Bistability in radiatively heated melt ponds
Rui Yang, Christopher J. Howland, Hao-Ran Liu, Roberto Verzicco, Detlef Lohse · 2025
Read Bistability in radiatively heated melt ponds by Rui Yang, Christopher J. Howland, Hao-Ran Liu, Roberto Verzicco, Detlef Lohse (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-14093.txt.
Introduction
Rui Yang and co-authors find two stable states in melt ponds on ice in a 2025 study. Melt ponds form when sun melts the top of glaciers and sea ice. Dark pond water soaks up heat and lowers reflectivity, a climate lever. Flows and freezing intertwine inside each pond.
Direct simulations plus theory reveal a tipping point. As sunlight and start depth vary, the pond snaps from fully frozen to a set melt depth. A heat flux balance model captures the snap and matches the runs. A classic convection theory then predicts pond temperature and flow strength well. The work sharpens how ice melt feeds back on Earth heat balance.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rui Yang, Christopher J. Howland, Hao-Ran Liu, Roberto Verzicco, Detlef Lohse |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-14093
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Bistability in radiatively heated melt ponds Rui Yang, Christopher J. Howland, Hao-Ran Liu, Roberto Verzicco, Detlef Lohse Abstract Melting and solidification processes, intertwined with convective flows, play a fundamental role in geophysical contexts. One of these processes is the formation of melt ponds on glaciers, ice shelves, and sea ice. It is driven by solar radiation and is of great significance for the Earth’s heat balance, as it significantly lowers the albedo. Through direct numerical simulations and theoretical analysis, we unveil a bistability phenomenon in the melt pond dynamics. As solar radiation intensity and the melt pond’s initial depth vary, an abrupt transition occurs: This tipping point transforms the system from a stable fully frozen state to another stable equilibrium state, characterized by a distinct melt pond depth. The physics of this transition can be understood within a heat flux balance model, which exhibits excellent agreement with our numerical results. Together with the Grossmann-Lohse theory for internally heated convection, the model correctly predicts the bulk temperature and the flow strength within the melt ponds, offering insight into the coupling of phase transitions with adjacent turbulent flows and the interplay between convective melting and radiation-driven processes. Flow mediated melting and solidification are fundamental processes in geophysics, encompassing icebergs ( ristroph2018sculpting ) , subglacial lakes, and sea ice holland2006future . Accurately quantifying these processes is critical for improving the estimate of the global ice melt rate eisenman2009nonlinear ; edwards_projected_2021 ; cenedese2022icebergs and climate models, where many small-scale processes are usually disregarded or parameterized holland1999role ; stroeve2007arctic . One of these small-scale processes is the formation and evolution of melt ponds, which recently have been identified as a key factor in the energy balance of Earth’s polar regions schroder2014september , and therefore in correctly modeling climate change. The reason is that the presence of liquid water on the surface of ice significantly alters the surface albedo, leading to increased absorption of solar radiation rather than reflection holland2006future . This enhanced absorption intensifies heating and accelerates the melting process. Consequently, the formation and growth of melt ponds globally contribute to the amplification of ice melt, including ice shelves van2023variable , sea ice popovic2018simple , ice sheets sneed2007evolution , and mountain glaciers miles2018surface . Previous studies considered different modeling approaches to investigate the evolution of melt ponds, such as a simple disk-filling model popovic2018simple , a 1D melt-pond model based on a two-stream radiation mode taylor2004model , and an Ising model for melt ponds ma2019ising , which provides similarity with real melt ponds in the length scale and fractal dimension. However, due to their complexity and numerous strong & simplifying assumptions, existing models of melt pond evolution provide only a limited fundamental understanding. Therefore, next to field measurement, lab experiments, and direct numerical simulations (DNS) of the melting process with radiative heating are indispensable to understanding the evolution of melt ponds from a fundamental point of view. Such lab experiments and DNS have often been cast in the framework