Ultraviolet spectra of comets: Rejecting the detection of pentacene, toluene, and Fe +
G. ROUILLÉ 1,* · 2025
Read Ultraviolet spectra of comets: Rejecting the detection of pentacene, toluene, and Fe + by G. ROUILLÉ 1,* (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-15550.txt.
Introduction
Gaël Rouillé rejects three claimed detections in comet spectra in a 2025 paper. A recent study said it found two organic molecules, pentacene and toluene, plus an iron ion, in the ultraviolet glow of many comets. Rouillé compared those comet spectra against lab spectra of the claimed molecules. The matches, he finds, do not hold up.
Lab data on the molecules in cold matrices and jets show none of the features the claim rests on. Iron reference data likewise fail to support the iron line. Since no lab spectrum of pentacene gas in this range exists, he computed one from theory. That synthetic spectrum gives future searches a proper template. The paper is a caution on naming new molecules in space from shaky matches.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | G. ROUILLÉ 1,* |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-15550
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Ultraviolet spectra of comets: Rejecting the detection of pentacene, toluene, and Fe + G. ROUILLÉ 1,* Abstract A recent study announced the detection of three bands in the ultraviolet emission spectra of more than a dozen comets, assigning two of them to pentacene (C 22 H 14 ) and the third one to toluene (C 7 H 8 ). The comparison of the spectra with the results of exploitable laboratory measurements on rare-gas-matrix-isolated pentacene and on jet-cooled toluene does not reveal elements that would justify the assignment, which is therefore unsubstantiated. The study also claimed the detection of an Fe II line in the gas of all but one comet. Yet, spectroscopic data on Fe II do not corroborate the attribution. Because spectroscopic measurements on the ultraviolet emission of pentacene in the gas phase are not available, this work also presents a synthetic spectrum of the S 5 → \rightarrow S 0 transition relevant to the wavelength range of the observations. Calculated using density functional theory and its time-dependent extension, the synthetic spectrum may facilitate the search for pentacene fluorescence in cometary spectra until laboratory measurements are accessible. \affilOne 1 Astrophysical Institute and University Observatory, Friedrich Schiller University Jena, Schillergässchen 2-3, D-07745 Jena, Germany. keywords Comets—Spectroscopy—Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons—Pentacene—Toluene. \corres [email protected] \msinfo 1 January 20151 January 2015 \artcitid #### \volnum 000 0000 \pgrange 1– \lp 1 1 Introduction Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) molecules represent a major part of cosmic substances and they are present in cometary matter. First, with various degrees of certainty, observers identified fluorescence bands of free phenanthrene (C 14 H 10 ), pyrene (C 16 H 10 ), and anthracene (C 14 H 10 ) molecules in the coma of comet 1P/Halley ( Moreels e t a l . 1994 ; Clairemidi e t a l . 2004 ; Clairemidi e t a l . 2008 , respectively) . Then, leaving no room for doubt as to the presence of PAH substances in comets, mass spectrometry of organic matter from grains collected by space probe Stardust in the coma of comet 81P/Wild 2 revealed, among others, PAH molecules naphthalene (C 10 H 8 ), phenanthrene, and pyrene, as well as several of their alkylated derivatives ( Sandford e t a l . 2006 ; Clemett e t a l . 2010 ) . Later, on-site measurements by mass spectrometer ROSINA on board the Rosetta probe evidenced benzene and toluene in the gas of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko ( Schuhmann e t a l . 2019 ) . Recently, Venkataraman e t a l . 