Impact of embedded 163 Ho on the performance of the transition-edge sensor microcalorimeters of the HOLMES experiment Journal: Eur. Phys. J. C

Douglas Bennett addr1, Matteo Borghesi addr5,addr6, Pietro Campana addr5,addr6, Rodolfo Carobene addr5,addr6, Giancarlo Ceruti addr6, Matteo De Gerone addr3, Marco Faverzani addr5,addr6, Lorenzo Ferrari Barusso addr3,addr4, Elena Ferri addr6, Joseph Fowler addr1, Sara Gamba addr5,addr6, Flavio Gatti · 2025

Read Impact of embedded 163 Ho on the performance of the transition-edge sensor microcalorimeters of the HOLMES experiment Journal: Eur. Phys. J. C by Douglas Bennett addr1, Matteo Borghesi addr5,addr6, Pietro Campana addr5,addr6, Rodolfo Carobene addr5,addr6, Giancarlo Ceruti addr6, Matteo De Gerone addr3, Marco Faverzani addr5,addr6, Lorenzo Ferrari Barusso addr3,addr4, Elena Ferri addr6, Joseph Fowler addr1, Sara Gamba addr5,addr6, Flavio Gatti (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-13665.txt.

Introduction

Douglas Bennett and a large team wrote a 2025 paper on how radioactive holmium placed inside the detectors used by HOLMES affects their work. HOLMES aims to weigh the neutrino by watching holmium-163 decay. Its detectors are transition-edge sensor microcalorimeters, tiny heat sensors that log the energy of one decay at a time. Putting holmium atoms inside them adds heat capacity, which can blunt how they respond.

The team built arrays with varied levels of holmium activity and checked energy resolution, decay times, and heat capacity. Energy resolution got worse as activity rose, in line with the rise in heat load the team had looked for. They found the specific heat of holmium-163 at about 94 millikelvin, close to the value for plain holmium metal. No extra slow decay parts showed up in the data. The results guide how much holmium arrays built next can safely carry.

Catalog record

CREATORDouglas Bennett addr1, Matteo Borghesi addr5,addr6, Pietro Campana addr5,addr6, Rodolfo Carobene addr5,addr6, Giancarlo Ceruti addr6, Matteo De Gerone addr3, Marco Faverzani addr5,addr6, Lorenzo Ferrari Barusso addr3,addr4, Elena Ferri addr6, Joseph Fowler addr1, Sara Gamba addr5,addr6, Flavio Gatti
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-13665