of Rayleigh-Bénard (RB) convection davis1984pattern ; esfahani2018basal ; favier2019 ; yang2023morphology , i.e., the flow in a box heated from below and cooled from above ahlers2009 ; Lohse2010 ; Chilla2012 ; shishkina2021rayleigh . What must be considered here is that the water within melt ponds is typically freshwater below 4^{o}C , where density increases with temperature. Indeed, this density anomaly effect on the melting process plays a significant role in the flow structure and melt dynamics wang2021growth ; wang2021equilibrium ; wang2021ice ; yang2022abrupt . Moreover, the influence of solar radiative heating, the primary heat source for melt ponds, which is usually considered as an exponentially decaying profile, is different from the fixed temperature or heat flux boundary condition in RB. Factors such as cloud patterns and diurnal cycles can cause solar radiation variations. Additionally, natural factors like topography or the accumulation of meltwater can lead to the formation of a water layer Scagliarini2020 . These effects are still less investigated. Figure 1: Snapshot of the temperature field of our simplified simulation setup at the final stable equilibrium stages with melt pond formation, with the diffusive equilibrium initial condition from eq. ( 3 ). The object of this Letter is a comprehensive understanding of melt pond formation. Therefore, within the RB framework, we numerically investigate the evolution of the melt pond depth under (varying) solar radiation, for which we use the Beer-Lambert model calloway1997beer . Our simple model captures the key physical processes relevant to melt ponds: radiation, convection, and melting. Our main numerical finding is a bistability of the system, leading to a tipping-point-like behavior, where a small change in radiation strength or initial melt pond depth triggers an abrupt change in the final melt pond state. We further provide a theoretical explanation for the observed bistability and regime transition based on the heat flux balance between ice and water, exhibiting good agreement with our numerical results. Additionally, we successfully predict the dependences of the bulk temperature and the flow intensity on the solar radiation strength with the help of the Grossmann-Lohse theory for internally heated convective flows grossmann2000scaling ; grossmann2001thermal ; wang2021scaling . We perform both two-dimensional (2D) and three-dimensional (3D) numerical simulations, integrating the velocity field u and the temperature field \theta according to the Navier-Stokes equations, employing the Oberbeck-Boussinesq (OB) approximation, i.e., we consider the density \rho to be linear in temperature as \rho=\rho_{0}(1+\alpha(T-T_{0})) , with the thermal expansion coefficient \alpha>0 since the maximum density of water is attained at 4^{o}C and melt ponds are typically below 2^{o}C kim2018salinity , and assume all other material properties to be temperature independent. The melting/freezing process is simulated with the phase-field method (PF), which has been extensively used for phase boundary evolutions favier2019 ; hester2020improved ; hester2021aspect ; couston2021topography ; yang2023morphology . More details of the method and validations can be found in our previous work yang2023morphology ; yang2023salinity . We further checked the effect of grid resolution and the phase-field-related parameter on the bifurcation and found robustness, see Supplementary Material. We set the top wall as free slip and adiabatic, the bottom wall as a fixed temperature T_{c}=-3^{o}C (a simplified estimated value from experiment measurement bliss2020glaciers , in a real scenario it likely depends on heat flux through the solid ice – the effect of T_{c} will be discussed below), and the sidewalls as no-slip and adiabatic. Lateral heat loss could also matter, as it can modify the flow pattern and the local heat flux. Here, we neglected its effect by assuming the melt pond is wide enough and thus the sidewall effect only plays a minor role, similarly as it does for the evolution of the melt pond morphology Scagliarini2020 . Our model flow is confined in a rectangular box, with height H , width W , and length L , with gravity acting vertically downwards. The aspect ratio is set at W/H=2 for 2D and L/H=1 for 3D, with a dimensional depth of H=0.2m , representative of common melt pond depths skyllingstad2007numerical ; taylor2004model . Figure 2: (a) The temporal evolution of 2D melt pond depth for various h_{i} while maintaining a fixed I_{0}=35W/m^{2} . The initial temperature profile is given by eq. ( 3 ). t_{f} is the dimensionless time in free-fall