Cosmic curl – Features and convergence of the vorticity power spectrum in N N -body simulations
and Thomas Tram · 2025
Read Cosmic curl – Features and convergence of the vorticity power spectrum in N N -body simulations by and Thomas Tram (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-15486.txt.
Introduction
Camilla Sørensen, Steen Hannestad, and Thomas Tram chart the swirl in the cosmic flow of matter. Surveys of how galaxies move could soon test cosmology, but only if theory predicts the flow cleanly. The swirl part, called vorticity, is the hardest piece: it suffers from sampling noise and grid effects in simulations. Their 2025 paper asks how far cheaper simulations can be trusted.
Using their CONCEPT code, the authors show that a simple particle-mesh method already lands within a few percent of a far costlier scheme for the velocity field. The vorticity spectrum, though, cannot be run to full convergence in a cosmic volume. Instead they extrapolate it robustly from just four runs with different particle counts, claiming accuracy within five percent. Their recipe gives coming velocity surveys a firm theoretical target without supercomputer-scale expense.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | and Thomas Tram |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-15486
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Cosmic curl – Features and convergence of the vorticity power spectrum in N N -body simulations and Thomas Tram Abstract Observations of the cosmic velocity field could become an important cosmological probe in the near future. To take advantage of future velocity-flow surveys we must however have the theoretical predictions under control. In many respects, the velocity field is easier to simulate than the density field because it is less severely affected by small-scale clustering. Therefore, as we also show in this paper, a particle-mesh (PM) based simulation approach is usually sufficient, yielding results within a few percent of a corresponding P 3 M \text{P}^{3}\text{M} simulation in which short-range forces are properly accounted for, but which also carry a much larger computational cost. However, in other respects the velocity field is much more challenging to deal with than the density field: Interpolating the velocity field onto a grid is significantly more complicated, and the vorticity field (the curl-part of the velocity field) is severely affected by both sample variance and discretisation effects. While the former can be dealt with using fixed amplitude initial conditions, the former makes it infeasible to run fully converged simulations in a cosmological volume. However, using the N N -body code concept we show that one can robustly extrapolate the cosmic vorticity power spectrum from just 4 simulations with different number of particles. We expect our extrapolated vorticity power spectra to be correct within 5% of the fully converged result across three orders of magnitude in k k . 1 Introduction Over the past two decades, large scale surveys of cosmic structure have reached a scale and precision that have made them an important tool in precision cosmology. Most surveys have focused on providing information on the cosmic matter density field, either via number counts of galaxies or via measurements of galaxy shapes which in turn allows for measurements of the matter distribution using weak gravitational lensing information. While the use of number counts is in principle straightforward, it comes with a number of important challenges such as uncertainties about completeness, mass-luminosity bias effects, etc. Using weak lensing circumvents these problems because it allows for a direct measurement of the gravitational potential. However, weak lensing suffers from the problem of having access only to line-of-sight information and even using tomography, 3D information is somewhat difficult to extract. Despite these various challenges, cosmological surveys such as DESI [ 1 , 2 ] and Euclid [ 3 ] are now reaching percent level precision on the inferred cosmological matter power spectrum. A completely different possibility is to use measurements of cosmic velocity fields to extract information about cosmic structure. If reliable distances and radial velocities can be measured for a large numbers of objects at cosmological distances, it is in principle possible to reconstruct e.g. cosmological velocity power spectra which in turn can be used to perform cosmological parameter inference. Velocity measurements have a number of advantages over measurements of the density field. For example they do not rely on knowing the completeness