Osiris revisited: Confirming a solar metallicity and low C/O in HD 209458 b
N. Bachmann, L. Kreidberg, P. Mollière, D. Deming, S.-M. Tsai · 2025
Read Osiris revisited: Confirming a solar metallicity and low C/O in HD 209458 b by N. Bachmann, L. Kreidberg, P. Mollière, D. Deming, S.-M. Tsai (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-16232.txt.
Introduction
A team led by Bachmann re-measured the air of a famous hot gas giant planet in a 2025 study. The planet, HD 209458 b, was the first of its kind found to cross its star. Fresh care with old space scope data let the team fix past flaws in how the light was read.
They joined the reworked light data with newer scope data and fit models of the planet air. Water and a key carbon gas showed up with strong proof. The mix of gases points to air much like our Sun in its metal share, with a low share of carbon next to oxygen. Such fine checks help sort how big planets form and move.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | N. Bachmann, L. Kreidberg, P. Mollière, D. Deming, S.-M. Tsai |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 85 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-16232
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Osiris revisited: Confirming a solar metallicity and low C/O in HD 209458 b N. Bachmann, L. Kreidberg, P. Mollière, D. Deming, S.-M. Tsai Abstract HD 209458 b is the prototypical hot Jupiter and one of the best targets available for precise atmosphere characterisation. Now that spectra from both Hubble Space Telescope (HST) and James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) are available, we can reveal the atmospheric properties in unprecedented detail. In this study, we perform a new data reduction and analysis of the original HST/WFC3 spectrum, accounting for the wavelength dependence of the instrument systematics that was not considered in previous analyses. This allows us to precisely and robustly measure the much-debated H 2 O \mathrm{H_{2}O} abundance in HD 209458 b’s atmosphere. We combine the newly reduced spectrum with archival JWST/NIRCam data and run free chemistry atmospheric retrievals over the 1.0 − 5.1 µ m $1.0\text{\,}$-$5.1\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro m}$ wavelength range, covering possible features of multiple absorbing species, including CO 2 \mathrm{CO_{2}} , CO \mathrm{CO} , CH 4 \mathrm{CH_{4}} , NH 3 \mathrm{NH_{3}} , HCN \mathrm{HCN} , Na \mathrm{Na} , SO 2 \mathrm{SO_{2}} , and H 2 S \mathrm{H_{2}S} . We detect H 2 O \mathrm{H_{2}O} and CO 2 \mathrm{CO_{2}} robustly at above 7 σ 7\text{\,}\sigma significance, and find a 3.6 σ 3.6\text{\,}\sigma preference for cloudy models compared to a clear atmosphere. For all other absorbers we tested, only upper limits of abundance can be measured. We use Bayesian model averaging to account for a range of different assumptions about the cloud properties, resulting in a water volume mixing ratio of 0.95 + 0.35 − 0.17 × 0.95^{+0.35}_{-0.17}\>\times solar and a carbon dioxide abundance of 0.94 + 0.16 − 0.09 × 0.94^{+0.16}_{-0.09}\>\times solar. Both results are consistent with solar values and comparable to predictions from the VULCAN 1D photochemistry model. Combining these values with a prior on the CO \mathrm{CO} abundance from ground-based measurements, we derive an overall atmospheric composition comparable to solar metallicity of [ M / H ] = 0.10 − 0.40 + 0.41 \mathrm{[M/H]}=0.10^{+0.41}_{-0.40} and very low C/O of 0.054 − 0.034 + 0.080 0.054^{+0.080}_{-0.034} with a 3 σ 3\text{\,}\sigma upper limit of 0.454 0.454 . This indicates a strong enrichment in oxygen and depletion in carbon during HD 209458 b’s formation. 1 Introduction HD 209458 b (also named Osiris) is one of the best characterised and most extensively studied exoplanets. Initially discovered through radial velocity measurements in 1999 ( Henry et al. 2000 ) , it was the first exoplanet observed transiting its host star ( Charbonneau et al. 2000 ; Henry et al. 2000 ) . Since then, it has become a prime target for transit observations ( Deming et al. 2013 ; Madhusudhan et al. 2014 ; MacDonald & Madhusudhan 2017 ; Giacobbe et al. 2021 ; Xue et al. 2024 , e.g.) due to its relatively bright host star and favourable planet-to-star radius ratio. HD 209458 b was the first exoplanet for which an atmosphere