2023 announced the detection of pentacene (C 22 H 14 ) and toluene (C 7 H 8 ) in the gas of more than a dozen comets after identifying fluorescence bands of the two aromatic substances in the ultraviolet (UV) emission spectra of the objects. The identification of pentacene and toluene bands in the spectra is, however, unsubstantiated when considering laboratory measurements published in the literature. The detection of Fe II in the comae of the same comets except one is also uncorroborated. 2 Observations Venkataraman e t a l . 2023 proposed a new analysis of cometary spectra measured with the International Ultraviolet Explorer (IUE), no longer in operation, and the Hubble Space Telescope (HST). Together, the Short-Wavelength Spectrograph (SWS) and Long-Wavelength Spectrograph (LWS) of IUE covered the 1150–3200 Å range ( Boggess e t a l . 1978 ) . Equipping the HST and both currently operational, the Cosmic Origins Spectrograph (COS) and the Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph (STIS) cover the 900–3200 Å ( McCandliss e t a l . 2010 ; Green e t a l . 2012 ; Hirschauer, A. S., et al. 2024 ) and 1150–10300 Å ( Medallon, S., Rickman, E., Brown, J., et al. 2023 ) ranges, respectively. The above-mentioned instruments allowed researchers to analyse the light produced by comets, in particular the sunlight-induced UV fluorescence of their gas. Thus, studies clearly identified lines and bands of several atomic and molecular species. For example, Feldman e t a l . 1980 and Weaver e t a l . 1981 identified emission features of H I , C I , O I , S I , OH, CO, C 2 , S 2 , CS, and CO {}_{2}^{+} in the spectra of comets Bradfield 1979l and Meier 1980q, alternatively denoted C/1979 Y1 and C/1980 V1, respectively, in the current style. To illustrate such an analysis, Figures 1 and 2 show emission spectra of comet Bradfield 1979l measured with the long- and short-wavelength spectrometers of IUE within a few hours on the same day, after which the emission flux decreased. Feldman e t a l . 1980 and A’Hearn & Feldman 1980 identified all clear lines and bands. Figure 1: Emission spectra LWR06607 and LWR06608 of comet Bradfield 1979l obtained on 10 January 1980 with the long-wavelength redundant (LWR) camera of IUE/LWS. Bradfield 1979l was then at 0.711 AU from the Sun ( A’Hearn & Feldman 1980 ) . The vertical grey bands indicate saturated pixels. (a) Spectrum LWR06607, shorter exposure time. Assignment according to Feldman e t a l . 1980 and A’Hearn & Feldman 1980 , except for the (1,1) and (1,2) bands of CS A–X (this work, Section 4 ). (b) Spectrum LWR06608, longer exposure time. The vertical dashed lines indicate the 1902, 2510, 2681, and 2795 \AA wavelength positions reported by Venkataraman e t a l . 2023 . Figure 2: Emission spectrum SWP07625 of comet Bradfield 1979l on 10 January 1980 obtained with the short-wavelength prime (SWP) camera of IUE/SWS. Bradfield 1979l was then at 0.711 AU from the Sun ( A’Hearn & Feldman 1980 ) . The vertical grey band signals saturated pixels. (a) Assignment according to Feldman e t a l . 1980 . (b) Vertically magnified view. Bands of the Fourth Positive system of CO, unmarked here, appear weakly between 1400 and 1650 Å ( Feldman e t a l . 1980 ; Tozzi e t a l . 1998 ) . The vertical dashed line indicates the 1902 \AA wavelength position reported by Venkataraman e t a l . 2023 . As comets release both gas and dust, the light that reveals their comae comprises not only the fluorescence of free atoms and molecules, but also the sunlight reflected and scattered by dust grains. The relative strengths of the gas fluorescence and reflected sunlight depend on parameters such as the comet composition and its position at the time of the observation. The solar irradiance spectrum being known ( Mount & Rottman 1981 ; Woods e t a l . 1996 , see, for instance,) , it is possible to separate the two contributions. Thus, Feldman 1997 subtracted the reflected sunlight from the UV spectrum of comet Hale-Bopp (C/1995 O1). Figure 3 compares a spectrum of another comet, Machholz 1994r (C/1994 T1), 1 1 1 Venkataraman e t a l . 2023 mistakenly attributed data LWP29389 to Machholz 1986e (96P/1986 J2). with the solar irradiance of the time and shows that the cometary spectrum consists mostly of reflected sunlight. Indeed, the