A H α \alpha metric for identifying dormant black holes in X-ray transients

J. Casares, M.A.P. Torres and S. Navarro Umpiérrez · 2025

Read A H α \alpha metric for identifying dormant black holes in X-ray transients by J. Casares, M.A.P. Torres and S. Navarro Umpiérrez (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-13765.txt.

Introduction

Casares and co-authors sharpen a way to spot sleeping black holes in binary systems, in a 2025 paper. A glow line from the gas disk around such a hole runs broad, but a class of small binaries can fake the same breadth. Sorting true holes from fakes matters for census work.

The team compared the line's width and strength across twenty quiet black hole systems and more than three hundred fifty rival binaries. Both measures shrink as the orbit lengthens, yet holes sit higher at any given period. Donor star dilution explains much of the trend. A tentative cut on the two measures keeps about eighty percent of holes while rejecting most fakes.

Catalog record

CREATORJ. Casares, M.A.P. Torres and S. Navarro Umpiérrez
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE78 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-13765

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A H α \alpha metric for identifying dormant black holes in X-ray transients J. Casares, M.A.P. Torres and S. Navarro Umpiérrez Abstract Dormant black holes in X-ray transients can be identified by the presence of broad H α \alpha emission lines from quiescent accretion discs. Unfortunately, short-period cataclysmic variables can also produce broad H α \alpha lines, especially when viewed at high inclinations, and are thus a major source of contamination. Here we compare the full width at half maximum (FWHM) and equivalent width (EW) of the H α \alpha line in a sample of 20 quiescent black hole transients and 354 cataclysmic variables (305 from SDSS I to IV) with secure orbital periods ( P orb P_{\rm orb} ) and find that: (1) FWHM and EW values decrease with P orb P_{\rm orb} , and (2) for a given P orb P_{\rm orb} both parameters are typically larger in black hole transients than in cataclysmic variables. We also compile spectral types for 17 low-mass companions in black hole transients from the literature and derive an empirical P orb − T eff P_{\rm orb}-T_{\rm eff} calibration. Using this, we conclude that the decrease in EW with P orb P_{\rm orb} is mostly driven by the dilution of the H α \alpha flux by the donor star continuum, which dominates the r-band spectrum for P orb ≳ 0.2 P_{\rm orb}\gtrsim 0.2 d. At shorter periods, the larger contribution of the disc to the total r-band flux introduces significant scatter in the EWs due to the changing visibility of the disc projected area with binary inclination. On the other hand, the larger EWs observed in black holes can be explained by their extreme mass ratios (which limit the fractional contribution of the companion to the total flux) and the absence of a white dwarf component (important at P orb ≲ 0.085 P_{\rm orb}\lesssim 0.085 d). Finally, we present a tentative metric, based on H α \alpha FWHM and EW information, and provide optimal cuts to select ∼ \sim 80 % of the black hole X-ray transients, while rejecting ∼ \sim 78 % of the cataclysmic variables in our sample. Such a metric, combined with other multi-frequency diagnostics, can help detect new dormant black hole X-ray transients in blind large-scale surveys such as H α {\alpha} WKs and its pathfinder, Mini-H α {\alpha} WKs. 1 Introduction Over the past 50 years, black hole X-ray transients (BH XRTs) have provided us with special windows through which to study accretion processes in extreme environments, supernova explosions, and the evolution of close binary systems. In recent years, other BH populations have also been revealed by gravitational wave detectors ( Abbott et al. 2019 ) and Gaia astrometry (e.g. Gaia Collaboration et al. 2024 ). n this context, XRTs remain a key benchmark for BH properties, as they are supposed to descend from a well-defined binary evolution channel at near solar metallicity, involving a common envelope phase (but see Naoz et al. 2016 , also Burdge et al. 2024 , for an alternative formation pathway in hierarchical triples). With only 20 dynamically confirmed cases and another \approx 50 candidates ( Corral-Santana et al. 2016 ) , the current sample of BH XRTs is severely limited by small numbers. In addition, the sample is X-ray selected, and thus biased towards transients with short recurrence times and high outburst luminosities ( Wu et al. 2010 ; Lin et al. 2019 ) . Other complex X-ray selection biases may also be at play, such as high-inclination BHs concealed by disc obscuration ( Narayan & McClintock 2005 ; Corral-Santana et al. 2013 ) , a potential lack of short-period ( < 4 h), radiatively inefficient BH transients ( Knevitt et al. 2014 , see also Arur & Maccarone 2018 ), period gap BH XRTs with very low X-ray luminosities ( Maccarone & Patruno 2013 ) , or the possible existence of faint, persistent (i.e. non-transient) BH X-ray binaries with long orbital periods ( Menou et al. 1999 ) . In addition, both the Galactic distribution of XRTs and their BH masses are likely to be shaped by natal kicks ( Gandhi et al. 2020 ) and obscuration by interstellar extinction ( Jonker et al. 2021 ) . Similarly, while the existence of the so-called lower mass-gap (i.e. dearth of BHs with masses between \simeq 2-5 M ⊙ ), appears robust against transient selection effects ( Siegel et al. 2023 ) , it depends critically on our ability to measure accurate masses in the presence of accretion disc contamination ( Kreidberg et al. 2012 ) . A significant step forward in the statistics of BH XRTs, with a more cleanly selected sample, is therefore fundamental to disentangling selection biases and advancing our knowledge of this reference population. In an attempt to increase the number of BH XRTs, we have developed a series of scaling relations between fundamental binary parameters and the properties of the H \alpha emission line, formed in the accretion disc around the BH ( Casares 2015 ; Casares 2016 ; Casares et al. 2022 ). In particular, a correlation between the H \alpha full width at half maximum (FWHM) and the radial velocity semi-amplitude of the companion star ( K_{2} ) allows for the extraction of compact object mass functions in systems where the spectrum of the donor star is not detected ( Casares 2015 ; hereafter C15). This requires independent knowledge of the orbital period, which can be obtained from light curve variability. If the FWHM is also measured photometrically, this opens up the new concept of ‘photometric mass function’, whereby BHs can be searched for and weighed photometrically in large fields of view, i.e. much more efficiently than by classical spectroscopy (see C15). In Casares 2018 (hereafter C18), we present a proof of concept of how to obtain H \alpha FWHMs using three custom interference filters of different widths. We also propose a new strategy (H \alpha WKs, an acronym for ’ H \alpha -Width Kilodegree survey ’) optimised for the detection of dormant 1 1 1 We consider dormant BHs to be quiescent BH XRTs that will eventually trigger an outburst episode. Therefore, we will hereafter use the terms, ’dormant’ and ’quiescent’ interchangeably. BH XRTs in a blind survey of the Galactic plane. In addition to H \alpha widths, the H \alpha WKs photometric system also provides equivalent width (EW) information. Furthermore, as the three filters are centred at 6563 Å, the results are invariant to interstellar extinction and the spectral energy distribution of the objects. H {\alpha} WKs was subsequently validated in a feasibility test, demonstrating that H \alpha FWHM and EW values can be recovered within 10% accuracy in a sample of quiescent BH XRTs down to at least r=22 ( Casares & Torres 2018 ) . Essentially, H {\alpha} WKs exploits the width of the Doppler-broadened H \alpha line as a proxy for the deep gravitational fields of compact stars, enabling the efficient selection of dormant BHs. To some extent, the approach is similar to reverberation mapping techniques, whereby line widths from the broad line region are used to weigh super-massive BHs in active galactic nuclei (e.g. Peterson et al. 2004 ). A

Read the complete text