Phase Transitions at Unusual Values of θ \theta
Csaba Csáki, Teruhiko Kawano, Hitoshi Murayama, and Ofri Telem · 2025
Read Phase Transitions at Unusual Values of θ \theta by Csaba Csáki, Teruhiko Kawano, Hitoshi Murayama, and Ofri Telem (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-14879.txt.
Introduction
Csaba Csáki, Teruhiko Kawano, Hitoshi Murayama, and Ofri Telem compute how vacuum energy depends on the angle theta in a cousin of quantum chromodynamics. Their theory can be solved exactly, unlike real QCD. It is a supersymmetric gauge theory, softly broken and coupled to anomaly-mediated supersymmetry breaking, with a clear scale ladder that keeps the analysis sound.
As in ordinary QCD, the vacuum energy shifts with theta and jumps in first-order transitions as different dyons condense. With no flavors, the jump sits at theta equal to pi, as expected. With one, two, or three flavors, the jumps land at fractional values of pi instead. The result sharpens theory about vacuum structure.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Csaba Csáki, Teruhiko Kawano, Hitoshi Murayama, and Ofri Telem |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 59 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-14879
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Phase Transitions at Unusual Values of θ \theta Csaba Csáki, Teruhiko Kawano, Hitoshi Murayama, and Ofri Telem Abstract We calculate the θ \theta dependence in a cousin of QCD, where the vacuum structure can be analyzed exactly. The theory is 𝒩 = 2 \mathcal{N}=2 S U ( 2 ) SU(2) gauge theory with N F = 0 , 1 , 2 , 3 N_{F}=0,1,2,3 flavors of fundamentals, explicitly broken to 𝒩 = 1 \mathcal{N}=1 via an adjoint superpotential, and coupled to anomaly mediated supersymmetry breaking (AMSB). The hierarchy m A M S B ≪ μ 𝒩 = 1 ≪ Λ m_{AMSB}\ll\mu_{\mathcal{N}=1}\ll\Lambda ensures the validity of our IR analysis. As expected from ordinary QCD, the vacuum energy is a function of θ \theta which undergoes 1st order phase transitions between different vacua where the various dyons condense. For N F = 0 N_{F}=0 we find the expected phase transition at θ = π \theta=\pi , while for N F = 1 , 2 , 3 N_{F}=1,2,3 we find phase transitions at fractional values of π \pi . 1 Introduction The \theta dependence of the vacuum is one of the most important and difficult aspects of the strong/confining dynamics in gauge theories. Even within real world QCD this question is not fully clarified, including the dynamical origin of the various terms appearing in the potential. Initially it was assumed that the \theta -dependence is due to instanton effects, which seems like a reasonable guess since instantons are intimately related to the existence of the \theta vacua. However Witten Witten:1978bc and di Vecchia and Veneziano DiVecchia:1980yfw realized that this is unlikely. The essence of the argument is as follows: when fermionic matter is introduced, an anomalous chiral symmetry appears which rotates the \theta term. The corresponding Goldstone boson (called \eta^{\prime} ) picks up a mass from the same dynamics that is responsible for the \theta -dependence of QCD. However since in the large- N limit the \eta^{\prime} mass has to vanish, the \theta -dependent part of the potential has to be more complicated than a simple instanton generated \Lambda^{4}\cos\theta term. In particular, it should have several branches, giving rise to first order phase transitions as one moves from on branch to the other. A separate argument for a phase transition in pure Yang-Mills theories was put forward long ago Dashen:1970et ; tHooft:1981bkw . The conjecture was that the charge-parity (CP) symmetry is spontaneously broken at \theta=\pi in pure Yang-Mills theories, leading to a doubly-degenerate vacuum and indicating a first-order phase transition. Recently, this assertion has been greatly sharpened for SU(N) Yang-Mills (YM) theory in Gaiotto:2017yup . The main tool employed in the latter analysis was the identification of a mixed anomaly between the Z_{N} 1-form center symmetry of SU(N) and time reversal at \theta=\pi . ’t Hooft anomaly matching then implies one of the following scenarios at \theta=\pi : (a) the theory is gapless; (b) the theory is non-trivially gapped and the IR topological field theory reproduces the anomaly; (c) the Z_{N} 1-form center symmetry is spontaneously broken and so the theory does not confine; or (d) time reversal is spontaneously broken, leading to