Sulphur abundances in star-forming regions from optical emission lines: A new approach based on photoionization models consistent with the direct method

E. Pérez-Montero 1,∗, B. Pérez-Díaz 1, J. M. Vílchez 1, I. A. Zinchenko 2,3,4, A. Castrillo 5,6, M. Gavilán 5, S. Zamora 5,6,7, and A. I. Díaz 5,6 · 2025

Read Sulphur abundances in star-forming regions from optical emission lines: A new approach based on photoionization models consistent with the direct method by E. Pérez-Montero 1,∗, B. Pérez-Díaz 1, J. M. Vílchez 1, I. A. Zinchenko 2,3,4, A. Castrillo 5,6, M. Gavilán 5, S. Zamora 5,6,7, and A. I. Díaz 5,6 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-14736.txt.

Introduction

Enrique Perez-Montero and co-authors offer a fresh way to gauge sulphur in star-forming gas clouds, in work from twenty twenty-five. Sulphur levels in galaxy gas are usually read from faint light lines. The direct method needs faint auroral lines that often go missing. Past model grids also fixed the sulphur share at the solar value.

The team extends a known code with grids that let the share vary freely. Sulphur lines can then set the total level with no auroral lines needed. No extra fix factor for unseen ions is needed either. Results match the direct method where both can be run. A large galaxy survey sample is then read with the new method. The sulphur share holds near the solar value across most of the range. Hints of a rise appear at the richest end.

Catalog record

CREATORE. Pérez-Montero 1,∗, B. Pérez-Díaz 1, J. M. Vílchez 1, I. A. Zinchenko 2,3,4, A. Castrillo 5,6, M. Gavilán 5, S. Zamora 5,6,7, and A. I. Díaz 5,6
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-14736

