Searching for Kerr in string amplitudes Preprint: CCTP-2025-05 ITCP-IPP-2025/05 QMUL-PH-25-12

F. Alessio ♮ , P. Di Vecchia †,∇ , M. Firrotta ♭ , P. Pichini ‡ · 2025

Read Searching for Kerr in string amplitudes Preprint: CCTP-2025-05 ITCP-IPP-2025/05 QMUL-PH-25-12 by F. Alessio ♮ , P. Di Vecchia †,∇ , M. Firrotta ♭ , P. Pichini ‡ (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-15529.txt.

Introduction

Alessio and colleagues search for the Kerr solution inside string scattering amplitudes. Their 2025 arXiv paper studies the infinite-spin limit of three-point amplitudes. A square-root Kerr object has a known classical current. Higher-spin string states may reproduce that current at infinite spin. The leading Regge trajectory, though, gives a different answer.

Subleading trajectories parallel to the leading one give the same result. The team extends the study to a non-parallel subleading path. That path holds states with the first two harmonics. All needed amplitudes were computed in two formalisms. New classical string solutions with two harmonics were derived. Their sourced currents were compared with the infinite-spin limit. The hunt refines how spinning black holes emerge from strings.

Catalog record

CREATORF. Alessio ♮ , P. Di Vecchia †,∇ , M. Firrotta ♭ , P. Pichini ‡
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE139 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-15529

