Causal Inference amid Missingness-Specific Independencies and Mechanism Shifts

Johan de Aguas, Leonard Henckel, Johan Pensar, Guido Biele · 2025

Read Causal Inference amid Missingness-Specific Independencies and Mechanism Shifts by Johan de Aguas, Leonard Henckel, Johan Pensar, Guido Biele (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-15441.txt.

Introduction

Four statisticians tackle causal questions in data sets where missing values themselves change how people act, in a 2025 paper. Standard tools assume that missingness does not touch the real-world process, yet a missing test score can change the decisions that follow. The team extends a graph method to tag the places where missing data shift the rules. They define two versions of a treatment effect inside such systems.

One effect asks what would happen in a world with no missing data at all. The other keeps the system's natural missingness in place. The authors give rules for when each effect can be recovered and build estimators that stay sturdy if one part is off. A case study on ADHD treatment and test scores in Norwegian children found a small effect, slightly shifted by missing pre-test scores. Simulations underline how the two effects can part ways.

Catalog record

CREATORJohan de Aguas, Leonard Henckel, Johan Pensar, Guido Biele
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-15441

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Causal Inference amid Missingness-Specific Independencies and Mechanism Shifts Johan de Aguas, Leonard Henckel, Johan Pensar, Guido Biele Abstract The recovery of causal effects in structural models with missing data often relies on m m -graphs, which assume that missingness mechanisms do not directly influence substantive variables. Yet, in many real-world settings, missing data can alter decision-making processes, as the absence of key information may affect downstream actions and states. To overcome this limitation, we introduce l ​ m lm -SCMs and l ​ m lm -graphs, which extend m m -graphs by integrating a label set that represents relevant context-specific independencies (CSI), accounting for mechanism shifts induced by missingness. We define two causal effects within these systems: the full average treatment effect (FATE), which reflects the effect in a hypothetical scenario had no data been missing , and the natural average treatment effect (NATE), which captures the effect under the unaltered CSIs in the system. We propose recovery criteria for these queries and present doubly-robust estimators for a graphical model inspired by a real-world application. Simulations highlight key differences between these estimands and estimation methods. Findings from the application case suggest a small effect of ADHD treatment upon test achievement among Norwegian children, with a slight effect shift due to missing pre-tests scores. 1]Department of Mathematics, University of Oslo 2]Department of Child Health and Development, Norwegian Institute of Public Health 3]School of Mathematics and Statistics. University College Dublin 4]INTEGREAT – The Norwegian Center for Knowledge-Driven Machine Learning 1 Introduction In certain causality paradigms, the fundamental problem of causal inference —namely, the impossibility to simultaneously observe outcomes under both treatment and no treatment conditions— has traditionally been regarded as a missing data problem ( Dabrowska & Speed 1923 ; Rubin 1974 ; Ding & Li 2018 ) . Over the past decade, a growing perspective has taken shape in the opposite direction, recasting missing data problems as instances of causal inference. This viewpoint has led to an expanding body of research that combines methodologies from both areas ( Mohan et al. 2013 ; Mohan & Pearl 2014 ; Saadati & Tian 2019 ; Bhattacharya et al. 2020 ; Mohan & Pearl 2021 ; Nabi et al. 2024 ) . A central focus of this research has been to determine the conditions under which causal and counterfactual queries can be recovered in the presence of missing data, by combining graphical assumptions about the underlying causal mechanisms with information from potential auxiliary experiments ( Mohan et al. 2013 ; Bhattacharya et al. 2020 ; Mohan & Pearl 2021 ; Guo et al. 2023 ) . Common queries include the average treatment effect (ATE) of an exposure variable upon an outcome variable ( Bia et al. 2024 ; de Aguas et al. 2025 ) , the conditional average treatment effect (CATE) and other functionals conditioned on evidence ( Tikka et