a doubly degenerate vacuum and a first order phase transition at \theta=\pi . While none of the above scenarios is ruled out, option (d) was seen as the most probable - and the only one consistent with the analysis of softly broken SUSY gauge theory and with large- N studies. The non-perturbative nature of the IR dynamics in asymptotically free theories makes the study of the \theta -dependence particularly hard, and one has to either specialize to supersymmetric Veneziano1982 ; Taylor1983 ; Affleck:1983vc ; Affleck:1983mk ; Affleck1985 ; Seiberg1994a ; Seiberg1994 ; Seiberg:1994bz ; Seiberg1995 ; Douglas1995 ; Hanany1995 ; Intriligator:1995id ; Leigh1995 ; Pouliot:1995me ; Kutasov1995 ; Finnell:1995dr ; Kutasov1995a ; Intriligator1995 ; Argyres1995 ; Argyres1995a ; Argyres1995b ; Matone1995 ; Klemm1995 ; Murayama:1995ng ; Klemm1996 ; Argyres1996 ; Argyres1996a ; Donagi1996 ; Intriligator1996 ; Kutasov1996 ; Pouliot1996 ; Pouliot1996a ; Intriligator1996a ; Aharony1997 ; Cachazo2002 ; Nekrasov2003 ; Auzzi2003 ; Intriligator2006 ; Pestun2012 or near-supersymmetric gauge theories Aharony:1995zh ; Evans:1995ia ; DHoker:1996xdz ; AlvarezGaume1996 ; Konishi1997 ; Evans1997 ; AlvarezGaume1997 ; AlvarezGaume1998 ; AlvarezGaume1998a ; Cheng1998 ; Martin:1998yr ; ArkaniHamed1998 ; Luty1999 ; Abel2011 ; Cordova2018 ; Csaki:2021xhi ; Csaki:2021aqv ; Csaki:2021jax ; Murayama:2021xfj ; Csaki:2021xuc ; Kondo:2021osz ; Luzio:2022ccn ; Csaki:2022cyg ; Dine:2022req ; Dine:2022nmt or make use of consistency conditions like anomaly matching Raby:1979my ; Hooft1980 ; Dimopoulos:1980hn ; Csaki:1997aw ; Gaiotto:2017yup ; Tanizaki2017 ; Gaiotto2018 ; Cordova2018 ; Shimizu2018 ; Bi2019 ; Tanizaki:2018wtg ; Tanizaki2018 ; Hsin2019 ; GarciaEtxebarria2019 ; Cordova2020 ; Freed2021 ; Cordova2020a ; Bolognesi:2020mpe ; Bolognesi:2021yni ; Tong2020 ; Razamat2021 ; Karasik2022 ; Smith2022 , or of large- N arguments. In this paper, we perform a complementary study to the one in Gaiotto:2017yup , by analyzing a particular set of near-supersymmetric theories, where the vacuum energy can be calculated exactly as a function of \theta . Our intention is the study of this particular toy model rather than the extrapolation to any particular non-supersymmetric gauge theory (e.g. QCD). For this reason, we are free to choose our original supersymmetric gauge theory as well as our method of SUSY breaking. The validity of our analysis is guaranteed as long as we correctly map the SUSY breaking from the UV to the IR, and as long as we maintain a hierarchy m_{breaking}\ll\Lambda , the strong scale of the theory. Our theory of interest is \mathcal{N}=2 gauge theory with gauge group SU(2) and N_{F}=0,1,2,3 flavors of fundamentals. This is particularly suitable for studying the phases of pure QCD-like theories. The reason is that adding matter fields will usually introduce an \eta^{\prime} into the spectrum, which will then act as a heavy axion and wash out the branches and phase structure of the pure QCD-like theory (see Csaki:2023yas for a new analysis of the \eta^{\prime} potentials in such models). However \mathcal{N}=2 theories with matter have the tree-level \tilde{Q}\Phi Q coupling in their superpotential, which explicitly breaks the usual axial symmetry and eliminates the relation between \eta^{\prime} and \theta . 1 1 1 The \tilde{Q}\Phi Q term does preserve a chiral U(1) symmetry under which Q,\tilde{Q} have charge 1 and \Phi has charge -2 . However this symmetry will be broken when {\cal N}=2 is broken to {\cal N}=1 via the adjoint mass term, and this breaking sets the resulting \eta^{\prime} to zero, removing it from the dynamics and uncovering the QCD-like branch structure for the \theta dependence. Thus studying \mathcal{N}=2 with different N_{F} and supersymmetry breaking is an ideal tool for understanding the dynamics leading to the phase structure of QCD-like theories. These \mathcal{N}=2 theories are the ones explored in the groundbreaking work of Seiberg and Witten Seiberg1994 ; Seiberg1994a . In the IR, the theory has an \mathcal{N}=2 supersymmetric Coulomb branch parametrized by the vacuum expectation value (VEV) of the adjoint scalar in the \mathcal{N}=2 gauge multiplet. On the Coulomb branch, the gauge symmetry is higgsed to its U(1) subgroup. At particular points on the Coulomb branch, the gauge coupling becomes singular, indicating the appearance of new massless degrees of freedom - the monopoles and dyons of the SU(2)\rightarrow