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Searching for Kerr in string amplitudes Preprint: CCTP-2025-05 ITCP-IPP-2025/05 QMUL-PH-25-12 F. Alessio ♮ , P. Di Vecchia †,∇ , M. Firrotta ♭ , P. Pichini ‡ Abstract We continue the approach of Cangemi:2022abk to attempt to reproduce the classical electromagnetic current of the Kerr \sqrt{\mathrm{Kerr}} solution from the infinite-spin limit of a three-point amplitude with two higher-spin string states and a massless vector. We review the infinite-spin limit of three-point amplitudes along the leading Regge trajectory, which differ from Kerr \sqrt{\mathrm{Kerr}} , and we provide evidence that any sub-leading trajectory parallel to the leading one give the same result. We extend the above investigation to the simplest sub-leading trajectory not parallel to the leading one, containing physical states with the first two harmonics. We compute all three-point amplitudes involving two such states and a massless vector, using both covariant and DDF formalism, and we extract the associated classical infinite-spin limit. Inspired by the leading Regge case, where this limit reproduces the classical electromagnetic current sourced by a rigid rotating string, we derive new classical string solutions containing the first two harmonics and compare the currents they source to the infinite-spin amplitude of the two-harmonic state. We do not see a matching between the two approaches, and we find that the classical behaviour is instead reproduced by the amplitude involving coherent string states. We conclude this paper by discussing common patterns between the different amplitudes we considered, and we conjecture how they can be generalised to reproduce Kerr \sqrt{\mathrm{Kerr}} . 1 Introduction The black holes that we observe at LIGO/VIRGO/KAGRA/GEO600 have a non-vanishing spin and are described in General Relativity (GR) by the Kerr black hole solution. In recent years, it was shown that Kerr observables can be obtained directly from the infinite-spin limit of scattering amplitudes with massive higher-spin states, and that the standard perturbative expansion for these amplitudes agrees with the post-Minkowskian expansion in GR. The starting point of this construction is the linearised energy-momentum tensor of a Kerr black hole Vines:2017hyw . The energy-momentum tensor of a massive field coupled to gravity is given by the three-point amplitude of two massive particles and a graviton. Therefore, to reproduce Kerr from amplitudes, one has to first find a class of three-point amplitudes with two spin- s particles and a graviton, for any value of s , and then show that it recovers the Kerr energy-momentum tensor for s\to\infty . It turned out that the correct amplitudes are exactly the ones studied in Ref. Arkani-Hamed:2017jhn due to having the tamest possible high-energy behaviour and henceforth referred to as “minimally-coupled”. Shortly after their first appearance, it was shown that they could be rewritten in terms of expectation values of the angular momentum operator instead of the standard polarisation vectors or spinors. In this new basis, these amplitudes are given by the exponential of the subleading soft operator Guevara:2017csg ; Guevara:2018wpp and, in the infinite-spin limit, they recover the energy-momentum tensor of Kerr in terms of the covariant classical spin vector Vaidya:2014kza ; Arkani-Hamed:2017jhn ; Cachazo:2017jef ; Guevara:2017csg ; Guevara:2018wpp ; Chung:2018kqs ; Johansson:2019dnu ; Maybee:2019jus ; Arkani-Hamed:2019ymq ; Damgaard:2019lfh ; Aoude:2020onz ; Guevara:2020xjx ; Chiodaroli:2021eug ; Cangemi:2022bew ; Cangemi:2023ysz ; Cangemi:2023bpe ; Gambino:2024uge ; Bjerrum-Bohr:2025lpw . Similarly, an analogous class of amplitudes with two equal spin- s particles and a photon reproduces the electromagnetic current of the gauge-theory counterpart of Kerr black holes, known as the \sqrt{\mathrm{Kerr}} solution Arkani-Hamed:2019ymq . However, accessing higher-order observables to all orders in the black hole’s spin requires a full understanding of the higher-point amplitudes for higher-spin particles that describe Kerr, starting with the four-point tree-level Compton amplitude with two spin- s particles and two gravitons. The first attempt at computing the correct Compton amplitude used factorisation constraints and recursion relations to try to derive it on-shell from the known three-point amplitudes Arkani-Hamed:2017jhn ; Johansson:2019dnu ; Guevara:2018wpp ; Chung:2018kqs ; Aoude:2020onz ; Falkowski:2020aso . However, this approach lead to contact-term ambiguities. To resolve this issue, a number of different avenues were explored. Some groups constructed generic effective field theories, or on-shell scattering amplitudes, directly in terms of classical spin vectors and tried to find sensible constraints to fix the free coefficients of the classical Compton amplitude Guevara:2020xjx ; Bern:2022kto ; Aoude:2022trd ; Aoude:2023vdk ; Haddad:2023ylx ; Bjerrum-Bohr:2023jau ; Bjerrum-Bohr:2023iey ; Vazquez-Holm:2025ztz . Others studied quantum field theory in the worldline formalism and found relations between black-hole amplitudes and symmetries of the worldline action Jakobsen:2021zvh ; Comberiati:2022cpm ; Ben-Shahar:2023djm ; Haddad:2024ebn . Another approach studied solutions to the Teukolsky equation, describing the propagation of gravitational waves on Kerr spacetime, and found a way to extract the Compton amplitude from it Bautista:2021wfy ; Bautista:2022wjf ; Bautista:2023sdf ; Bautista:2024agp . Alternatively, other groups focussed on studying the massive higher-spin theories underlying the three-point amplitudes connected to Kerr Aoude:2020mlg ; Chiodaroli:2021eug ; Cangemi:2022bew ; Cangemi:2023bpe . In particular, one of the authors of this work found a set of physical constraints which uniquely determines the correct three-point amplitudes, and used it to derive the Compton amplitude to all spin orders. All the approaches mentioned above have been able to obtain state-of-the-art classical observables for Kerr black holes and binary systems Guevara:2019fsj ; Chung:2019duq ; Aoude:2020mlg ; Chung:2020rrz ; Damgaard:2022jem ; Kosmopoulos:2021zoq ; Chen:2021kxt ; Jakobsen:2022fcj ; Alessio:2022kwv ; Aoude:2022thd ; Menezes:2022tcs ; Jakobsen:2022zsx ; Chen:2022clh ; Saketh:2022wap ; Alessio:2023kgf ; Bautista:2023szu ; Jakobsen:2023ndj ; Scheopner:2023rzp ; Buonanno:2024vkx ; Chen:2024mmm ; Chen:2024bpf ; Akpinar:2024meg ; Bautista:2024agp ; Bohnenblust:2024hkw ; Gatica:2024mur ; Akpinar:2025bkt ; Jakobsen:2021lvp ; Bautista:2021inx ; Riva:2022fru ; Heissenberg:2023uvo ; DeAngelis:2023lvf ; Brandhuber:2023hhl ; Aoude:2023dui ; Bohnenblust:2023qmy ; Alessio:2025flu ; Bohnenblust:2025gir ; Akpinar:2025huz . However, all the answers provided are either truncated to a finite spin order or still present some ambiguities, and the complete tree-level Compton amplitude for Kerr is still missing. Moreover, higher-order black-hole observables require knowledge of amplitudes at five points and above, which are still an open problem. Studying higher-spin amplitudes in string theory provides a new perspective on this problem. Indeed, since string theory is a consistent quantum theory containing infinitely-many higher-spin states, it is natural to see if one can find the amplitudes describing Kerr within it Cangemi:2022abk ; Azevedo:2024rrf . One advantage of this is that, assuming there is a string state that reproduces known Kerr amplitudes, all higher-point amplitudes will be uniquely determined by the state’s vertex operator, thus providing a novel realisation of (long-distance) black-hole physics from strings. As a first step, one can consider the infinite-spin limit of all sorts of three-point tree-level string amplitudes to see what classical objects emerge from it. We follow the approach in Ref. Cangemi:2022abk , where it was shown that three-point amplitudes with two spin- s leading Regge states and one massless boson, in the open and closed superstring, reproduce the electromagnetic current and energy momentum tensor sourced by known classical string solutions representing a rigid rotating string Ademollo:1974te , in the s\to\infty limit. However, leading-Regge amplitudes give a different result from Kerr, so to make further progress one needs to investigate subleading string states. It is easy to find the physical states at the few lowest levels, but at higher levels it becomes more subtle due to the complexity of solving physical-state constraints,

Read the complete text