Long Coalition Leads to Shrink? The Roles of Tipping and Technology-Sharing in Climate Clubs

Lei Zhu, Zhihao Yan, Hongbo Duan, Yongyang Cai, Xiaobing Zhang · 2025

Read Long Coalition Leads to Shrink? The Roles of Tipping and Technology-Sharing in Climate Clubs by Lei Zhu, Zhihao Yan, Hongbo Duan, Yongyang Cai, Xiaobing Zhang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-16162.txt.

Introduction

Yongyang Cai and co-authors study climate clubs in a 2025 paper whose head title frames the work as two margins of joint action. Clubs are groups of lands that cut their gas output as one. The team asks what holds such a club together as the world warms and a tipping point looms.

In their game, heat widens the gap in output between club lands and outsiders, so clubs shrink with time. The threat of a tip spurs more free-riding, which lifts output and shrinks clubs still more. Rich lands form the core, while growth lands drive the swings in who joins. The team weighs club perks against fines as glue.

Catalog record

CREATORLei Zhu, Zhihao Yan, Hongbo Duan, Yongyang Cai, Xiaobing Zhang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE96 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-16162

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Long Coalition Leads to Shrink? The Roles of Tipping and Technology-Sharing in Climate Clubs Lei Zhu, Zhihao Yan, Hongbo Duan, Yongyang Cai, Xiaobing Zhang Abstract Global cooperation is posited as a pivotal solution to address climate change, yet significant barriers, like free-riding, hinder its realization. This paper develops a dynamic game-theoretic model to analyze the stability of coalitions under multiple stochastic climate tippings, and a technology-sharing mechanism is designed in the model to combat free-ridings. Our results reveal that coalitions tend to shrink over time as temperatures rise, owing to potential free-ridings, despite a large size of initial coalition. The threat of climate tipping reduces the size of stable coalitions compared to the case where tipping is ignored. However, at post-tipping period, coalitions temporarily expand as regions respond to the shock, though this cooperation is short-lived and followed by further shrink. Notably, technology-sharing generates greater collective benefits than sanctions, suggesting that the proposed dynamic technology-sharing pathway bolsters coalition resilience against free-riding while limiting the global warming. This framework highlights the critical role of technology-sharing in fostering long-term climate cooperation under climate tipping uncertainties. Keywords: International climate cooperation; Tipping events; Technology-sharing; Stable coalition; Dynamic game; Markov strategy JEL Code: H23; Q51; Q54, Q55; Q58 1 Introduction Climate change represents one of the most pressing global challenges of our time, necessitating unprecedented cooperation among nations to mitigate its escalating impacts. As global temperatures continue to rise, the international community has sought to foster collective action through mechanisms such as the Paris Agreement. While this landmark accord has been criticized for its insufficient stringency to achieve the targeted temperature goals of 1.5°C or 2°C, it remains the largest coalition of its kind, with 194 signatory states as of 2023 1 1 1 https://unfccc.int/process-and-meetings/the-paris-agreement . The challenge of facilitating large-scale climate cooperation has been a central focus in the study of international environmental agreements (IEAs). A persistent obstacle, termed "the paradox of cooperation" by Barrett 1994 , arises from the inherent tension between individual and collective rationality: the greater the potential benefits of cooperation, the more difficult it becomes to sustain a large coalition. This phenomenon is theoretically substantiated by Finus et al. 2024 , who demonstrate that countries are incentivized to free-ride, opting to remain outside climate coalitions despite the collective benefits of participation. To address the free-rider problem in international climate negotiations, scholars have proposed the implementation of sanctions against non-participants ( Bahn et al. 2009 ; Breton et al. 2010 ). Nordhaus 2015 applies club theory to advocate for a uniform tariff mechanism to penalize non-member countries, arguing that such punitive measures can enhance cooperation levels and overall welfare without significantly disrupting trade efficiency. This approach has spurred a growing body of research exploring the role of trade sanctions in climate cooperation. For instance, Clausing and Wolfram 2023 highlight the potential of market access and border carbon adjustments (BCAs) to strengthen international climate mitigation efforts. In 