Navigating through CS1: The Role of Self-Regulation and Supervision in Student Progress CCS: Social and professional topics CS1
Ville Isomöttönen, Denis Zhidkikh · 2025
Read Navigating through CS1: The Role of Self-Regulation and Supervision in Student Progress CCS: Social and professional topics CS1 by Ville Isomöttönen, Denis Zhidkikh (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-13461.txt.
Introduction
Ville Isomöttönen and Denis Zhidkikh reported in 2025 on how first-year computing students manage their own learning. Starting university calls for self-regulation: planning work, keeping habits, and asking for help well. Their course trained teaching assistants to watch for study skills during one-to-one supervision, not just code errors.
Interviews with fourteen students gave mixed results. Jobs, past crises in study habits, and traits like grit shaped self-regulation more than the course did. Feeling safe with a supervisor mattered most, while shyness or fear made some students hide problems. The authors urge support that starts from each student's own history.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ville Isomöttönen, Denis Zhidkikh |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 70 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-13461
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Navigating through CS1: The Role of Self-Regulation and Supervision in Student Progress CCS: Social and professional topics CS1 Ville Isomöttönen, Denis Zhidkikh Abstract . The need for students’ self-regulation for fluent transitioning to university studies is known. Our aim was to integrate study-supportive activities with course supervision activities within CS1. We educated TAs to pay attention to students’ study ability and self-regulation. An interview study ( N = 14 N=14 ) was undertaken to investigate this approach. A thematic analysis yielded rather mixed results in light of our aims. Self-regulation was underpinned by the influences external to our setting, including labor market-related needs, earlier crises in study habits, and personal characteristics such as passion, grit, creativity, and valuation of utility. Safety in one-to-one supervision was considered essential, while shyness, fear, and even altruism caused self-handicapping during the course. Students were aware of their learning styles and need for self-regulation, while did not always know how to self-regulate or preferred to externalize it. The results highlight that supporting self-regulation should be integrated with students’ personal histories and experiences, and thereby calls attention to transformative learning pedagogies. The thematization can help to understand CS1 students’ self-regulation processes and improve CS1 support practices. † † authorsaddresses: Corresponding author: Ville Isomöttönen, [email protected] ; University of Jyväskylä, Faculty of Information Technology, P.O. Box 35, FI-40014 Jyväskylä, Finland 1. Introduction New university students face numerous challenges, including managing increased workloads, adapting to new learning styles, and taking greater responsibility for their learning ( Perry et al. 2001 ; Meehan and Howells 2018 ) . In Computer Science (CS) education, challenges related to self-regulation (SRL), self-efficacy, and help-seeking during the first year have been reported in many studies ( Hämäläinen and Isomöttönen 2019 ; Kinnunen and Malmi 2006 ; Petersen et al. 2016 , e.g.,) . Consequently, universities have fostered students’ integration through various services and intervention programs. For instance, universities provide professional counseling, where students consult faculty members for assistance with learning, administrative issues, and career guidance ( Thi Van Pham et al. 2021 , e.g.,) . Additionally, reduced attrition rates have been reported after implementing first-year introductory modules that teach basic meta-learning skills such as information seeking, academic writing, and SRL skills ( Turner et al. 2017 ; Perin 2011 , e.g.,) . Similar subject-oriented “transition courses” that prepare students for core curriculum content have also been found to improve retention and promote social integration ( Kangas et al. 2017 , e.g.,) . Furthermore, Teaching Assistant (TA) programs that employ undergraduate or graduate students as course lecturers’ assistants and a peer support resource have proven popular in CS1 ( Mirza et al. 2019 ) . TAs provide course-specific technical assistance to students, typically through workshops or personal tutoring ( Minnes et al. 2018 , e.g.,) . They also help to alleviate the workload of the course lecturers by editing course materials ( van Dam 2018 ) , grading assignments ( Minnes et al. 2018 ) , and holding office hours. While students are provided with various support avenues, current practices tend to separate student integration from the course context. For instance, organizational support like professional study counselors and introductory modules teach SRL skills but are generally situated outside any courses ( Mason 2019 ) . Students may also be reluctant to seek external support if they hold negative attitudes or stigma towards them ( Giovazolias et al. 2010 , e.g.,) . In that sense, TA programs may help bring counseling and comprehensive support “closer to the student”. In a comprehensive review of TA use in CS, Mirza et al. 2019 conclude that most TA programs focus primarily on training TAs to provide technical, course-specific support and general instruction skills. Moreover, near-peer mentoring programs have shown promise as a means of course-integrated student counseling support ( Pon-Barry et al. 2017 , e.g.,) . The cited study demonstrates an approach that was favorably received by the students according to the feedback. However, we believe that more detailed research is needed to further elaborate on different scenarios that explain students’ self-regulatory processes and use of supervision in such settings. The present study initially aimed to examine the effects of training TAs to support students’ studying, and not only progress with assignments, during CS1. The TAs were educated regarding the struggles typically faced by CS1 students and how to approach them. During the course, students participated in periodic one-on-one supervision sessions with TAs, where they could privately discuss studying and seek solutions to learning problems. Students were frequently asked to write reflections about their progress in a virtual learning environment for TAs to view. Participated students were invited for personal one-on-one interviews after the course to evaluate the TA support. Altogether 14 students were interviewed. During the interviews, we noticed that students’ perception of the CS1 course and the one-to-one supervision sessions was clearly coupled with influences arising from students’ personal histories and experiences – and not from the study arrangement. As such, we repositioned our research from merely evaluating the offered one-to-one sessions to illuminating self-regulation and help-seeking more broadly in CS1 context. We performed a qualitative analysis seeking to answer the question of how self-regulatory processes and use of supervision emerged during CS1 . We conjectured that this goal usefully complements the studies focusing on TAs role and their training, such as one by Pon-Barry et al. 2017 . The study follows an inductive approach in which the resultant thematization provides the answer to the set question. 2. Research background We refer to two theoretical frameworks: SRL, which scoped the inductive study, and transformative learning, which appeared to emerge in our results and is hence addressed. SRL refers to a student’s ability to approach learning by setting goals and proactively working towards them while monitoring their progress and adjusting their learning methods as necessary ( Schunk 2005 ) . In SRL, students set goals, use various learning resources and learning strategies, monitor their progress, and reflect on their performance and outcomes to refine their future learning actions ( Zimmerman 2008 ) . Self-regulation manifests in learning by a student regulating various cognitive aspects, such as motivation, self-efficacy beliefs, behavior, use of time, and the learning context ( Pintrich 2000 , e.g.,) . Self-regulation skills are closely linked to metacognition and self-efficacy, which are actively researched in CS education ( Steinhorst et al. 2020 ; Prather et al. 2020 ) . We identify at least four perspectives of SRL in computing education research: students’ approach to studying, problem-solving process, specific SRL aspects such as help-seeking, and SRL interventions. The study by Falkner et al. ( Falkner et al. 2014 ) exemplifies the first two aspects, identifying various SRL strategies used by CS students. The results included general planning and time management strategies, visualization, problem decomposition, and knowledge building via practice. Loksa and Ko 2016 primarily focused on the process of SRL when solving programming problems and noticed that SRL strategies proved more successful when a student had sufficient programming knowledge for the task. The help-seeking perspective is present in the study by Doebling and Kazerouni 2021 , who surveyed CS students about their approaches and found that CS students most often seek help from online and peers before