Primordial Black Holes are 5D Preprint: MPP-2025-117 Preprint: LMU-ASC 16/25

Luis A. Anchordoqui, Alek Bedroya, Dieter Lüst · 2025

Read Primordial Black Holes are 5D Preprint: MPP-2025-117 Preprint: LMU-ASC 16/25 by Luis A. Anchordoqui, Alek Bedroya, Dieter Lüst (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-14874.txt.

Introduction

Luis Anchordoqui, Alek Bedroya, and Dieter Lüst argue that black holes born in the early universe should really live in five dimensions. Their stage is the Dark Dimension scenario, an idea from quantum gravity research that adds one large extra dimension. They revisit the three classic ways such primordial black holes form: from inflation, from phase transitions, and from cosmic strings.

Under the rules of that scenario, each route, short of exotic new low-energy physics, ends up making five-dimensional holes. Holes strung along cosmic strings could even survive for as long as the universe has existed. The authors point to a recent catch by the KM3NeT telescope, a neutrino of striking energy close to the five-dimensional Planck scale of the scenario. If the reading is right, such holes might one day be spotted through particles they shed.

Catalog record

CREATORLuis A. Anchordoqui, Alek Bedroya, Dieter Lüst
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE21 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-14874

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Primordial Black Holes are 5D Preprint: MPP-2025-117 Preprint: LMU-ASC 16/25 Luis A. Anchordoqui, Alek Bedroya, Dieter Lüst Abstract We revisit well-established mechanisms for primordial black hole (PBH) production, namely inflation, phase transitions, and cosmic strings, in the context of the Dark Dimension Scenario, which is motivated by Swampland principles. Applying quantum gravity constraints, we demonstrate that any viable mechanism, barring exotic new physics at low energies, inevitably leads to the formation of five-dimensional PBHs. We further show that PBHs formed from cosmic strings can have lifetimes comparable to the age of the universe. We comment on the observational implications of this result, including a potential connection to the recent detection of a high-energy neutrino by KM3NeT, whose energy is intriguingly close to the five-dimensional Planck scale in the Dark Dimension Scenario. I Introduction Our observational access to the early universe is limited, yet any relic formed in the early universe that behaves like dark matter offers a potential window into early cosmology. One such candidate is the primordial black hole (PBH), which can naturally arise from overdensities in the early universe Zeldovich:1967lct ; Hawking:1971ei . PBHs have long been proposed as a dark matter candidate Chapline:1975ojl ; see Carr:2020xqk for a recent review. Most conventional studies of PBHs assume them to be ordinary four-dimensional (4D) black holes. However, this assumption must be re-evaluated in scenarios with large extra dimensions Arkani-Hamed:1998jmv ; Antoniadis:1998ig . From a purely non-gravitational perspective, large extra dimensions might appear exotic. Yet, general principles believed to hold in quantum gravity suggest that our notion of what is “natural” needs to change significantly in gravitational theories. The Swampland program aims to reformulate naturalness in the context of quantum gravity Agmon:2022thq . In particular, it has been shown that Swampland principles Lust:2019zwm , given the observed smallness of the cosmological constant and existing constraints from cosmological and tabletop experiments, lead to a particular corner of theory space with a micron-sized extra dimension Montero:2022prj . This scenario is known as the Dark Dimension Scenario . In the Dark Dimension Scenario, the Standard Model is localized on a brane embedded in a fifth dimension of micron-scale size. A notable consequence of this setup is that Kaluza-Klein (KK) gravitons are inevitably produced by brane-localized radiation. These KK modes interact only gravitationally and behave as a component of dark matter Gonzalo:2022jac ; Obied:2023clp , yielding a particular realization of the dynamical dark matter framework Dienes:2011ja . Thus, many observational features of our universe could follow naturally from a single observation: the existence of an exponentially small cosmological constant. Given the presence of a large extra dimension, the study of primordial black holes requires careful reconsideration. For example, Refs. Anchordoqui:2022txe ; Anchordoqui:2024akj ; Anchordoqui:2024dxu explored the implications of dark matter composed of 5D black holes, whose slower evaporation rates compared to their 4D counterparts relax existing observational constraints. In this paper, we revisit the formation mechanisms of PBHs and ask whether, within the Dark Dimension Scenario, PBHs are effectively 