Coarse graining of stochastic differential equations: averaging and projection method
Hong Duong (1), Carsten Hartmann (2), Michela Ottobre (3) · 2025
Read Coarse graining of stochastic differential equations: averaging and projection method by Hong Duong (1), Carsten Hartmann (2), Michela Ottobre (3) (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-14939.txt.
Introduction
Manh Hong Duong and co-authors compare two ways to simplify random dynamic systems. Coarse graining replaces a complex system with a smaller one that keeps the main behavior. Averaging works when fast and slow motions split cleanly in time. A projection method, by contrast, uses conditional expectations and can in principle work without that split.
The paper gives the projection method a firmer base and ties it tightly to a mimicking approach of Gyöngy. It then asks when the two methods agree under time-scale separation. The authors state exact conditions for agreement, and counterexamples show the methods can also part ways. The result warns modelers not to treat the two shortcuts as interchangeable.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hong Duong (1), Carsten Hartmann (2), Michela Ottobre (3) |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 105 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-14939
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Coarse graining of stochastic differential equations: averaging and projection method Hong Duong (1), Carsten Hartmann (2), Michela Ottobre (3) Abstract . We study coarse-graining methods for stochastic differential equations. In particular we consider averaging and a type of projection operator method, sometimes referred to as effective dynamic via conditional expectations. The projection method (PM) we consider is related to the “mimicking marginals” coarse graining approach proposed by Gyöngy. The first contribution of this paper is to provide further theoretical background for the PM and a rigorous link to the Gyöngy method. Moreover, we compare PM and averaging. While averaging applies to systems with time scale separation, the PM can in principle be applied irrespective of this. However it is often assumed that the two methods coincide in presence of scale separation. The second contribution of this paper is to make this statement precise, provide sufficient conditions under which these two methods coincide and then show – via examples and counterexamples – that this needs not be the case. Keywords. Coarse Graining for Stochastic Differential Equations, two-parameter Markov Semigroups, Averaging, Projection Methods. AMS Classification (MSC 2020). 60H10, 34F05,60J60, 34K33, 35B40, 82C31. 1. Introduction Coarse-graining of nonlinear dynamical systems, also called model (order) reduction, often involves a combination of systematic mathematical approaches and heuristics based on either physical intuition or observations drawn from data. Prime examples of this fact are projection operator methods, among which are optimal prediction (e.g. [ CHK00 ] ) or stochastic mode reduction approaches (e.g. in climate modelling [ MTVE01 ] ) that eliminate small-scale variables from a potentially high-dimensional system. Other coarse-graining approaches include multiscale methods, prominently averaging and homogenization, [ PS08 ] , thermodynamic (mean field) limits [ Szn91 ] , Mori-Zwanzig [ Kup04 , Mor65 ] , with this list being by far not exhaustive. The general purpose of all such methods is to reduce a high dimensional system to a lower dimensional one, in such a way that the latter preserves certain properties of the original dynamics. The eliminated degrees of freedom are often referred to as unresolved variables. For many of the available methods the starting point is the modelling of the entire high dimensional system; this involves first a modelling step in which the unresolved variables are parametrised by e.g. a stochastic process or a probability measure, depending on the context, and then, secondly, the elimination step per se. The first step is an issue in its own right; for example, in the context of slow-fast systems, identifying suitable dimensionless small parameters and modelling the fast variables can be a big challenge [ IS09 ] . In this paper we do not consider this first step but rather assume that a model for the entire system is given and focus solely on the elimination, i.e. the coarse graining step. 1 1 1 In this paper we use the terms dimension reduction and coarse graining interchangeably. In particular we will be concerned with coarse graining of systems modelled by Stochastic Differential Equations (SDEs). Coarse graining is needed and routinely used in molecular dynamics, continuum mechanics, control engineering, atmosphere and ocean dynamics, and in many other fields of applied science. Yet some dimension reduction methods have by now undergone complete mathematization, others less so. Moreover, when more than one method is applicable to the system at hand, rigorous comparisions are often still lacking but certainly needed, as advocated e.g. in [ GKS04 ] . Since appropriate mathematization can contribute towards comparison, the two issues are related. In this paper we consider two types of coarse graining methods and compare them. Specifically, we consider the classical averaging principle, which assumes time scale separation between variables (e.g. [ Kha68 , Ver91 ] ), and projection operator methods for SDEs in the spirit of the works [ LL10 , LLO17 ] . The latter are an approximation of the dimension reduction approach introduced by Gyöngy in his seminal paper [ Gyö86 ] . In particular, we address the question under which conditions the projection method reduces to the averaging principle. We motivate addressing this question in some depth in Subsection 2.3 and more briefly below. There are various projection operator type approaches in the literature that are closely related to the one we will consider, such as optimal prediction [ CHK00 ] , stochastic modelling [ JKRH01 ] , Born-Markov [ MHS99 ] , or Born-Oppenheimer approximation [ PST07 ] . There are subtle differences between the aforementioned methods though and, for the sake of clarity, we will recall the method presented in [ LL10 ] , in Section 2 . This is the one we will study here and that from now on we refer to as the Projection Method (PM). For now we just briefly mention that any projection operator-based method can be understood as a form of best approximation in a weighted L^{2} space where the weight is a probability distribution of choice. In the PM one takes a conditional probability distribution as weight, namely the distribution of the entire invariant measure of the system, conditional on knowledge of the resolved variables. The resulting projection operator is a conditional expectation. While averaging methods for SDEs are by now well grounded on rigorous mathematical foundations, the theory underpinning the PM is less developed (though there are results in the literature, see e.g. [ LL11 , HNS20 ] ). The first goal of this paper is to contribute to the development of the mathematical understanding of the PM and to make the relation between the PM and the Gyöngy approach rigorous, which helps to shed light on potential and limitations of the PM. We show that, for a large class of SDEs, the dynamics produced via the GM and the one produced via the PM have the same long time behaviour. We moreover provide sufficient conditions under which the PM works (i.e. conditions under which the produced coarse grained dynamics has the desired properties) and examples where it fails. The PM can in principle be used irrespective of whether there is a time-scale separation in the system (by which we mean that the high dimensional system is a slow-fast system, with the unresolved variables being the fast part of the dynamics). However, it is a common belief (e.g. [ CHK06 , KJB+04 ] ) that, in presence of scale separation, the coarse-grained dynamics obtained by PM and the one obtained via averaging coincide (we will be more precise on this in Section 2 ). This belief seems to stem from the fact that when the original system is reversible (in gradient form) then it is (to an extent, which we clarify in the next section) true that the PM approximation boils down to the approximation produced via averaging. The second main goal of this paper is to point out that, in general, it is not the case that these two coarse graining procedures coincide in presence of scale separation. We provide both counterexamples (see Section 2 and Section 4 ) and sufficient conditions under which this statement holds. We note in passing that it is moreover often argued that the so-called Mori–Zwanzig projection operator formalism is an extension of the optimal prediction projection operator formalism that