Evidence for a steeper SMBH–Bulge mass relationship extended to low masses using TDE host galaxies 2021 Evidence for a steeper SMBH–Bulge mass relationship extended to low masses using TDE host galaxies – A

Paige Ramsden, Matt Nicholl, Sean L. McGee, Andrew Mummery · 2025

Read Evidence for a steeper SMBH–Bulge mass relationship extended to low masses using TDE host galaxies 2021 Evidence for a steeper SMBH–Bulge mass relationship extended to low masses using TDE host galaxies – A by Paige Ramsden, Matt Nicholl, Sean L. McGee, Andrew Mummery (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-16155.txt.

Introduction

Paige Ramsden, Matt Nicholl, Sean McGee, and Andrew Mummery extend, in 2025, the known link between a galaxy's central black hole and its bulge of stars to much smaller black holes. Events where a star is torn apart by a black hole reveal small ones that would otherwise stay hidden. The team studied forty such events with late, steady glow.

From that glow they estimated black hole masses, and from galaxy light they estimated bulge masses. Combined with heavier known systems, the overall relation came out steeper than older estimates. Modeling showed selection effects explain the flatter fit within the new sample, but not the steepening overall.

Catalog record

CREATORPaige Ramsden, Matt Nicholl, Sean L. McGee, Andrew Mummery
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE62 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-16155