4D or 5D black holes. Surprisingly, we find that, under mild assumptions and applying quantum gravity constraints, PBHs must be 5D, regardless of their abundance 1 1 1 Phases that are more stable than black holes are universal in quantum gravity. The ”black hole scale” \Lambda_{\rm BH} marks the temperature threshold above which black holes decay into more stable configurations Bedroya:2024uva , such as higher-dimensional black holes Gregory:1993vy or Horowitz–Polchinski-type solutions Horowitz:1997jc ; Balthazar:2022hno ; Bedroya:2024igb . To arrive at this conclusion, we focus on three well-studied mechanisms for generating the overdensities that seed PBHs: (i) inflation Ivanov:1994pa , (ii) phase transitions Crawford:1982yz , and (iii) cosmic strings Hawking:1987bn . Of these, the inflationary mechanism is already in tension with quantum gravity expectations, not only due to its fine-tuned initial conditions but also because the type of scalar potential that it requires is in tension with Swampland principles Bedroya:2019snp ; Bedroya:2019tba ; Bedroya:2024zta . We therefore concentrate on the latter two scenarios and demonstrate that both generically lead to PBHs that are 5D. In scenarios with extra dimensions, the early universe evolves as a higher-dimensional system until a transition occurs at a characteristic temperature known as the normalcy temperature T^{*} after which the universe becomes effectively 4D with stabilized geometric moduli Arkani-Hamed:1998sfv . In the Dark Dimension Scenario, this temperature is T^{*}\sim\mathrm{GeV} Gonzalo:2022jac ; Obied:2023clp . Since PBH formation can occur at temperatures higher than this, we derive quantum gravity constraints on the evolution of the extra dimension prior to T=T^{*} to extend our conclusions to earlier cosmological epochs. Along the way, we show that the universe before the normalcy temperature was in a kination-dominated phase. Finally, we analyze the lifetime of these 5D PBHs and explore the intriguing possibility that some of them evaporate at late times. This could potentially account for the high-energy neutrino event recently observed by the KM3NeT experiment KM3NeT:2025npi along with the proposal of Anchordoqui:2025xug . II Dark Dimension Before the Normalcy Temperature In the Dark Dimension Scenario, there is a stringent upper bound on the temperature at which the four-dimensional description of the universe with a fixed-size extra dimension remains valid. The temperature marking the beginning of this ”normal” epoch is referred to as the normalcy temperature, denoted by T^{*} . If T^{*} were too high, it would lead to an overproduction of KK gravitons, resulting in an excess of dark matter. Assuming the extra dimension has a size on the order of one micron, this constraint implies that T^{*}\sim\text{GeV} Gonzalo:2022jac ; Obied:2023clp . Since the effective field theory (EFT) remains valid at this scale, it is reasonable to extrapolate the cosmological evolution to earlier times using a semi-classical, potentially higher-dimensional, picture. This raises a natural question: what happens before the temperature drops to T^{*} ? A plausible hypothesis, originally proposed in Obied:2023clp to offer an independent explanation for the T^{*}\sim\text{GeV} scale, is that the universe was hot enough at earlier times to excite the geometric moduli of the internal manifold. These moduli eventually stabilized once the temperature fell to around T\sim\text{GeV} . Before this stabilization, the size of the extra dimension must have been smaller to avoid excessive production of KK gravitons. In what follows, we derive a lower bound on the size of the extra dimension, or equivalently, an upper bound on the KK mass scale M_{\rm KK} , at temperatures above T\sim\text{GeV} . As a corollary, we also show that in the Dark Dimension Scenario, the energy density of the universe could not have been dominated by Standard Model excitations during this earlier epoch, as that would lead to an overproduction of KK gravitons. At temperatures above T\sim\text{GeV} , the evolution of geometric moduli is approximately captured by lower-dimensional scalar fields, and is constrained by Hubble friction. The maximal evolution of these scalar fields is bounded by the so-called kination solution, for which: \displaystyle\frac{T}{{T^{*}}}=\frac{a(T^{*})}{a(T)}\geq\exp\left(\frac{\Delta\phi}{\sqrt{6}}\right)\geq\left(\frac{M_{\rm KK}(T)}{M_{\rm KK}}\right)^{1/3}\,, (1) where a is the scale factor and \Delta\phi is the displacement in field space, measured using the canonical moduli space metric. The final inequality is saturated if the evolution of the scalar field is entirely along the direction that decompactifies the fifth dimension (see Bedroya:2025ris for a discussion of coefficients in the exponents). This yields an upper bound on

Read the complete text