2023, the European Union operationalized this concept through the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), which imposes carbon tariffs on carbon-intensive imports 2 2 2 https://taxation-customs.ec.europa.eu/carbon-border-adjustment-mechanism . However, the use of sanctions remains contentious. Critics argue that such measures may destabilize the existing international trade order. Ernst et al. 2023 employ a dynamic three-region multi-sector general equilibrium model to assess the welfare implications of carbon pricing and border adjustment taxes. Their findings suggest that while BCAs mitigate carbon leakage, they do not eliminate it, nor do they provide sufficient incentives for non-participating regions to join climate coalitions. Similarly, Hagen and Schopf 2024 examine the influence of industrial lobbying on coalition formation under BCAs, concluding that lobbying can exacerbate emissions and reduce welfare unless carbon tax revenues are redistributed to firms. In light of these challenges, alternative mechanisms to promote climate cooperation have been proposed, including intra-coalition payment transfers ( Eyckmans and Tulkens 2003 ; Bréchet et al. 2011 ; Fanokoa et al. 2011 ), solar geoengineering ( McEvoy et al. 2024 ), and technology-sharing ( Barrett 2013 ; Paroussos et al. 2019 ; Acemoglu et al. 2023 ). Nordhaus 2021 further contend that a dual approach-combining trade sanctions (such as tariffs) against non-members with low-carbon technology-sharing within the climate coalition- is essential to achieve cost-effective deep decarbonization. Despite their potential, these mechanisms have yet to be fully realized within the framework of the Paris Agreement, leaving an open question for further investigation. The urgency of climate cooperation is underscored by the risk of triggering abrupt and irreversible climate tipping events, which could precipitate catastrophic ecological and economic consequences (e.g., Kriegler et al. 2009 ; Solomon et al. 2009 ; Cai et al. 2016 ; Cai et al. 2017 ; Cai and Lontzek 2019 ). According to the IPCC’s Fifth Assessment Report, surpassing a global temperature increase of 2°C ( IPCC 2014 ) —or even 1.5°C ( IPCC 2022 ) —above pre-industrial levels could lead to devastating outcomes, including glacial melt, sea-level rise, and biodiversity loss. While the literature extensively discusses tipping events (e.g., Lenton et al. 2008 ; Solomon et al. 2009 ; Dietz et al. 2021 ), fewer studies have quantified their economic impacts (e.g., Alley et al. 2003 ; Lenton 2011 ; Weitzman 2012 ; Berger et al. 2016 ; Heutel et al. 2016 ; Daniel et al. 2019 ). The timing and likelihood of these tipping events depend critically on the effectiveness of global emission regulation and temperature control. The threat of tipping events may influence international cooperation, as regions adjust their emission strategies in response to potential catastrophes. Scholars have integrated tipping thresholds into integrated assessment models (IAMs) to explore optimal climate policies, such as carbon taxes, under the threat of tipping events (e.g., de Zeeuw and Zemel 2012 ; Lontzek et al. 2015 ; Cai et al. 2016 ; Nkuiya and Costello 2016 ; van der Ploeg and de Zeeuw 2018 ; Cai et al. 2017 ; Cai and Lontzek 2019 ). However, much of this research focuses on extreme cases of full cooperation or non-cooperation, with limited attention to partially cooperative arrangements and coalition stability ( Barrett 2013 ; Nkuiya 2015 ; van der Ploeg and de Zeeuw 2016 ). In this paper, we develop a dynamic game-theoretic model to investigate the formation and stability of coalitions among heterogeneous regions in the context of climate tipping events. The model builds on the literature on international environmental agreements (IEAs), which has explored various assumptions, including homogeneity versus heterogeneity among regions (e.g., Fuentes-Albero and Rubio 2010 ; Kolstad 2010 ), static versus dynamic game structures (e.g., Barrett 1999 ; Rubio and Ulph 2007 ), and deterministic versus stochastic frameworks (e.g., Kolstad 2007 ; Finus and Pintassilgo 2011 ). Additionally, the robustness of these models has been examined through both non-parametric and parametric approaches (e.g., Karp and Simon 2013 ; Lessmann et al. 2015 ). By deriving Markov strategies for emissions among member and non-member regions, our heterogeneous dynamic model provides a more nuanced understanding of how coalitions evolve over time and in response to rising temperatures, offering both theoretical and practical insights. Our model extends the frontier of IEA research in several aspects: First, we focus on the conditions necessary to establish and maintain a grand coalition among heterogeneous regions in a

Read the complete text