Triangular instability of a strained Batchelor vortex

A. S. P. Ayapilla, Y. Hattori, S. Le Dizès · 2025

Read Triangular instability of a strained Batchelor vortex by A. S. P. Ayapilla, Y. Hattori, S. Le Dizès (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-14717.txt.

Introduction

Ayapilla, Hattori, and Le Dizès study how a triangular strain field destabilizes a swirling Batchelor vortex. Three satellite vortices squeeze the main one into a three-fold shape. Waves riding the core can resonate with that strain and grow. Theory pairs core modes whose wave counts differ by three.

Simulations of the linearized flow equations check the predicted growth rates. Without axial flow, only one mode pair breaks loose. A modest axial stream wakes three more pairs by easing critical layer damping. The champion mode swaps identity as the stream strengthens. A full instability map over flow strength caps the study.

Catalog record

CREATORA. S. P. Ayapilla, Y. Hattori, S. Le Dizès
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE88 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-14717

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Triangular instability of a strained Batchelor vortex A. S. P. Ayapilla, Y. Hattori, S. Le Dizès Abstract We investigate the triangular instability of a Batchelor vortex subjected to a stationary triangular strain field generated by three satellite vortices, in the presence of weak axial flow. The analysis combines theoretical predictions with numerical simulations. Theoretically, the instability arises from resonant coupling between two quasi-neutral Kelvin modes with azimuthal wavenumbers m m and m + 3 m+3 with the background strain. Numerically, we solve the linearized Navier–Stokes equations around a quasi-steady base flow to identify the most unstable modes, and compare their growth rates and frequencies with theoretical predictions for a Reynolds number R ​ e = 10 4 {Re}=10^{4} and a straining strength ϵ = 0.008 \epsilon=0.008 . In the absence of axial flow, only the mode pair ( m A , m B ) = ( − 1 , 2 ) (m_{A},m_{B})=(-1,2) (and its symmetric counterpart) is unstable. However, we show that additional combinations such as ( 0 , 3 ) (0,3) , ( 1 , 4 ) (1,4) , and ( 2 , 5 ) (2,5) —which are otherwise strongly damped by the critical layer in the absence of axial flow—also become unstable once axial flow exceeds a certain threshold, as the critical layer damping is significantly reduced. Furthermore, we show that the most unstable mode in the no-axial-flow case—originating from the second branch of m = − 1 m=-1 and the first branch of m = 2 m=2 —becomes less unstable as axial flow increases. It is eventually overtaken by a mode from the first branches of both wavenumbers, which then remains the dominant unstable mode across a wide range of axial flow strengths and Reynolds numbers. A comprehensive instability diagram as a function of the axial flow parameter is presented. 1 Introduction Vortices are naturally prone to instabilities triggered by small disturbances, which can amplify through inviscid or viscous mechanisms either within the vortex core or via interactions with the surrounding flow. Understanding vortex stability is of great theoretical interest and practical importance across a wide range of natural and industrial flows, including geophysical and astrophysical systems, aircraft wakes, and various rotating flows. A detailed overview of vortex stability theory can be found in Ash et al. 1995 . Among the various types of instabilities, short-wave instabilities occur at scales comparable to or smaller than the vortex core. These arise through parametric resonance, where two Kelvin modes of the underlying vortex become resonant with the vortex correction induced by the background strain. Depending on the nature of the background strain, two well-studied types of short-wave instabilities are: (1) the elliptic instability, where the strain induces a quadrupolar correction that causes elliptic deformation of the vortex streamlines, and (2) the curvature instability, where a dipolar correction is introduced. The elliptic instability is a key mechanism by which vortex pairs, such as wingtip vortices of airplanes, develop instabilities, alongside the Crow instability ( Crow 1970 ; Leweke et al. 2016 ) . In such cases, each vortex induces a quadrupolar correction on