Short–Range Hard–Sphere Potential and Coulomb Interaction: Deser–Trueman Formula for Rydberg States of Exotic Atomic Systems
Gregory S. Adkins, Ulrich D. Jentschura · 2025
Read Short–Range Hard–Sphere Potential and Coulomb Interaction: Deser–Trueman Formula for Rydberg States of Exotic Atomic Systems by Gregory S. Adkins, Ulrich D. Jentschura (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-15973.txt.
Introduction
Gregory Adkins and Ulrich Jentschura derived a formula for strong-force shifts in exotic atoms in 2025. Atoms with a hadron in place of an electron feel the nuclear force at close range, and its effect on energy levels defies standard perturbation theory. High-spin Rydberg states of such atoms are prized hunting grounds for new physics.
The pair generalized the Deser-Trueman formula to any hydrogen-like state, labeled by its size and spin quantum numbers. The shift scales with the hadronic radius against the Bohr radius, raised to a power set by the spin. A double-factorial term in the denominator crushes the shift for high spins. The closed form lets experimenters estimate corrections instead of guessing.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gregory S. Adkins, Ulrich D. Jentschura |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 21 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-15973
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Short–Range Hard–Sphere Potential and Coulomb Interaction: Deser–Trueman Formula for Rydberg States of Exotic Atomic Systems Gregory S. Adkins, Ulrich D. Jentschura Abstract In exotic atomic systems with hadronic constituent particles, it is notoriously difficult to estimate the strong-interaction correction to energy levels. It is well known that, due to the strength of the nuclear interaction, the problem cannot be treated on the basis of Wigner–Brioullin perturbation theory. Recently, high-angular-momentum Rydberg states of exotic atomic systems with hadronic constituents have been identified as promising candidates for the search of New Physics in the low-energy sector of the Standard Model. In order to render this endeavor feasible, it is necessary to estimate the strong-interaction correction to the atomic energy levels. We thus derive a generalized Deser–Trueman formula for the induced energy shift for a general hydrogenic bound state with principal quantum number n n and orbital angular momentum quantum number ℓ \ell , and find that the energy shift is given by the formula δ E = 2 α n , ℓ β ℓ ( a h / a 0 ) 2 ℓ + 1 E h / n 3 \delta E=2\alpha_{n,\ell}\,\beta_{\ell}\,(a_{h}/a_{0})^{2\ell+1}E_{h}/n^{3} , where α n , 0 = 1 \alpha_{n,0}=1 , α n , ℓ = ∏ s = 1 ℓ ( s − 2 − n − 2 ) \alpha_{n,\ell}=\prod_{s=1}^{\ell}(s^{-2}-n^{-2}) , β ℓ = ( 2 ℓ + 1 ) / [ ( 2 ℓ + 1 ) !! ] 2 \beta_{\ell}=(2\ell+1)/[(2\ell+1)!!]^{2} , where E h E_{h} is the Hartree energy, a h a_{h} is the hadronic radius and a 0 a_{0} is the generalized Bohr radius. The square of the double factorial, [ ( 2 ℓ + 1 ) !! ] 2 [(2\ell+1)!!]^{2} , in the denominator implies a somewhat fortunate, drastic suppression of the effect for higher angular momenta. The results are verified by numerical calculations on an exponential lattice with 20,000 points. I Introduction Recently, the Rydberg states of exotic hadronic atomic systems have been proposed as candidates for the search for New Physics effects as additions to the low-energy sector BaEtAl2025 . Examples include antiprotonic atoms BaEtAl2025 , as well as K -mesic atoms (see Ref. Tr1961 ) such as those involving a negatively charged K meson and a proton ( K^{-} –p) or deuteron ( K^{-} –d), and protonium, the bound system of a proton and its antiparticle (see Refs. CaRiWy1992 ; BaFrGa2001 ; KlBaMaRi2002 ). In general, the search for New Physics effects SaEtAl2018 on the basis of Rydberg states of two-body exotic hadronic atomic systems is very promising because of the extreme field strengths experienced at a distance equal to the generalized Bohr radius can exceed the Schwinger critical field strength, (for muonic bound systems, see Fig. 3 of Ref. Je2015muonic ). It is of crucial importance to estimate the effects due to the strong interaction, which becomes dominant at distances commensurate with a_{h}=1\,{\rm fm} . While previous papers Tr1961 ; CaRiWy1992 ; BaFrGa2001 ; KlBaMaRi2002 have put an emphasis on S and P states, novel approaches (see, e.g. , Ref. BaEtAl2025 ) call for generalizations to states with high angular