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Sulphur abundances in star-forming regions from optical emission lines: A new approach based on photoionization models consistent with the direct method E. Pérez-Montero 1,∗, B. Pérez-Díaz 1, J. M. Vílchez 1, I. A. Zinchenko 2,3,4, A. Castrillo 5,6, M. Gavilán 5, S. Zamora 5,6,7, and A. I. Díaz 5,6 Abstract The derivation of sulphur chemical abundances in the gas-phase of star-forming galaxies is explored in this work, using the emission lines produced in these regions in the optical part of the spectrum and by means of photoionization models. We adapted the code HII-CHI-mistry to account for these abundances by implementing additional grids of models that assume a variable sulphur-to-oxygen abundance ratio, beyond the commonly assumed solar ratio. The addition of these models, and their use in a new iteration of the code allows us to use sulphur lines to precisely estimate the sulphur abundance, even in the absence of auroral lines. This approach aligns with the results from the direct method, and no additional assumptions about the ionization correction factor are needed, as the models directly predict the total sulphur abundance. We applied this new methodology to a large sample of star-forming regions from the MaNGA survey, and we explored the variation of the S/O ratio as a function of metallicity, making corrections for the significant contribution from diffuse ionized gas, which particularly affects the [S ii ] emission. Our results indicate no significant deviations from the solar S/O value in the range 8.0 < < 12+log(O/H) < < 8.7, where the bulk of the MaNGA sample stays, , but also with possible enhancements of sulphur production both at low and high metallicity regimes. The latter may be linked to the depletion of oxygen in the gas-phase due to its incorporation onto dust grains \journalinfo The Open Journal of Astrophysics 1 Introduction Sulphur (S), while not the most abundant element, ranks among the most prevalent metals in the Universe. Sulphur is primarily produced through nucleosynthesis via the alpha-chain in massive stars that later eject it into the interstellar medium (ISM). Consequently, S/H serves as a tracer for the total metal content in the gas-phase of galaxies and, when compared with other species, such as oxygen (O), it also provides insights into the processes of production, ejection, and mixing within the gas-phase. Given its main channel of production and mass range of the stars creating it, S abundance is usually assumed to scale with O abundance following solar proportions (i.e. log(S/O) ⊙ = -1.57, Asplund et al. 2009 ), which is consistent with the results obtained in several works (e.g. Garnett et al. 1997 ; Izotov et al. 2006 ; Berg et al. 2020 ). However, despite this general consistency, other research supports a constant S/O ratio slightly below the solar value ( Kehrig et al. 2006 ) , and even some studies have found non-negligible deviations from this ratio at distinct metallicity regimes. For instance, some authors find evidence of an increasing S/O ratio with decreasing metallicity (e.g. Vilchez et al. 1988 ; Dors et al. 2016 ; Zinchenko et al. 2024 ), what could be explained by e.g., including pair-instability supernovae (PISN) in chemical modeling ( Goswami et al. 2024 ) . Moreover, the observed behavior of S/O as a function of metallicity could be even bimodal, according to Díaz & Zamora 2022 , as, besides the high S values found in the metal-poor regime and after finding low S/O at solar metallicity, also report an increase of S/O for higher values, this latter possibly related with the different refractory nature of O and S ( Henry 1993 ) . This result, with very low S/O values in some galaxies with solar-like oxygen abundances has also been reported by Pérez-Díaz et al. 2024a based on sulphur infrared emission lines. The determination of S abundances in the gas-phase of galaxies in the optical and near-IR ranges, the unique so far for which a statistically significant amount of objects can be studied to explore S/O at all regimes, can be made by means of several bright emission lines of collisional nature (CELs) (i.e. [S ii ] \lambda 6717,31 Å [S iii ] \lambda 9069,9532 Å). On one hand, the relative abundances of the ions responsible for the emission of these lines can be accurately determined following the direct or t_{e} method ( Pérez-Montero 2017 ) , if, in addition, their respective auroral lines (i.e. [S ii ] 4068,4072 Å, [S iii ] 6312 Å) can also be measured with enough confidence to allow for a determination of the corresponding electron temperatures. However, one of the main drawbacks of the optical regime to be used for the derivation of S abundance stays on the fact that a non-negligible fraction of the sulphur abundance can be found in higher stages of ionization, such as S +3 , only measurable in the infra-red regime (e.g. at [S iv ] \lambda 10.5 \mu m) ( Vermeij & van der Hulst 2002 ) . The acquisition of mid-IR data can thus be undertaken to have a more precise quantification of the total sulphur abundance, above all in nebula ionized by very hard incident radiation fields, such as Extreme Emission Line Galaxies (EELGs) or Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN). Therefore, if the observed spectrum is not complete, even if the direct method can be applied, additional assumptions can be made to calculate the total S abundance by means of an ionization correction factor (ICF) to account for the sulphur stages unseen in the optical or IR parts, contributing to enhance the uncertainty of the S abundance derivation ( Stasińska 1978 ; Pérez-Montero et al. 2006 ; Dors et al. 2016 ) . The emissivity of the auroral line from [S iii ] at \lambda 6312 Å as an advantage in relation to the auroral lines emitted by other elements, such as [O iii [ \lambda 4363 Å, depends less on temperature, making it easier to detect at higher metallicity (e.g. Castellanos et al. 2002 ; Bresolin et al. 2005 ). Nevertheless, as the direct method for the determination of S abundances can hardly be applied in large samples composed of weak/distant objects, the estimation of S chemical abundance in the gas-phase must rely on the application of other techniques based on strong detected emission-lines. For instance, one of the most widely used parameters based uniquely on strong sulphur CELs is the S23 parameter, defined by Vilchez & Esteban 1996 as: S23=\frac{\mathrm{[S\,II]}6717,6731\AA+\mathrm{[S\,III]}9069,9532\AA}{H\beta} (1) This parameter was calibrated to provide an estimate of the total oxygen abundance ( Díaz & Pérez-Montero 2000 ; Pérez-Montero & Díaz 2005 ), and also as a direct tracer of the total sulphur abundance by Pérez-Montero et al. 2006 . However, the fact that the same parameter can be used either as a tracer for O, or for S, underlines the basic assumption of a constant S/O, so it cannot be used to figure out the variation of S/O with metallicity. Another alternative to calculate abundances is the use of photoionization models, that when tailored to individual objects can account for the calculation of either ICF when auroral lines are detected, or the total S abundance from the unique use of strong lines, (e.g. Evans

Read the complete text