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Evidence for a steeper SMBH–Bulge mass relationship extended to low masses using TDE host galaxies 2021 Evidence for a steeper SMBH–Bulge mass relationship extended to low masses using TDE host galaxies – A Paige Ramsden, Matt Nicholl, Sean L. McGee, Andrew Mummery Abstract Tidal disruption events (TDEs) are excellent tools for probing low mass supermassive black holes (SMBHs) that may otherwise remain undetected. Here, we present an extended SMBH–Bulge mass scaling relationship using these lower mass TDE black holes and their host galaxies. Bulge masses are derived using Prospector fits to UV-MIR spectral energy distributions for the hosts of 40 TDEs that have a detected late-time UV/optical plateau emission, from which a SMBH mass is derived. Overall, we find that TDE plateaus are a successful method for probing BH scaling relations. We combine the observed TDE sample with a higher mass SMBH sample and extend the known relationship, recovering a steeper slope ( m = 1.34 ± 0.03 m=1.34\pm 0.03 ) than current literature estimates, which focus on the high mass regime. For the TDE only sample, we measure an equally significant but shallower relationship with a power-law slope of m = 1.17 ± 0.10 m=1.17\pm 0.10 and significance < 0.001 <0.001 . Forward modelling is used to determine whether known selection effects can explain both the comparatively flatter TDE only relation and the overall steepening across the full SMBH mass range. We find that the flattening at TDE masses can be accounted for, however the steepening can not. It appears that if a single slope extends for the whole BH mass range, it must be steeper to include the TDE population. 1 Introduction With supermassive black holes (SMBHs) residing in the nuclei of most galaxies, tidal disruption events (TDEs) occur when an unfortunate star is perturbed into the galactic centre. The star is torn apart when the tidal forces it experiences overcome its own self-gravity ( Hills 1975 ; Rees 1988 ) . If the orbital pericentre is close to the critical ‘tidal radius’, and that tidal radius lies outside of the black hole’s event horizon, it is theorised that roughly half of the stellar debris becomes bound to the SMBH and the resulting accretion of this bound matter produces an observable flare ( Lacy & Townes 1982 ) . If instead the star intersects the horizon before disruption (i.e. the tidal radius is inside the gravitational radius), it will be swallowed whole and no flare will be observed. This criterion that the tidal radius must lie outside the gravitational radius, introduces a critical SMBH mass, the Hills mass, below which TDEs can be observed ( Hills 1975 ) . For a main-sequence star of mass M_{*} \sim 1 {\rm M}_{\odot} , and radius R_{*} \sim 1 {\rm R}_{\odot} , the maximum mass for a SMBH that can produce an observable TDE is \lesssim 10^{8}{\rm M}_{\odot} . Note that as well as depending strongly on SMBH mass, this critical Hills mass is also impacted by spin. For a maximally rotating SMBH the Hills limit softens, enabling observations of TDEs around somewhat more massive SMBHs ( Mummery 2024 ) . By nature, TDEs are excellent probes for the lower mass-regime of black holes, successfully identifying systems that would otherwise lie undetected. These events also provide the opportunity to study accretion physics, the evolution of SMBHs over cosmic time, and the link between SMBHs and their host environments. In comparison to other transient events, TDEs remain intrinsically rare. However, they are now routinely found by wide-field, time-domain surveys, with an estimated occurrence rate of one every 10 4-5 years per galaxy ( Yao et al. 2023 ; Sazonov et al. 2021 ) . While similar in brightness to some supernovae (SNe), with a characteristic luminosity of \sim 10^{44} erg s -1 , they have been detected only in galactic nuclei and have a distinct lack of colour evolution; a longer rise and fade time than most SNe; and a slow decay often approximated as a power-law or exponential over time ( Phinney 1989 ; van Velzen et al. 2011 ) . Certain spectroscopic features also distinguish TDEs from other transients, including a strong blue continuum with colour temperature of 10,000 - 50,000 K and broad emission lines ( Hung et al. 2017 ) . Studies of BH demographics ( Kormendy & Ho 2013 ) have shown that SMBH properties correlate strongly with those of the galaxies that host them, and relationships linking SMBH mass with galaxy bulge mass and velocity dispersion were derived ( Häring & Rix 2014 ; Gebhardt et al. 2000 ; Ferrarese & Merritt 2000 ; Magorrian et al. 1998 ) . Constraining the slopes of these relationships enables the estimation of SMBH masses for large samples, furthering our understanding of early structure formation and the evolution of SMBHs ( Gültekin et al. 2009 ; McConnell & Ma 2013 ) . Particularly at low masses, the slope of BH scaling relations may reflect the physical mechanisms by which SMBHs grow ( Greene et al. 2020 ) . However, as most direct estimates of SMBH masses (outside of a handful of very nearby galaxies) are made by reverberation mapping in active galactic nuclei, relationships are often derived using samples dominated by SMBHs of mass \gtrsim 10^{7} M ⊙ ( Kormendy & Ho 2013 ; Bentz et al. 2013 ; McConnell & Ma 2013 , e.g.) . In addition to reverberation mapping, BH demographics can be explored using alternative techniques such as AGN broad line measurements ( Reines & Volonteri 2015 ) , megamaser disks ( Greene et al. 2016 ) , and stellar kinematics ( Krajnović et al. 2018 ; Thater et al. 2019 ; Nguyen et al. 2019 ) . These methods can probe lower mass black hole samples and allow for a broader analysis of the correlation between SMBH and stellar mass ( Reines & Volonteri 2015 ; Greene et al. 2020 ) . Often, when dealing with intermediate-mass black holes or low-mass host galaxies, studies consider the relation in terms of total stellar mass rather than bulge mass due to challenges in resolving bulges through ground-based imaging. However, the tightest correlations appear to be between the SMBH and bulge properties ( Kormendy & Ho 2013 ) . The limiting Hills mass restricts TDEs to the lower end of the SMBH mass function. This has been confirmed by previous TDE host galaxy studies, which estimate SMBH masses using established galaxy scaling relations, finding them to be in the range 10^{4}\lesssim M_{\text{BH}}\lesssim 10^{8} M ⊙ ( Wevers et al. 2019 ; Yao et al. 2023 ) . These estimates assume that the scaling relations derived at high galaxy mass also apply in the lower mass hosts of TDEs. However, if SMBH masses can be inferred directly using TDE emission, rather than properties of the host, TDEs could provide the perfect opportunity to test this assumption. With a large enough sample, TDEs could even be used to improve the calibration of scaling relations at the low mass end, and to test whether this differs from the high-mass regime. If we find that properties of TDE-selected BHs do couple with those of their hosts, the TDE BH demographic can be

Read the complete text