Dissecting the Gender Divide: Authorship and Acknowledgment in Scientific Publications
Keigo Kusumegi, Yukie Sano, Daniel E. Acuña · 2025
Read Dissecting the Gender Divide: Authorship and Acknowledgment in Scientific Publications by Keigo Kusumegi, Yukie Sano, Daniel E. Acuña (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-15237.txt.
Introduction
Keigo Kusumegi and co-authors ask whether women in science get named in acknowledgments where men would be listed as authors. Their 2025 study draws on more than twenty thousand authors and sixty thousand acknowledged people across nine fields in open-access journals. The common suspicion was that women are thanked more and credited less; the data let the team test it directly.
The suspicion held in part. Women were more often acknowledged than listed as co-authors, above all for work classed as investigation and analysis. Status changed the picture, though. In pairs joining a highly cited scholar with a less-cited one, the senior partner was more likely to be an author whatever their gender. Highly cited women in such pairs were even more likely than their male counterparts to be co-authors. Credit, the authors conclude, follows power and perceived success as much as gender alone.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Keigo Kusumegi, Yukie Sano, Daniel E. Acuña |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-15237
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Dissecting the Gender Divide: Authorship and Acknowledgment in Scientific Publications Keigo Kusumegi, Yukie Sano, Daniel E. Acuña Abstract The issue of gender bias in scientific publications has been a topic of ongoing debate. One aspect of this debate concerns whether women receive equal credit for their contributions compared to men. Conventional wisdom suggests that women are more likely to be acknowledged than listed as co-authors—a role that carries greater prestige. Here, we analyze data from hundreds of thousands of scientists across nine disciplines and a broad range of publications. Our results confirm persistent gender disparities: women are more frequently acknowledged than credited as co-authors, especially in roles involving investigation and analysis. To account for status and disciplinary effects, we examined collaboration pair composed of highly-cited (high-status) and less-cited (low-status) scientists. In collaborations, highly-cited scientist is more likely to be listed as a co-author regardless of gender. Notably, highly-cited women in such pairs are even more likely to be co-authors than their male counterparts. Our findings suggest that power dynamics and perceived success heavily influence the distribution of credit in scientific publishing. These results underscores the role of status dynamics in shaping authorship and call for a more nuanced understanding of how gender, power, and recognition interact in scientific publishing. Our findings offer valuable insights for scientists, editors, and funding committed to advancing equity in science. 1 Introduction The story of Rosalyn Franklin, a key contributor to the pivotal discovery of the structure of DNA, serves as a powerful reminder of gender bias in the academic landscape ( Rossiter 1993 ) . Despite her pivotal role, she was not given due credit as an author ( Klug 1968 ) . Instead, she was acknowledged in the DNA structure paper ( Watson and Crick 1953 ) . While most accounts attribute this to her gender, one must also ask whether her relatively lower level of power or prestige compared to her male colleagues played a role. This well-known case makes us consider how frequently such dynamics of gender and power affect credit in science. Although gender disparities are known to exist in various aspects of academia, including citation practices, authorship patterns, academic representation, and dropout rates ( Teich et al. 2022 ; Dauxois 2008 ; West et al. 2013 ; Paul-Hus et al. 2020 ; Kong et al. 2022 ; Liu et al. 2023 ; Jadidi et al. 2018 ) , the issue of authorship versus acknowledgment with respect to gender, though discussed ( Rossiter 1993 ) , remains poorly understood due to lack of comprehensive data. In this study, we aim to address this gap by examining a large-scale dataset on authorship and acknowledgment, through the lens of gender and power dynamics. Gender disparity in academia has become a widely recognized and persistent topic of discussion, transcending disciplinary boundaries and geographical boundaries. A recent study shows that women are systematically credited less than men in science ( Ross et al. 2022 ) . Beyond individual variations influenced by factors such as career length, personal circumstances, or parental leave, women and minority groups often face systematic under-valuation within homophilic networks