its counterpart, leading to elliptic bending of streamlines and the onset of elliptic instability. In contrast, curvature instability typically arises from the bending of vortex tubes, such as in curved filaments and vortex rings, where the curvature creates a dipolar correction. Moore & Saffman 1975 and Tsai & Widnall 1976 were the first to explain this mechanism as a parametric resonance, for the Lamb-Oseen vortex and Rankine vortex, respectively. A thorough summary of the elliptic instability is provided by Kerswell 2002 , with notable contributions from Pierrehumbert 1986 ; Bayly 1986 ; Leweke & Williamson 1998 ; Le Dizes & Laporte 2002 ; Meunier & Leweke 2005 ; Schaeffer & Le Dizès 2010 ; Blanco-Rodríguez & Le Dizès 2016 ; Lacaze et al. 2007 among others. Curvature instability was first observed in a helical vortex filament by Widnall 1972 , along with long-wave and mutual-inductance instability modes. Further theoretical and numerical studies on vortex rings and helical vortices include works by Hattori & Fukumoto 2003 ; Fukumoto & Hattori 2005 ; Blanco-Rodríguez & Le Dizès 2017 ; Hattori et al. 2019 ; Xu et al. 2025 among others. Multipolar short-wave instabilities, involving strain of order higher than two or non-axisymmetric vortices with higher symmetries, have received comparatively little attention. Long-lived non-axisymmetric vortices—such as dipoles, tripoles, and higher-order multipoles—have been observed in rotating turbulent flows through experiments and simulations ( Hopfinger & Van Heijst 1993 ; Carnevale & Kloosterziel 1994 ; Rossi et al. 1997 ; Dritschel 1998 ) . There is also evidence of Kelvin waves emerging on vortex filaments in transitional flows ( Arendt et al. 1998 ) , with elliptic and multipolar instabilities potentially explaining their appearance and providing a mechanism for rich vortex dynamics of turbulent flows and transition. Multipolar instability has been studied theoretically and numerically for Rankine vortices ( Le Dizès & Eloy 1999 ; Le Dizes 2000 ; Eloy & Le Dizès 2001 ) , with experimental evidence of triangular instability reported in rotating cylinder configurations ( Eloy et al. 2000 ; Eloy et al. 2003 ) . However, Rankine vortices are idealized, whereas models with continuous vorticity distributions, such as Lamb–Oseen and Batchelor vortices—self-similar solutions of the Navier–Stokes equations—offer a more realistic representation of vortices in wakes and rotating flows, with multipolar instability particularly having potential implications in rotor wakes such as wind turbines and ship propellers. This highlights the importance of studying multipolar instabilities in these models. Additionally, continuous vorticity profiles give rise to critical layers, which suppress many Kelvin modes and significantly affect instability behaviour ( Sipp & Jacquin 2003 ; Fabre & Jacquin 2004 ; Le Dizès 2004 ; Le Dizès & Lacaze 2005 ; Fabre et al. 2006 ) . In a recent study ( Ayapilla et al. 2025 ) , we presented the first evidence of triangular instability in a Lamb–Oseen vortex and characterized its behaviour both theoretically and numerically. For brevity, we refer to Ayapilla et al. 2025 as AHL25. However, it is important to extend this analysis to the Batchelor vortex. In reality, vortices in wakes often possess a non-zero axial flow component, and the Batchelor vortex is recognized as a better model for trailing vortices in aircraft wakes ( Batchelor 1964 ) . Rotor wakes—such as in Joukowski’s rotor wake model—typically consist of a hub vortex, root vortices, and tip vortices, where the hub vortex generally possesses axial flow. Therefore, investigating the effect of axial flow on the triangular instability is crucial. The influence of axial flow on the elliptic instability has been examined for a Rankine vortex by Lacaze et al. 2005 and for the Batchelor vortex by Lacaze et al. 2007 . These works showed that adding a small axial flow slightly modifies the dispersion curves and breaks the symmetry between Kelvin modes, leading to new resonant modes and altering how the critical layer affects the modes. For example, beyond the well-known stationary helical modes m=1 and -1 in the elliptic instability of the Lamb–Oseen vortex, modes with m=0 , 2 , and other pairs were also shown to become unstable. The asymptotic behaviour of the Kelvin modes of the

Read the complete text