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Impact of embedded 163 Ho on the performance of the transition-edge sensor microcalorimeters of the HOLMES experiment Journal: Eur. Phys. J. C Douglas Bennett addr1, Matteo Borghesi addr5,addr6, Pietro Campana addr5,addr6, Rodolfo Carobene addr5,addr6, Giancarlo Ceruti addr6, Matteo De Gerone addr3, Marco Faverzani addr5,addr6, Lorenzo Ferrari Barusso addr3,addr4, Elena Ferri addr6, Joseph Fowler addr1, Sara Gamba addr5,addr6, Flavio Gatti addr3,addr4, Andrea Giachero addr5,addr6, Marco Gobbo addr5,addr6, Danilo Labranca addr5,addr6, Roberto Moretti addr5,addr6, Angelo Nucciotti e1,addr5,addr6, Luca Origo addr6, Stefano Ragazzi addr5,addr6, Dan Schmidt e2,addr1, Daniel Swetz addr1, Joel Ullom addr1,addr2 Abstract We present a detailed investigation of the performance of transition-edge sensor (TES) microcalorimeters with 163 Ho atoms embedded by ion implantation, as part of the HOLMES experiment aimed at neutrino mass determination. The inclusion of 163 Ho atoms introduces an excess heat capacity due to a pronounced Schottky anomaly, which can affect the detector’s energy resolution, signal height, and response time. We fabricated TES arrays with varying levels of 163 Ho activity and characterized their performance in terms of energy resolution, decay time constants, and heat capacity. The intrinsic energy resolution was found to degrade with increasing 163 Ho activity, consistent with the expected scaling of heat capacity. From the analysis, we determined the specific heat capacity of 163 Ho to be ( 2.9 ± 0.4 ​ ( stat ) ± 0.7 ​ ( sys ) ) (2.9\pm 0.4\mathrm{(stat)}\pm 0.7\mathrm{(sys)}) J/K/mol at ( 94 ± 1 ) (94\pm 1) mK, close to the literature values for metallic holmium. No additional long decay time constants correlated with 163 Ho activity were observed, indicating that the excess heat capacity does not introduce weakly coupled thermodynamic systems. These results suggest that our present TES microcalorimeters can tolerate 163 Ho activities up to approximately 5 Bq without significant performance degradation. For higher activities, reducing the TES transition temperature is necessary to maintain energy resolution. These findings provide critical insights for optimizing TES microcalorimeters for future neutrino mass experiments and other applications requiring embedded radioactive sources. The study also highlights the robustness of TES technology in handling implanted radionuclides while maintaining high-resolution performance. ∎ 1 1 1 e-mail: [email protected] 2 2 2 e-mail: [email protected] 1 Introduction Calorimetric measurement of the fraction of energy released in nuclear beta decays that is not carried away by neutrinos was originally proposed to overcome the limitations of external-source spectrometric neutrino mass experiments with tritium simpson_measurement_1981 and 163 Ho derujula_calorimetric_1982 . Pioneering neutrino mass calorimetric experiments have been performed with tritium ions implanted in Si(Li) simpson_measurement_1981 and HPGe hime_evidence_1989 detectors, with 163 Ho ions implanted in HPGe laegsgaard_capture_1984 detectors, and with a high-temperature gas proportional detector containing a gaseous organometallic holmium compound hartmann_high_1992 . In those early experiments based on standard detector technologies, sensitivity was limited by the energy resolution and possibly by solid-state effects franklin_appearance_1995 . The advent of sensitive low-temperature detectors (LTDs) has provided new opportunities to improve calorimetric experiments nucciotti_use_2016b and has expanded the choice of source isotopes. Besides some attempts to use ion-implanted tritium erhardt_transition-edge_2000 ; lowry_beta_1993 , early neutrino mass experiments with LTDs focused on the low Q beta decay of 187 Re in both metallic rhenium fontanelli_data_1999 and dielectric AgReO 4 sisti_new_2004 energy absorbers. However, the very low specific activity of rhenium ( 187 Re, half-life \sim 4\times 10^{10} years) made scaling up these experiments impractical nucciotti_use_2016b . In contrast, the much shorter half-life of electron-capture 163 Ho (about 4750 years) makes it preferable for LTD-based calorimetric experiments, requiring only 10^{11} nuclei per 1 decay/sec. Several approaches have been explored for the inclusion of the 163 Ho source in the absorbers, including the encapsulation by epoxy drops contained in folded tin foils gatti_calorimetric_1997 , the inclusion of holmium in superconducting yttrium compounds gastaldo_superconducting_2004 , or the drying of a holmium-containing solution dripped onto nanoporous gold croce_development_2016 . However, the most promising technique to date remains ion implantation of 163 Ho, adopted by the ECHo gastaldo_electron_2017 and HOLMES alpert_holmes_2015b neutrino mass experiments. Radioactive sources have been embedded in LTD absorbers—mainly via ion implantation—for applications such as 7 Be electron-capture studies for sterile neutrino searches friedrich_limits_2021 , astrophysical process investigations fretwell_direct_2020 , and total decay energy spectroscopy for metrology, safeguards, and other purposes koehler_low_2021 . Recently, tritium generated in LiF LTDs by neutron capture has also been used for sterile neutrino searches lee_lab-scale_2022 . 2 Transition-edge Sensor Microcalorimeters for HOLMES The HOLMES experiment uses transition-edge sensor (TES) microcalorimeters irwin_transition-edge_2005 whose design and fabrication details are described here and in B . In this paper we also investigate how the inclusion of 163 Ho atoms affects the detector response. The TES irwin_transition-edge_2005 microcalorimeters used for this work are specifically designed alpert_high-resolution_2019b to meet the experimental requirements of HOLMES. Mo/Cu bilayer TESs are tuned to have critical temperatures around 95\, mK and are thermally coupled via a thin-film copper link to a 180 \times 180 \times 2\,\mu m 3 gold absorber, in which the 163 Ho is embedded by ion implantation (Fig. 1 ). HOLMES microcalorimeters are designed with the absorber positioned beside the sensor to prevent proximization faverzani2016holmes . Detectors are suspended on a SiN x membrane to provide a finite thermal link G to the thermal bath, which is kept at a constant temperature of 40\, mK. Additional copper banks are inserted to increase G and to control the TES resistance and excess noise hays-wehle_thermal_2016 ; ullom_characterization_2004 ; alpert_high-resolution_2019b . Figure 1: Left: Layout of the TES microcalorimeter, showing the side-by-side Mo/Cu bilayer sensor and gold absorber, with a copper perimeter for enhanced thermal conduction hays-wehle_thermal_2016 . Right: Schematic (not to scale) of the micromachined TES microcalorimeter with embedded 163 Ho as used in this work. The detectors operate as thermal equilibrium calorimeters mccammon_thermal_2005 , where all energy deposited in the absorber is converted into a thermal signal. In the simplest model, the system is treated as a single heat capacity – the sum of absorber and TES electron contributions – characterized by the TES electron temperature. Both signal amplitude and decay time constant depend on this total heat capacity. For accurate performance predictions, electrothermal feedback from constant-voltage TES biasing must be included, as described by the full electrothermal model irwin_transition-edge_2005 . Here, we use its small-signal approximation. For a holmium-based neutrino mass experiment with approximately 1000 detectors to accumulate sufficient statistics to reach neutrino mass sensitivities below 1 eV/c 2 , it is desirable to have per detector activities of several hundred decays per second nucciotti_statistical_2014b . Therefore, it is critical to assess the impact of doping on detector performance. In fact, sensitivity would be adversely affected by excessive deterioration of energy resolution or increase in dead time nucciotti_statistical_2014b ; borghesi_matrix_2022b . The experiment’s dead time is determined by the signal fall time, as any new event occurring during the decay of a previous pulse results in both events being discarded from analysis. Since the fall time is proportional to the heat capacity ( C ), an increased heat capacity leads to longer dead times. Furthermore, the heat capacity directly impacts the achievable energy resolution: for negligible readout noise and in the regime of strong electrothermal feedback, the energy resolution scales as \sqrt{C} , so a larger heat capacity results in poorer energy resolution

Read the complete text