that favor men and reinforce cumulative advantages ( Neuhäuser et al. 2023 ; Karimi et al. 2018 ; Teich et al. 2022 ; DiPrete and Eirich 2006 ) . Given growing evidence that gender diversity enriches perspective-taking, collective intelligence, and innovation ( Nielsen et al. 2017 ; Yang et al. 2022 ) , prompting gender equality is imperative–not only to benefit individuals, but to accelerate scientific progress at large. The assignment of credit–including both authorship and acknowledgment–is critical in shaping inequalities within the scientific community. Authorship, as the more prestigious form of credit, carries particular weight: it shapes researchers’ professional profiles and influences their evaluation within institutional reward structures ( Maddox 2002 ; Cobb and Comfort 2023 ; Dauxois 2008 ) . However, biased credit allocation persists, disproportionately disadvantaging early-career researchers and influencing processes such as hiring, funding, and prestigious awards. Gender disparities further compound these issues. Prior research shows that women, despite making comparable contributions, are less likely to be credited as authors or acknowledged appropriately ( Ross et al. 2022 ) . Moreover, women frequently encounter disputes over authorship order and naming, leading to frustration and discouragement when their contributions go unrecognized ( Ni et al. 2021 ) . These disparities demand urgent attention to rectify gender biases in credit assignments–particularly authorship–given its profound impact on careers achievement and access to scientific opportunities. The concept of credit in scholarly publications has undergone a significant shift, moving from a traditional emphaisis on authorship to a greater recognition of individuals’ specific contributions, particularly as research teams grow larger and collaboration extends beyond geographical boundaries ( Holcombe 2019 ; Vasilevsky et al. 2021 ; Fortunato et al. 2018 ) . In 1997, Rennie proposed a contribution-based system that aimed to accurately acknowledge scholarly contributions, offering a valuable framework for scientific institutions and society to assess researchers’ actual contributions rather than relying solely on authorship ( Rennie et al. 1997 ) . In 2016, PLOS introduced the Contributor Roles Taxonomy (CRediT) system, a standardized system for recognizing the diverse contributions made to scholarly publications ( Sauermann and Haeussler 2017 ; Corrêa Jr et al. 2017 ) . Larivière et al. analyzed CRediT data from PLOS publications between 2017 and 2018, revealing systematic associations between contributor roles, author counts, and author position ( Larivière et al. 2021 ) . This shift towards recognizing specific contributions has also emerged beyond academia–for example, in open-source software development, where recognizing a range of contributions offers more comprehensive picture of collaboration ( Young et al. 2021 ) . Together, these developments highlight the growing importance of accurately attributing contributions and providing the full complexity of collaborative work across domains. With the increasing emphasis on recognizing specific scholarly contributions, concerns about gender equality in these contributions have emerged. Previous research has examined the gender differences in authorship roles and found that women are more likely to be associated with performing experiments, whereas men are more frequently credited with other roles, even after accounting for academic age ( Macaluso et al. 2016 ) . However, the issue lies in biased credit assignment: women may be acknowledged rather than listed as co-authors, despite making similar contributions. In this context, a comparative analysis of authors and acknowledgees–those acknowledged in a paper–becomes crucial for evaluating how credit is assigned and whether such practices are equitable across genders. Research on scientific credit assignment has also explored whether power dynamics–beyond gender and race–play a role. These dynamics often manifest in institutional hierarchies, where highly-cited senior scientists exert influence over less-cited colleagues ( Aiston and Jung 2016 ) . Power imbalances are also evident in research funding, where decision-making bodies are predominantly composed of established scientists ( Lauer and Roychowdhury 2021 ) . These individuals tend to favor research topics and investigators that align with their own research interests, further skewing the credit assignment process. Thus, the interplay of power dynamics in scientific credit assignment extends beyond personal attributes like gender and race, and warrants systematic scrutiny to ensure equity and fairness in recognition of academic contributions. In this paper, we aim to investigate the gender disparities