al. 2021 ; Kuzmanovic et al. 2023 ) , the interventional distribution ( Mohan et al. 2013 ; Bhattacharya et al. 2020 ) , and the full data distribution ( Nabi et al. 2020 ) , among others. Various techniques have been developed to recover and estimate causal effects under missing data and other forms of endogenous selection of unit information. These techniques include imputation methods ( Rubin 1976 ; Rubin 1978 ; Kyono et al. 2021 ) , covariate adjustment ( Correa et al. 2018 ; Saadati & Tian 2019 ; Mathur et al. 2023 ) , inverse probability weighting (IPW) or other ratios ( Huber 2012 ; Mohan & Pearl 2014 ) , and doubly-robust approaches ( Wei et al. 2022 ; Negi 2024 ) . In certain settings, especially under a semiparametric model and missing outcomes, it has been shown that multiply-robust and efficient estimators for the ATE can incorporate elements from imputation, covariate adjustment, and weighting, thereby providing a unifying framework for estimation ( Bia et al. 2024 ; de Aguas et al. 2025 ) . In methodological and applied research, special attention has been given to cases of missing outcome data, as these can arise from common phenomena such as attrition or loss to follow-up, which can threaten the validity of causal claims in both observational and experimental studies ( Hernán et al. 2004 ; Lewin et al. 2018 ; Biele et al. 2019 ) . The problems of recovering causal queries from missing covariate data ( Yang et al. 2019 ; Chang et al. 2023 ; Levis et al. 2024 ) and missing exposure data ( Kuzmanovic et al. 2023 ; Shi et al. 2024 ) have also been studied, though aside from Saadati & Tian 2019 , these works generally place less emphasis on graphical criteria. Furthermore, sound recovery algorithms and heuristics have been developed for general queries under multiple missingness and selection mechanisms ( Bhattacharya et al. 2020 ; Tikka et al. 2021 ) . Several sets of sufficient conditions have been proposed for recovering causal effects from missing data. These typically combine: (i) the existence of an admissible adjustment set that, along with relevant missingness indicators, can block all backdoor paths between exposure and outcome in an m -graph —a graphical model encoding both causal relationships and missingness mechanisms; (ii) specific d -separation conditions between the missingness indicators and either the exposure or the outcome; (iii) a missing at random (MAR) assumption for the variables affected by missingness; and (iv) the requirement that missingness indicators are not causal descendants of the exposures transmitting the effect to the outcome, among other structural restrictions ( Saadati & Tian 2019 ; Mohan & Pearl 2021 ) . These conditions ensure that causal effect estimands, whether via covariate adjustment or IPW, remain valid despite the presence of missing data. Violations, by contrast, can induce selection bias and undermine causal conclusions for the target population ( Hernán et al. 2004 ) . In most typical setups, if conditions for recovery are satisfied, the interpretation of the recovered effect is framed in an idealized scenario where no data are missing. For instance, a recovered ATE would be understood as the population-level expected difference in outcomes between treated and untreated scenarios, ceteris paribus , and as if no data had been missing ( Nabi et al. 2024 ) . This interpretation allows the problem of inference under missing data to be viewed in a manner akin to a counterfactual scenario. Motivation Conventional m -graph-based approaches to missing data typically assume that missingness mechanisms affect only each other and do not have a direct causal impact on the substantive variables in the system ( Mohan & Pearl 2021 ; Nabi & Bhattacharya 2023 ; Nabi et al. 2024 ) . In other words, the missingness status of a variable does not alter the causal mechanisms governing substantive variables. For the problem of missing covariate data, this assumption helps ensuring that the causal mechanisms of the exposure, the outcome, and their relationship remain invariant to the missingness indicators. However, in certain settings and applications, this constraint may be too restrictive or misaligned with the underlying data-generating process. Consider an observational study where schoolchildren take standardized tests at two consecutive time points, with corresponding scores Y_{0},Y_{1}\in\mathbb{R} . Between the two tests, some children receive stimulant

Read the complete text