MMM. 2 General Market Setting This section summarizes general results of the benchmark approach. 2.1 Primary Security Accounts Consider a continuous market, which consists of a set of m\in\{1,2,,...\} primary security accounts S^{1}_{t},...,S^{m}_{t} . When holding units of a primary security account, its owner is reinvesting in this account all interest payments, dividends, or other payments obtained or paid. For matrices and vectors \bf{x} we denote by {\bf{x}}^{\top} their transpose. Moreover, {\bf 1}=(1,\dots,1)^{\top} is a vector, and we write \bf 0 for a zero matrix or vector, where the dimensions follow from the context. Throughout the paper, the modeling is performed on a filtered probability space (\Omega,\mathcal{F},\underline{\cal{F}},P) , satisfying the usual conditions; see, e.g., ? ), and ? ). The filtration \underline{\cal{F}} =(\mathcal{F}_{t})_{t\in[0,\infty)} models the evolution of information relevant to the market model. The information available at time t\in[0,\infty) is captured by the sigma-algebra \mathcal{F}_{t} . The vector {\bf{S}}_{t}=(S^{1}_{t},...,S^{m}_{t})^{\top} of the strictly positive values of the primary security accounts at time t\in[0,\infty) is assumed to be a unique strong solution of the m -dimensional Itô-vector stochastic differential equation (SDE), see ? ), \frac{d{\bf{S}}_{t}}{{\bf{S}}_{t}}=\mu_{t}dt+{\bf{\sigma}}_{t}d{\bf{W}}_{t} ( 2.1 ) with vector of strictly positive initial values {\bf{S}}_{0} and a vector process {\bf{W}}=\{{\bf{W}}_{t}=(W^{1}_{t},\dots,W^{n}_{t})^{\top},t\in[0,\infty)\} of n\in\{1,2,...\} driving independent standard Brownian motions . The dynamics of the primary security accounts are determined by the expected return vector \mu_{t}=(\mu^{1}_{t},\dots,\mu^{m}_{t})^{\top} , and the volatility matrix {\bf{\sigma}}_{t}=[\sigma^{j,k}_{t}]_{j,k=1}^{m,n} for t\in[0,\infty) . Here we write \frac{d{\bf{S}}_{t}}{{\bf{S}}_{t}} for the n -vector of Itô-stochastic differentials (\frac{dS^{1}_{t}}{S^{1}_{t}},...,\frac{dS^{m}_{t}}{S^{m}_{t}})^{\top} . The components of the processes {\bf\mu} and \sigma , as well as other quantities and processes that will be employed, are assumed to have appropriate measurability and integrability properties so that all manipulations we will perform are permitted. In particular, the volatility matrix components are assumed to be predictable and square integrable. The components of the expected return vector are assumed to be predictable and integrable. 2.2 Portfolios The market participants can form portfolios by combining primary security accounts. If changes in the value of a portfolio are only due to changes in the values of the primary security accounts, then no extra funds flow in or out of the portfolio, and the corresponding portfolio and strategy are called self-financing . A positive self-financing portfolio S^{\pi}_{t} is described by its initial value S^{\pi}_{0}>0 and its weight process \pi=\{\pi_{t}=(\pi^{1}_{t},...,\pi^{m}_{t})^{\top},t\in[0,\infty)\} . The latter is describing the fractions of wealth invested in the respective securities, where \pi_{t}^{\top}{\bf 1}=1 ( 2.2 ) for t\in[0,\infty) . The value of a self-financing portfolio S^{\pi}_{t} satisfies the SDE \frac{dS^{\pi}_{t}}{S^{\pi}_{t}}=\pi_{t}^{\top}\frac{d{\bf{S}}_{t}}{{\bf{S}}_{t}}=\pi_{t}^{\top}\mu_{t}dt+\pi_{t}^{\top}{\bf{\sigma}}_{t}d{\bf{W}}_{t} ( 2.3 ) for t\in[0,\infty) . By application of the Itô formula, one can show that a portfolio that is self-financing in the denomination of one price process is also self-financing in the denomination of other price processes. If not otherwise stated, we consider self-financing portfolios. We introduce for a strictly

Read the complete text