was observed ( Charbonneau et al. 2002 ) (though the detection was later called into question by ground-based observations Casasayas-Barris et al. 2020 ). An undisputed detection of the atmosphere came from HST/WFC3 spatial scan observations, which revealed a strong signature of water vapour ( Deming et al. 2013 ) . Water is among the easiest molecules to detect and analyse in exoplanetary atmospheres because of the numerous observable ro-vibrational bands in the near and mid-infrared, now accessible to multiple instruments. Additionally, water remains a key tracer of planet formation theories ( Öberg et al. 2011 ; Helled & Lunine 2014 ; Sing et al. 2016 ; Öberg & Bergin 2016 ) . Since the first atmospheric observations of HD 209458 b, clouds have been inferred in the transmission spectrum ( Charbonneau et al. 2002 ; Deming et al. 2013 ) to account for the low abundances measured. The water abundance in the atmosphere of HD 209458 b, as measured using retrieval techniques, has been a topic of ongoing debate. Earlier studies reported sub-solar water abundances ( <-4.5 in log volume mixing ratio) ( Madhusudhan et al. 2014 ; MacDonald & Madhusudhan 2017 ; Brogi et al. 2017 ; Welbanks et al. 2019 ; Pinhas et al. 2019 ) , therefore contradicting most planetary formation models, which predict solar or higher oxygen and water abundances based on core accretion scenarios ( Fortney et al. 2013 ; Öberg & Bergin 2016 ; Booth et al. 2017 ) . Potential explanations for the low water abundance include high-altitude opaque clouds or hazes, although such factors were considered in some of the analyses ( MacDonald & Madhusudhan 2017 ) . These studies were primarily based on the transmission spectrum observed with the Hubble Space Telescope’s (HST) Wide Field Camera 3 (WFC3) ( Deming et al. 2013 ) . However, more recent work has suggested higher water abundances, with some studies reporting solar to super-solar values based on the same HST data ( Line et al. 2016 ; Sing et al. 2016 ; Tsiaras et al. 2018 ; Welbanks & Madhusudhan 2021 ) . Additionally, several molecular absorbers, including sodium ( \mathrm{Na} ) ( Charbonneau et al. 2002 ) , methane ( \mathrm{CH_{4}} ), carbon monoxide ( \mathrm{CO} ), carbon dioxide ( \mathrm{CO_{2}} ) ( Swain et al. 2009 ; Madhusudhan & Seager 2009 ; Snellen et al. 2010 ) , ammonia ( \mathrm{NH_{3}} ), and/or hydrogen cyanide ( \mathrm{HCN} ) ( MacDonald & Madhusudhan 2017 ; Giacobbe et al. 2021 ) , have claimed findings in the planet’s transmission spectrum. The simultaneous detection of \mathrm{H_{2}O} and \mathrm{HCN} of Giacobbe et al. 2021 led to more discussion as it suggests a super-solar C/O ( \approx 1 ), but it could not be confirmed in later studies by Blain et al. 2024a and Xue et al. 2024 . Following the launch of the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) in December 2021, its high precision and resolution have made it a powerful tool for exoplanetary and atmospheric studies. JWST’s enhanced capabilities enable unprecedented spectral resolution, opening new possibilities for detecting molecules in exoplanetary atmospheres. Given its high signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) for transmission spectroscopy, HD 209458 b was one of the first targets observed with JWST’s NIRCam instrument. Xue et al. 2024 published the NIRCam transmission spectrum of HD 209458 b, along with an equilibrium chemistry retrieval analysis and a joint retrieval of their new spectrum with archival HST/WFC3 data. Their results support the presence of higher water abundances in the planet’s atmosphere ( Xue et al. 2024 ) due to the enrichment in oxygen supported by the low C/O and the comparable to solar metallicity. Most previous studies relied on the HST transmission spectrum published by Deming et al. 2013 , which was reduced using a different method than the one commonly used today. Therefore, for this study, we re-reduced the HST/WFC3 spectral data using the PACMAN pipeline ( Zieba & Kreidberg 2022 ) , with particular attention to instrument systematics. We compared two different approaches to address these. To investigate the previously reported low water abundances, we performed atmospheric retrievals on our newly reduced HST transmission spectrum, both individually and in combination with the JWST/NIRCam data ( Xue et al. 2024 )