Using Real-Variable Techniques to Study Zeros of Complex-Valued Harmonic Functions

Jennifer Brooks, Mary Jenkins, Samuel Liechty, Kaden Parker, Katherine Perez, Dallin Robison, Eli Sampson, Matthew G. Wilson · 2025

Read Using Real-Variable Techniques to Study Zeros of Complex-Valued Harmonic Functions by Jennifer Brooks, Mary Jenkins, Samuel Liechty, Kaden Parker, Katherine Perez, Dallin Robison, Eli Sampson, Matthew G. Wilson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-14966.txt.

Introduction

Brooks and seven co-authors used plain real tools in twenty twenty-five to count the zeros of two families of wave-true functions. Zeros are the points where a function hits nil, and they shape much of its tale. For these families, all zeros sit on fixed rays from the core of the plane.

That ray fact lets real-line tricks do the counting work ray by ray. They show how the zero count shifts as the family dial turns. Each ray's count is pinned by sign checks on one real axis. The work gives a clean case where real methods crack a plane task.

Catalog record

CREATORJennifer Brooks, Mary Jenkins, Samuel Liechty, Kaden Parker, Katherine Perez, Dallin Robison, Eli Sampson, Matthew G. Wilson
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-14966

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Using Real-Variable Techniques to Study Zeros of Complex-Valued Harmonic Functions Jennifer Brooks, Mary Jenkins, Samuel Liechty, Kaden Parker, Katherine Perez, Dallin Robison, Eli Sampson, Matthew G. Wilson Abstract . We investigate the zeros of two one-parameter families of harmonic functions and describe how the number of zeros depends on the parameter. Our functions have the property that all zeros lie on certain rays in the complex plane and thus we are able to use real-variable techniques to count the zeros on each ray. 1991 Mathematics Subject Classification 30C15 1. Introduction We consider the zeros of two closely-related families of complex-valued harmonic functions. Such functions have the form f=u+iv where both u and v are real-valued harmonic functions. Additionally, they can be expressed as f=h+\overline{g} , where h and g are analytic. Much of the research to date on the zeros of such functions focuses on the polynomial case. The Fundamental Theorem of Algebra states that for non-constant analytic polynomials, the number of zeros equals the degree. However, for harmonic polynomials, this theorem does not apply and the number of zeros may be much larger than the degree. Many researchers have sought bounds on the number of zeros of these polynomials. Sheil-Small conjectured sheil and Wilmhurst wilmshurst1998valence proved that for a harmonic polynomial f=h+\overline{g} for which \deg h=n , \deg g=m , and m<n , the maximum number of zeros of f is n^{2} . Sète and Zur sete2024zeros showed that for every k=n,n+1,...,n^{2} there exists a harmonic polynomial of degree n with k zeros. For analytic polynomials, the establishment of the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra did not end the study of their zeros; researchers have sought and continue to seek results relating the locations of these zeros to the coefficients. (See melman1 and the references therein.) Analogously, the establishment of sharp bounds on the number of zeros of complex-valued harmonic polynomials does not end their study. Because the number of zeros itself depends not only on the degree but also on the coefficients, ongoing research addresses both how the number and locations of the zeros vary with the coefficients. (See sam , work , legesse2022location , melman24 .) Much of this research focuses on simple one- or two-parameter families of functions with the goal of obtaining detailed zero-counting theorems. Specifically, Brilleslyper et al. BBDHS investigated a family of trinomials: (1) q(z)=z^{n}+c\overline{z}^{k}-1 where 1\leq k\leq n-1 , n\geq 3, c\in\mathbb{R}_{+} and \gcd(n,k)=1 . Their theorem states that as c increases over the positive reals, the number of zeros increases monotonically from a minimum of n to a maximum of n+2k . Their proof used the Argument Principle for harmonic functions; for this family, the critical curve separating the sense-preserving and sense-reversing regions is a circle whose