Assessing the impact of Binarization for Writer Identification in Greek Papyrus
Dominic Akt, Marco Peer, Florian Kleber · 2025
Read Assessing the impact of Binarization for Writer Identification in Greek Papyrus by Dominic Akt, Marco Peer, Florian Kleber (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-15852.txt.
Introduction
Dominic Akt, Marco Peer, and Florian Kleber test a photo prep step in a 2025 paper on old Greek papyrus. To name a scribe by hand, models first turn the page to pure black and white. That cut stops the model from learning the page stains, but old pages are torn, stained, and streaked with fibers.
The team sets old hand craft cuts next to deep learning cuts, with and sans a custom boost trick. Each cut is then graded by how well the scribe hunt runs after it. The chain shows that prep worth flows straight into the end score. Archive teams gain a ranked prep kit for frail pages.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dominic Akt, Marco Peer, Florian Kleber |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-15852
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Assessing the impact of Binarization for Writer Identification in Greek Papyrus Dominic Akt, Marco Peer, Florian Kleber Abstract This paper tackles the task of writer identification for Greek papyri. A common preprocessing step in writer identification pipelines is image binarization, which prevents the model from learning background features. This is challenging in historical documents, in our case Greek papyri, as background is often non-uniform, fragmented, and discolored with visible fiber structures. We compare traditional binarization methods to state-of-the-art Deep Learning (DL) models, evaluating the impact of binarization quality on subsequent writer identification performance. DL models are trained with and without a custom data augmentation technique, as well as different model selection criteria are applied. The performance of these binarization methods, is then systematically evaluated on the DIBCO 2019 dataset. The impact of binarization on writer identification is subsequently evaluated using a state-of-the-art approach for writer identification. The results of this analysis highlight the influence of data augmentation for DL methods. Furthermore, findings indicate a strong correlation between binarization effectiveness on papyri documents of DIBCO 2019 and downstream writer identification performance. 1 Introduction Writer retrieval and writer classification are tasks in the field of document analysis, with applications ranging from historical research to forensics [ 1 ] . Writer retrieval aims to identify documents written by the same writer, based on handwriting similarities, by returning a ranked list of potential matches. In contrast, writer classification seeks to assign a given document image to one author from a predefined set of known writers by returning a single author label. Although writer identification and writer classification are sometimes used interchangeably in the literature, this work defines “writer identification” as an umbrella term encompassing both writer retrieval and writer classification tasks. Deep Learning (DL) approaches, particularly unsupervised DL methods, have demonstrated comparable or even superior performance to “classical” supervised techniques in paleographic tasks [ 2 ] . A fundamental preprocessing step for most DL-based writer identification approaches is image binarization [ 3 ] , which converts color or grayscale document images into binary images, separating text (foreground) from background. Binarization is essential because it prevents models from learning background features, allowing the model to focus exclusively on the characteristics of the author’s handwriting. The challenges and potential benefits of automated writer identification become particularly evident when dealing with ancient papyri. Paleographic experts face the challenge of analyzing large collections of ancient papyri, many of which lack author attribution or dates [ 4 ] . Specifically, writer retrieval can assist experts by automatically grouping unattributed fragments that may belong together, enabling the reconstruction of larger texts or identifying the output of a single scribe. Writer classification, on the other hand, can help experts attribute newly found or analyzed fragments to known writers. DL methods are the current state of the art for writer identification [ 5 ] . While binarization is a well-studied problem for machine printed text or handwriting on paper, applying it to historical documents such as papyri presents unique challenges. Papyri can suffer from severe degradation as some of the earliest Greek papyri found date back to 400 BCE [ 6 ] . They exhibit degradations such as faded text, visible fiber structures, and fragmentation reducing the accuracy of traditional binarization methods for distinguishing text from background. DL approaches are able to effectively binarize degraded images because they learn context-dependent features. Traditional methods, in contrast, depend on histograms or local statistics, making them more susceptible to errors when dealing with image degradations [ 7 ] . The central aim of this work is to systematically evaluate the impact of binarization techniques on the performance of writer identification, particularly in the context of Greek papyrus. Also, an augmentation is proposed to enhance binarization. To summarize, the key contributions are: • A data augmentation methodology to adapt existing binarization datasets for improved performance on Greek papyri. • An analysis between binarization quality and subsequent writer identification performance, demonstrating that the PSNR metric on papyri (DIBCO 2019 [ 8 ] Set B) serves as the most effective indicator for selecting binarization models that optimize writer identification. • The identification of the most effective model selection metric (F-Measure) for training DL-based binarization models in the context of papyri. The paper is organized as follows. Section 2 describes the datasets and presents the methodology for the proposed augmentation technique, the training of DL binarization models, and the subsequent writer identification approach. Section 3 presents and discusses the results for both binarization and writer identification, as well as an analysis of their correlation, and Section 4 concludes the paper. 2 Methodology This section details the methodology employed for training and evaluating DL models binarization performance. It outlines the datasets used for training and validation, as well as the developed augmentation method. Subsequently, the writer identification pipeline, which is based on the approach proposed by Christlein et al. [ 3 ] , is described. 2.1 Datasets The dataset used for training and validation of the DL binarization models includes the following datasets: DIBCO (2009-2013, 2017), H-DIBCO (2014, 2016, 2018) [ 9 ] [ 10 ] [ 11 ] , BICKLEY a collection of Ms. Anna Felton Bickley’s handwritten diary (1922 to 1926) [ 12 ] , Monk Cuper Set (MCS) containing a series of 17th-century scholarly handwritten letters (in multiple languages) [ 13 ] , Handwritten Malayalam palm leaf manuscript dataset (HMPLMD) containing images of palm leaves inscribed with Malayalam script [ 14 ] , and Persian Heritage Image Binarization Dataset (PHIBD) containing images of historical Persian manuscripts from a library in Yazd, Iran, which also exhibit various types of degradation, including bleed-through, faded ink and blur [ 15 ] . The DIBCO 2019 [ 8 ] dataset used for DL model binarization performance evaluation consists of 20 image-ground truth pairs, partitioned into two parts: Set A and Set B, each containing 10 image-ground truth pairs. Set A includes images representing common challenges found within the DIBCO series, containing images featuring predominantly black text on white background, while Set B is exclusively composed of images of papyri fragments. For writer retrieval and identification evaluation, the GRK-Papyri dataset [ 4 ] is utilized. This dataset contains 50 labeled images of Greek papyri fragments from approximately 600 CE, where each image is attributed to one out of the 10 scribes. 2.2 Data Augmentation A data augmentation method is developed to enhance DL models’ performance on papyri. The objective is to specifically adapt the training dataset by simulating key visual characteristics found in papyrus documents such as fiber structure. This involves applying two primary augmentations to existing training images: Firstly, the application of papyrus textures such as those found in collections like GRK-Papyri [ 4 ] and secondly, the simulation of the irregular, degraded edges characteristic of papyrus fragments. When augmenting the dataset, HMPLMD [ 14 ] is excluded, since its images are already similar in color and texture. For the augmentation GRK-120 [ 4 ] is used, which is an extension of the GRK-Papyri [ 4 ] dataset. Figure 1: Two Step Augmentation Process The first augmentation involves recreating a similar background featuring fiber structure by removing writing from images sampled from GRK-120 [ 4 ] . A pretrained DP-LinkNet [