Two Higgs Doublet Solutions to the Strong CP Problem

Quentin Bonnefoy, Lawrence Hall, Claudio Andrea Manzari, and Bea Noether · 2025

Read Two Higgs Doublet Solutions to the Strong CP Problem by Quentin Bonnefoy, Lawrence Hall, Claudio Andrea Manzari, and Bea Noether (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-13853.txt.

Introduction

Quentin Bonnefoy and co-authors solve a deep puzzle in particle physics in their 2025 paper on the strong CP problem. The strong force should, by the math, break a key symmetry far more than experiments allow. Their fix uses theories with two Higgs fields instead of one, plus flavor symmetries that set the offending term to zero.

The team proves the term also stays zero at the first level of quantum corrections, no matter how heavy the second Higgs is. In one sample model, the leftover effect is tiny. In another, it could show up in planned lab tests. The setup also predicts small shifts in how the known Higgs couples to other particles, which future colliders could spot.

Catalog record

CREATORQuentin Bonnefoy, Lawrence Hall, Claudio Andrea Manzari, and Bea Noether
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE75 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-13853

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Two Higgs Doublet Solutions to the Strong CP Problem Quentin Bonnefoy, Lawrence Hall, Claudio Andrea Manzari, and Bea Noether Abstract We solve the strong CP problem in a broad class of two Higgs doublet theories that will be probed at the Large Hadron Collider and at future colliders. These theories feature CP and Abelian flavor symmetries, both broken softly in the scalar potential, that yield realistic quark masses and mixings. The flavor symmetry charges are chosen so that θ ¯ = 0 \bar{\theta}=0 at tree level for all values of the Yukawa and quartic couplings of the theory. We prove that in all such theories the 1-loop contribution to θ ¯ \bar{\theta} also vanishes, independently of the mass scale of the second Higgs doublet. We study two illustrative models with flavor group ℤ 3 \mathbb{Z}_{3} . The direct contributions to the neutron electric dipole moment are negligible in both models. While the 2-loop contribution to θ ¯ \bar{\theta} is less than 10 − 12 10^{-12} in one model, it can be as large as 10 − 10 10^{-10} in the other, yielding the prospect of a signal in planned experiments. Even with Abelian flavor symmetries, CP violation in neutral kaon mixing is generally expected to yield naturalness bounds on the masses of additional Higgs doublets of order 20 TeV. We prove that for all models in our class, where the flavor symmetry forces θ ¯ \bar{\theta} to vanish at tree-level, the flavor-changing neutral currents are CP-conserving, yielding model-dependent bounds from neutral meson mixing near 1 TeV. Mixing of the two CP-even scalars gives corrections to the couplings of the 125 GeV Higgs state to t ¯ ​ t , b ¯ ​ b , c ¯ ​ c , τ ¯ ​ τ \bar{t}t,\bar{b}b,\bar{c}c,\bar{\tau}\tau and μ ¯ ​ μ \bar{\mu}\mu , giving possible signals at high luminosity runs at LHC and at future colliders. Furthermore, distinctive correlations between corrections in the various channels can probe the underlying flavor symmetry. 1 Introduction The strong CP problem, which refers to the absence of violation of the combination of Parity (P) and Charge-conjugation (C) in the strong interactions, is one of the most compelling puzzles in particle physics. The strength of the potential violation is described by the dimensionless parameter \bar{\theta} which is constrained by the experimental limit on the neutron electric dipole moment (nEDM): \bar{\theta}\leq 10^{-10} Pendlebury:2015lrz . In the Standard Model (SM) of particle physics, the parameter \bar{\theta} receives two distinct contributions. The first arises from the Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) Lagrangian, which, constrained only by Lorentz and gauge invariance, includes a CP-odd term : \theta_{\rm QCD}\frac{g_{s}^{2}}{32\pi^{2}}G_{a}^{\mu\nu}\tilde{G}_{a,\mu\nu}\ , (1) where G_{a}^{\mu\nu} is the gluon field strength tensor, g_{s} is the strong coupling constant, and \tilde{G}_{a,\mu\nu}=\frac{1}{2}\epsilon_{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}G_{a}^{\alpha\beta} . The second contribution to \bar{\theta} arises from the chiral transformations required to diagonalize the quark Yukawa matrices, y^{u} and y^{d} , leading to \bar{\theta}=\theta_{\rm QCD}+\arg\det(y^{u}y^{d})\ . (2) These two contributions stem from entirely different SM