of the sample since they are inherently volume weighted rather than density weighted (see e.g. [ 4 , 5 ] ). However, they have the distinct disadvantage of requiring very accurate distance measurements, i.e. they require a set of very good standard candles. This limitation means that cosmic velocity measurements (beyond the important measurement of the current background expansion rate of the Universe, H_{0} ) have not yet reached a level of precision where they are competitive with galaxy surveys. However, this situation is likely to change with the advent of very large scale supernova surveys from facilities such as the Vera C. Rubin telescope (see e.g. [ 6 ] ). These will allow for the detection of hundreds of thousands of type Ia supernovae and provide a detailed 3D map of the cosmic velocity field [ 5 , 7 , 8 ] . With the advent of very precise cosmological surveys demands on the corresponding theoretical calculations of observables naturally increases. Current measurements of the matter power and lensing power spectra, for example, require that theoretical computations are accurate at percent level precision over a wide range of scales. This is generally achievable using sets of N -body simulations which include effects from the baryonic component such as star formation and supernova feedback (see e.g. [ 9 ] for a discussion). However, the precision with which observables related to velocity can be calculated are much less well known. In particular, the generation of vorticity in the cosmic velocity field could be problematic because it is not sourced at lowest order in perturbation theory and is therefore only generated by the emergence of non-linear structures (see e.g. [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] ). In this paper we provide a detailed investigation of vorticity generation in cosmological N -body simulations with particular emphasis on convergence properties. Section 2 provides an overview of the required theory, and section 3 describes our numerical simulation setup. Section 4 discusses how to best extract velocity divergence and vorticity spectra from simulations by means of Delauney tesselation. We present our main results in section 5, and finally we provide a discussion and conclusion in section 6. 2 Theory Analysing cosmic velocity fields, both from numerical N -body simulations and from real measurements, is done by calculating the power spectra for the velocity divergence, \nabla\cdot\vec{v} , and the velocity vorticity, \nabla\times\vec{v} . These power spectra can then be used to obtain information about the structure of the velocity field at different physical scales [ 17 ] . The divergence \theta is defined as the gradient of the velocity field \theta=\nabla\cdot\vec{v}=\frac{\partial v_{i}}{\partial x_{i}}+\frac{\partial v_{j}}{\partial x_{j}}+\frac{\partial v_{k}}{\partial x_{k}} (2.1) and the vorticity \vec{\omega} is defined as the curl of the velocity field \omega^{k}=\epsilon^{ijk}\frac{\partial v_{j}}{\partial x_{i}} where \epsilon^{ijk} is the Levi-Civita symbol. We find it convenient to define the quantity \omega_{ij}=\frac{1}{2}\left[\frac{\partial v_{i}}{\partial x_{j}}-\frac{\partial v_{j}}{\partial x_{i}}\right]\,, (2.2) primarily because it coincides with the output of the numerical code dtfe which we shall introduce later. After the divergence and vorticity for the velocity field has been calculated, the power spectra can be calculated in the usual way. Divergence is a scalar quantity, so P_{\theta} is constructed directly from \theta . The vorticity vector has three components that due to isotropy should be statistically identical. Thus, we compute the power spectra of each component independently and add the power spectra together. In summary, P_{\theta}=\text{Power spectra of }\theta\,, (2.3) P_{\omega}=P_{\omega_{12}}+P_{\omega_{13}}+P_{\omega_{23}}\,, (2.4) where the factor of \frac{1}{2} in equation ( 2.2 ) ensures that this matches the usual definition of P_{\omega} . The cosmological model used throughout this work is a spacially flat \Lambda CDM model compatible with the Planck 2015 result as well as reference [ 13 ] : h=0.67556 , \Omega_{\text{b}}h^{2}=0.022032 , \Omega_{\text{CDM}}h^{2}=0.12038 , A_{\text{s}}=2.215\cdot 10^{-9} , n_{\text{s}}=0.9619 , and k_{*}=0.05\text{ Mpc}^{-1} . It should be noted that the initial conditions are set using linear perturbation theory where \vec{\omega}=0 , but because of discretisation and finite numerical precision, some vorticity will be generated initially. 3 Numerical simulation setup We have used the N -body code concept [ 18 ] to make all N -body simulations used in