momenta. This latter fact necessitates a generalization of the Deser–Trueman formulas DeGoBaTh1954 ; BedH1955 ; By1957 ; Tr1961 for arbitrary excited states, which is the subject of the current paper. According to Sec. 3 of Ref. KlBaMaRi2002 , a suitable approximation for the incorporation of strong-interaction effects into the discussion of energy levels of electromagnetically bound particle-antiparticle systems consists in the addition of an intense, short-range (radius a_{h} ) potential, which can be assumed to approximate a hard-sphere potential for r\leq a_{h} . Such intense, short-range hard-sphere (infinitely intense) potentials, when added to a long-range Coulomb potential, cannot be treated on the basis of Wigner–Brioullin perturbation theory (for a recent overview, see Chap. 5 of Ref. JeAd2022book ). This is because the expectation value of a hard-sphere potential (which assumes an infinite value inside the core) is infinite for any bound state in a Coulomb potential. Rather, one needs to apply so-called radius perturbation theory where the expansion parameter is the ratio a_{h}/a_{0} of the radius a_{h} of the hard-sphere potential and the Bohr radius a_{0} . The calculation of the shift E_{n}\to E_{n}+\delta E due to the hard-sphere potential has been considered by Deser et al. (see Ref. DeGoBaTh1954 ) and Trueman (see Ref. Tr1961 ), and is therefore commonly referred to as the Deser–Trueman formula (see Refs. BaDe1999 ; MiIv2001 ; De2001scat ; YaEtAl2009 ; NuSuYaFa2009 ; BoHivD2010 ; RiFa2017 ; MoHoRi2020 . It is generally assumed [see, e.g. , Eq. (3.69) of Ref. KlBaMaRi2002 ] that the energy perturbation takes the form \delta E=f(n,\ell)\,\left(\frac{a_{h}}{a_{0}}\right)^{2\ell+1}\,, (1) where f(n,\ell) remains to be determined. The problem of the calculation of \delta E arises in hadronic bound systems such as protonium Ba1989 ; CaRiWy1992 ; BaFrGa2001 ; KlBaMaRi2002 , and in other bound systems where hadrons are the constituent particles. (The concept of the Bohr radius finds a natural generalization in these systems as a_{0}=\hbar/(\alpha m_{r}c) , where m_{r} is the reduced mass.) It is well known that the nucleon-antinucleon potential is more attractive than the nucleon-nucleon potential, in view of the fact that \omega -meson exchange flips sign and becomes attractive Ri2020 . For Coulombic bound systems where the constituent particles are hadrons and annihilation is involved, this means that, for very close approach r\leq a_{h}\sim 1\,{\rm fm} , the strong interaction leads to immediate annihilation of the particles. The wave function of the Coulombic bound system thus needs to vanish inside the range of the strong interaction, typically assumed to be of the order of a_{h}\sim 1\,{\rm fm} . Therefore, the strong-interaction potential, on the scale of the Bohr radius, acts, somewhat counter-intuitively, as a hard-sphere potential. One thus needs to calculate the perturbed energies under the assumption that the wave functions vanish for r<a_{h} , as induced by the potential V_{h} . Hence, again, somewhat counter-intuitively, the strong-interaction correction shifts the bound-state energies of protonium upwards in energy, i.e., it reduces the (modulus of the) binding energy. The necessity to calculate \delta E has been recognized in the early days of the analysis of mesic atoms DeGoBaTh1954 ; By1957 ; Tr1961 ; Ba1989 ; KlBaMaRi2002 . Our goal here is to derive a formula for \delta E which is valid for general quantum numbers n and \ell , and to verify the result based on numerical calculations (see Sec. II.2 ). The latter require the use of extended-precision arithmetic, because, for higher \ell , the perturbations \delta E becomes very small in view of the their scaling with (a_{h}/a_{0})^{2\ell+1} (see Sec. III ). Conclusions are drawn in Sec. IV . II Derivation II.1 Mathematical Foundations Let us now discuss the mathematical details; these are quite straightforward. We consider the physical system where a short-range hard-sphere potential, V_{h}(r)=\left\{\begin{array}[]{cc}\infty&\qquad r\leq a_{h}\\ 0&\qquad r>a_{h}\end{array}\right.\,, (2) perturbs an attractive Coulomb potential V_{c}(r)=-\frac{e^{2}}{4\pi\epsilon_{0}r}=-\frac{E_{h}a_{0}}{r}\,. (3) Here, e is the electron charge, \epsilon_{0} is the vacuum permittivity, c is the speed of light, and \hbar is Planck’s unit of action. The Hartree energy is E_{h}\equiv m_{r}c^{2}\alpha^{2} , and a_{0} is the Bohr radius as defined earlier. It is