sectors and have no intrinsic reason to cancel; the SM does not provide a theoretical understanding of the smallness of \bar{\theta} . Among the proposed strategies to solve this problem, one class of solutions invokes a fundamental CP Georgi:1978xz ; Mohapatra:1979kg ; Nelson:1983zb ; Barr:1984qx ; Glashow:2001yz ; Feruglio:2023uof ; Feruglio:2024ytl ; Hall:2024xbd ; Feruglio:2025ajb or P Babu:1988mw ; Babu:1989rb ; Barr:1991qx ; Hall:2018let ; Dunsky:2019api ; Bonnefoy:2023yoj symmetry at high energies, which is either softly or spontaneously broken, having significant implications for the SM flavor sector. In such scenarios, CP or P ensures \theta_{\rm QCD}=0 , necessitating a mechanism that accounts for the large CP-violating phase observed in weak interactions while simultaneously explaining why \arg\det(y^{u}y^{d}) remains small. While it could seem ad hoc to impose P or CP at the Lagrangian (or path integral) level in a QFT model, this finds an elegant realization in string theory, where they can arise as gauge symmetries and be spontaneously broken by the expectation values of moduli and matter fields Strominger:1985it ; Dine:1992ya ; Choi:1992xp ; Maiezza:2021dui . Motivated by early models addressing the strong CP problem Georgi:1978xz ; Segre:1979dx ; Mohapatra:1979kg ; Glashow:2001yz , some of us introduced a class of multi-Higgs doublet extensions of the SM that solves the strong CP problem Hall:2024xbd . (See Refs. Nebot:2018nqn ; Ferreira:2019aps ; Ferro-Hernandez:2024snl for other studies of multi-Higgs theories that consider the strong CP problem.) This framework is based on CP and a flavor symmetry, G_{HF} , both softly broken only in the scalar potential. Ref. Hall:2024xbd found many choices for G_{HF} and for G_{HF} -charges of quarks and scalars that lead to fully realistic Yukawa coupling matrices describing the observed quark masses and mixing while giving \bar{\theta}=0 at tree-level. In addition, it was found that radiative contributions to \bar{\theta} vanished in all theories with two Higgs doublets, providing the mass of the second Higgs doublet is significantly larger than the electroweak scale. In this framework, the mass scale for the additional Higgs doublets ranges over many orders of magnitude and was typically taken far above the TeV scale, even at the cost of significant fine-tuning for the SM Higgs. The lower bound on this mass scale was not investigated. In this paper, we prove that there is a large class of models with two Higgs doublets (2HDM), including the list presented in Ref. Hall:2024xbd , where there are no one-loop corrections to \bar{\theta} , regardless of the mass scale of the second Higgs doublet. Furthermore, we discuss radiative corrections to \bar{\theta} at two-loops, presenting two illustrative models where these are well below the current experimental limit. Given that there is a theoretical advantage to having a low mass scale for the second Higgs doublet, namely that a low-scale UV completion of the theory allows much less fine-tuning than for a heavier Higgs, we study in this paper how light the second Higgs doublet can be. Since our theories do not satisfy the Glashow-Weinberg criterion Glashow:1976nt , dimensional analysis suggests that the lower bound on the heavy Higgs mass from CP violation in neutral meson mixing is of order 10^{5} TeV. This turns out to be incorrect for two reasons. First, a flavor symmetry restricts the relevant Yukawa couplings to be much less than unity, lowering the expected bound to around 20 TeV Hall:1993ca . However, this is also a significant overestimate as we prove a surprising result: in all 2HDM with an abelian flavor symmetry that imposes \bar{\theta}=0 at tree-level, all neutral flavor-changing interactions are CP conserving. Hence, our results motivate experimental searches for theories with two Higgs doublets that solve the strong CP problem, both directly at current and future colliders and in flavor-changing processes as well as direct contributions to electric dipole moments. The paper is structured as follows. In Sec. 2 we discuss the theories presented in Ref. Hall:2024xbd . In Sec. 3 and Sec. 4 we discuss the generalities of the scalar potential and Yukawa sector of theories with two Higgs doublets. The solution to the strong CP problem in these theories is studied in Sec. 5 . In Sec. 6 we present two illustrative models, showing that they account for the observed quark masses and mixings and have a two-loop contribution to \bar{\theta} well below the experimental

Read the complete text