Deflating Deflationism: A Critical Perspective on Debunking Arguments Against LLM Mentality

Alex Grzankowski, Geoff Keeling, Henry Shevlin, Winnie Street · 2025

Read Deflating Deflationism: A Critical Perspective on Debunking Arguments Against LLM Mentality by Alex Grzankowski, Geoff Keeling, Henry Shevlin, Winnie Street (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-13403.txt.

Introduction

Grzankowski, Keeling, Shevlin, and Street examine arguments against treating large language models as minded. Many people naturally describe these systems as if they had beliefs and desires. So-called deflationists say all such talk is misplaced and warn it can breed misplaced trust. The authors focus on two common deflationist arguments. One says the systems' humanlike behavior is not robust, since it fails to generalize as real thinking would. The other attacks the simple causal stories people give for the behavior and offers deflating alternatives.

The authors find both arguments powerful against strong claims, yet neither rules out every mental attribution. They defend a modest middle view: ordinary practice can justify speaking of knowledge, beliefs, and desires in these systems, since those notions are not metaphysically heavy. Far more caution is needed, they say, for claims about inner experience such as consciousness.

Catalog record

CREATORAlex Grzankowski, Geoff Keeling, Henry Shevlin, Winnie Street
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-13403

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Deflating Deflationism: A Critical Perspective on Debunking Arguments Against LLM Mentality Alex Grzankowski, Geoff Keeling, Henry Shevlin, Winnie Street Abstract Many people feel compelled to interpret, describe, and respond to Large Language Models (LLMs) as if they possess inner mental lives similar to our own. Responses to this phenomenon have varied. Inflationists hold that at least some folk psychological ascriptions to LLMs are warranted. Deflationists argue that all such attributions of mentality to LLMs are misplaced, often cautioning against the risk that anthropomorphic projection may lead to misplaced trust or potentially even confusion about the moral status of LLMs. We advance this debate by assessing two common deflationary arguments against LLM mentality. What we term the robustness strategy aims to undercut one justification for believing that LLMs are minded entities by showing that putatively cognitive and humanlike behaviours are not robust, failing to generalise appropriately. What we term the etiological strategy undercuts attributions of mentality by challenging naive causal explanations of LLM behaviours, offering alternative causal accounts that weaken the case for mental state attributions. While both strategies offer powerful challenges to full-blown inflationism, we find that neither strategy provides a knock-down case against ascriptions of mentality to LLMs simpliciter . With this in mind, we explore a modest form of inflationism that permits ascriptions of mentality to LLMs under certain conditions. Specifically, we argue that folk practice provides a defeasible basis for attributing mental states and capacities to LLMs provided those mental states and capacities can be understood in metaphysically undemanding terms (e.g. knowledge, beliefs and desires), while greater caution is required when attributing metaphysically demanding mental phenomena such as phenomenal consciousness. 1 Introduction It is hard to shake the thought that Large Language Models (LLMs) have minds. When interacting with LLM-based dialogue agents like ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini, many users ask these systems for advice, joke with them, and confide in them. Some even fall in love. Accordingly, users often find themselves speaking to LLMs as if these systems have thoughts, desires, or points of view. Is the attribution of mentality to LLMs a mistake---an anthropomorphic glitch in our social cognition? Or could it be reasonable to treat LLMs as minded? 1 1 1 Colombatto and Fleming 2024 , Ibrahim et al. 2025 and Scott et al. 2023 provide empirical assessments of user perceptions of mentality in LLMs. For ethical discussions of anthropomorphism in relation to LLMs see Weidinger et al. 2021 , Gabriel et al. 2024 , Shevlin 2021 , Manzini et al. 2024a , Manzini et al. 2024b , Akbulut et al. 2024 and Reinecke et al. 2025 . For further discussion see Guingrich and Graziano 2023 . The question of whether and when it is appropriate to ascribe mentality to LLMs has become a central flashpoint in the societal conversation on AI. While some researchers are engaged in exploratory work evaluating models for mental phenomena such as preferences, beliefs, and pleasure and pain states ( Anthropic 2025 , Scherrer et al. 2023 , Keeling et al. 2024 ) , others remain deeply sceptical ( Li and Etchemendy 2024 , Bender et al. 2021 ) . We here distinguish two sets of views about LLM mentality which we term inflationism and deflationism . Inflationism holds that at least some attributions of mentality to LLMs are accurate or appropriate, while deflationism denies this. 2 2 2 Palminteri and Pistilli 2025 also use the term ‘inflationism.’ According to them, ‘[t]he inflationary stance consists of easily attributing higher-order cognition to LLMs, often extrapolating from their linguistic fluency to claims about Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) or even artificial consciousness’ (see also Maclure 2020 , Maclure 2020 ). Our usage of the term ‘inflationism’ is broader than theirs in that inflationism as we understand it encompasses any ascriptions of mentality to LLMs—not merely ascriptions of higher-order cognition and consciousness. In framing the debate in these terms, we aim to draw a broad heuristic distinction, rather than a strict conceptual demarcation: in practice, commentators are often not inflationist or deflationist tout court , but instead focus their arguments on some particular mental capacity or class of mental states. 3 3 3 Cappelen and Dever 2025 are an exception. Their book manuscript Going the Whole Hog: A Philosophical Defense of AI Cognition provides a broad defence of inflationism, although the form of inflationism that they defend is neutral on the issue of consciousness. For example, Bender and Koller 2020 defend deflationism with respect to semantic understanding ( Bender et al. 2021 , c.f.) , and Søgaard 2023 defends the corresponding inflationist view. We aim to step back from these debates and take a broader methodological perspective, examining two general deflationist strategies for debunking mental state attributions to LLMs: the robustness strategy , which challenges mental states attributions on a broadly functional basis, emphasising failures of generalisation; and the etiological strategy , which appeals to the causal history of LLMs to undermine the case for interpreting their behaviour in mentalistic terms. We argue that both strategies fall short of decisively undermining inflationism, with a recurring problem being that they beg the question against inflationist alternatives. Once these debunking arguments are defused, a modest form of inflationism emerges as not only defensible but perhaps even the natural starting point in interpreting the behaviour of LLMs. In defending modest inflationism, our aim is not to claim that LLMs have rich mental lives, or that their internal workings closely resemble those of human minds. Rather, we suggest that some amount of mentalising is sometimes justified. In particular, where the mental states or capabilities at issue can be understood in metaphysically undemanding terms (as has been argued for the case of beliefs and desires), in contrast to more metaphysically demanding states such as phenomenally conscious experiences. Accordingly, the modest inflationism that we endorse registers that ascribing mentality to LLMs need not entail ascribing mental states and capacities which are equivalent to those of humans—in much the same way that ascriptions of beliefs, desires and intentions to non-human animals need not presuppose that their realisations of those mental states are exactly equivalent to ours. We note also that in what follows, our primary focus will be specifically on LLM-based dialogue agents such as ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini ( Shanahan 2024b ) . While much of what we say will generalise to debunking arguments as applied to AI systems in general, we believe it is useful to have a specific target in mind, not least because the sheer variety of actual and possible AI systems (including neuromorphic architectures or even systems with biological components) introduces nuance and complexity beyond the scope of this paper. The paper proceeds as follows. In Section 2, we lay out a basic plausibility case for mentalising LLMs. Sections 3 and 4 critically examine the robustness and etiological strategies as deflationary attempts to debunk this plausibility. In Section 5, we revisit the inflationism/deflationism debate in light of these arguments, and sketch a moderate, tractable form of inflationism that countenances attributions of mentality to LLMs provided the relevant attributions are in a relevant way metaphysically undemanding. The upshot is that the case for mentalising AI may be stronger than often assumed. 2 Ascribe Mentality, Absent Defeaters LLMs

Read the complete text