image under the function is a hypocycloid. They determined how the winding number about the origin of this hypocycloid varies with c and were therefore able to count the zeros inside the sense-reversing region for all values of c . We investigate two families of complex-valued harmonic functions. The first is a family of harmonic polynomials of a form similar to ( 1 ): (2) p(z)=z^{m}+c(z^{k}+\overline{z}^{k})-1,\qquad\text{where }m>k,\quad c>0 A natural question is: How does this addition of a single term affect the number of zeros as c increases? The strategy for counting the zeros of the two families turns out to be quite different. Unfortunately, because of the additional term in our family of polynomials, the critical curve is non-circular. This renders the strategy used in Brilleslyper et al. BBDHS not viable. However, we specifically add the term c{z}^{k} , which is the conjugate of the middle term of ( 1 ). Because of this addition, z^{m} is the only non-real term in ( 2 ). Conveniently, we can then reduce much of the problem to counting the zeros of a real-valued polynomial and can apply real variable techniques. In this paper we prove the following theorem: Theorem 1 . Let p(z)=z^{m}+c(z^{k}+\overline{z}^{k})-1 where m>k , c\in\mathbb{R_{+}} , and \gcd(m,k)=1 . As c increases, the number of zeros of p increases monotonically from a minimum of m to a maximum of m+N , where N is determined as follows: • If m\equiv 0\mod 4 , N=m . • If m\equiv 1\mod 4 and k is odd, N=m-1 . • If m\equiv 1\mod 4 and k is even, N=m+1 . • If m\equiv 2\mod 4 , N=m-2 . • If m\equiv 3\mod 4 and k is odd, N=m+1 . • If m\equiv 3\mod 4 and k is even, N=m-1 . Before we continue, we illustrate with an example: Example 1 . Consider the polynomial p(z)=z^{5}+c(z^{4}+\overline{z}^{4})-1 corresponding to m=5 and k=4 . Because 5\equiv 1\mod 4 and 4 is even, by Theorem 1 , the number of zeros grows from 5 to 5+(5+1)=11 . As c changes from c=0.1 to c=1 and eventually to c=3 , the number of zeros increases from 5 to 7 , then to 11 . See Figure 1 . (a) c=0.1 (b) c=1 (c) c=3 Figure 1. Zeros of p(z)=z^{5}+c(z^{4}+\overline{z}^{4})-1 Inspired by the work of Brilleslyper et al., Brooks and Lee lee investigated a related family of harmonic trinomials, each having a pole at the origin: (3) f_{c}(z)=z^{n}+\frac{c}{\overline{z}^{k}}-1 where n,k\in\mathbb{N} with n>k and \gcd(n,k)=1 . They showed that for this family, the number of zeros decreases from n+k to n-k as c increases through the positive reals. Not surprisingly, their proof strategy was the same as that in Brilleslyper et al. The critical curve separating the sense-preserving and sense-reversing regions is again a circle, but this time, its image under the function is an epicycloid. They determined the winding number of this epicycloid about the origin for all values of c and were therefore able to count the zeros in the sense-reversing region for all values of c . Just as we added a single term to go from ( 1 ) to ( 2 ), we also investigate a family of harmonic functions related to the family ( 3 ). However, we write our functions in a way that makes their connection with ( 2 ) clearer: (4) p(z)=z^{m}+c\left(z^{k}+\overline{z}^{k}\right)-1 where m\in\mathbb{N} , k\in\mathbb{Z} with k<0 , m>|k| , c\in\mathbb{R_{+}} , and \gcd(m,k)=1 . Because of the additional analytic term, we again have a family of harmonic functions whose critical curve is not a circle. Therefore, once again, a proof using the Harmonic Argument Principle is not viable. However, because the middle two terms are conjugates, once again z^{m} is the only non-real term. We can therefore again reduce the complex problem to a real-variable problem. In this paper, we prove the following theorem: Theorem 2 . Let p(z)=z^{m}+c(z^{k}+\overline{z}^{k})-1 , where m\in\mathbb{N} , k\in\mathbb{Z} with k<0 , m>|k| , c\in\mathbb{R}_{+} , and \gcd(m,k)=1 . As c increases, the number of zeros of p decreases monotonically from a maximum of M+N to a minimum of M , where M and N are determined as follows: • If m\equiv 0\mod 4 , M=m+1 and N=m-2 . • If m\equiv 1\mod 4 and k is odd, M=m-1 and N=m+1 . • If m\equiv 1\mod{4} and k is even, M=m,N=m+1 • If m\equiv 2\mod 4 , M=m-1 and N=m . • If m\equiv 3\mod 4 and k

Read the complete text