Fortified Proximal Causal Inference with Many Invalid Proxies
Myeonghun Yu, Xu Shi, Eric J. Tchetgen Tchetgen · 2025
Read Fortified Proximal Causal Inference with Many Invalid Proxies by Myeonghun Yu, Xu Shi, Eric J. Tchetgen Tchetgen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-13152.txt.
Introduction
Myeonghun Yu, Xu Shi, and Eric Tchetgen Tchetgen wrote this statistics paper, published in 2025. It works on a hard problem in causal inference: judging a treatment's effect from observed data when hidden factors may distort the picture. A second problem is that the stand-in measures on hand may not all be trustworthy.
A method called proximal causal inference uses pairs of proxy measures to work around hidden bias, but it usually assumes every proxy is valid. That assumption often fails and cannot be checked. The authors build a version that tolerates bad proxies, as long as the analyst states how many of the candidates are good, without knowing which ones. They prove the average treatment effect can still be pinned down. They also design estimators that stay sound even if parts of the model are off. Tests include data on heart catheter care for very ill patients.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Myeonghun Yu, Xu Shi, Eric J. Tchetgen Tchetgen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 108 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-13152
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Fortified Proximal Causal Inference with Many Invalid Proxies Myeonghun Yu, Xu Shi, Eric J. Tchetgen Tchetgen Abstract Causal inference from observational data often relies on the assumption of no unmeasured confounding, an assumption frequently violated in practice due to unobserved or poorly measured covariates. Proximal causal inference (PCI) offers a promising framework for addressing unmeasured confounding using a pair of outcome and treatment confounding proxies. However, existing PCI methods typically assume all specified proxies are valid, which may be unrealistic and is untestable without extra assumptions. In this paper, we develop a semiparametric approach for a many-proxy PCI setting that accommodates potentially invalid treatment confounding proxies. We introduce a new class of fortified confounding bridge functions and establish nonparametric identification of the population average treatment effect (ATE) under the assumption that at least γ \gamma out of K K candidate treatment confounding proxies are valid, for any γ ≤ K \gamma\leq K set by the analyst without requiring knowledge of which proxies are valid. We establish a local semiparametric efficiency bound and develop a class of multiply robust, locally efficient estimators for the ATE. These estimators are thus simultaneously robust to invalid treatment confounding proxies and model misspecification of nuisance parameters. The proposed methods are evaluated through simulation and applied to assess the effect of right heart catheterization in critically ill patients. Keywords: Causal inference, Invalid proxies, Semiparametric inference, Unmeasured confounding 1 Introduction The assumption of no unmeasured confounding is a common assumption of causal inference in observational studies, which requires that all confounders are measured accurately and accounted for in the analysis. However, this assumption is often violated in practice, as some confounders may be unobserved or imperfectly measured. Violations of this assumption can lead to biased estimates and invalid inference about causal effects. To address this challenge, a variety of methods have been developed over the years, including recent approaches that leverage so-called proxy variables which have drawn growing interest ( Miao et al. 2018 ; Shi et al. 2020b ; Tchetgen Tchetgen et al. 2024 ; Cui et al. 2024 ) . Proximal causal inference (PCI) provides a formal framework that uses proxy variables to identify and estimate causal effects despite the presence of unmeasured confounding. In addition to having potentially measured a subset of relevant confounders, it relies on having also measured two types of proxy variables: (1) treatment confounding proxies; and (2) outcome confounding proxies. Treatment confounding proxies must be associated with the outcome only through a shared unmeasured confounder with the treatment, while outcome confounding proxies must be associated with the treatment only through a shared unmeasured confounder with the outcome. We refer readers to Section 2.1 for formal definitions. Prominent examples of proxies of types (1) and (2) are so-called negative control exposures and negative control outcomes, respectively. Importantly, both types of proxies should share the same unmeasured confounding structure as the primary treatment and outcome of interest. However, the assumption that proxy variables are valid, in the sense of satisfying either (1) or (2), is not empirically testable without additional assumptions. Assessments of proxy validity often rely on domain knowledge ( Lipsitch et al. 2010 ; Shi et al. 2020b ) , which may be subjective and potentially unreliable. Existing data-driven validity tests rely on stringent structural equation models, and are limited to validating one particular type of proxies, known as disconnected proxies ( Kummerfeld et al. 2024 ) . In practice, identifying valid outcome confounding proxies may be more straightforward than selecting valid treatment confounding proxies. For example, pre-treatment outcome measures are widely used as outcome confounding proxies since they cannot be causally affected by the treatment. A case in point is Jackson et al. 2006 , who used pre-season influenza hospitalizations as an outcome confounding proxy to detect residual confounding bias in evaluating the effect of vaccination among the elderly. More broadly, the widely popular difference-in-differences methodology uses pre-treatment outcome measurements as valid outcome confounding proxies to debias causal effect estimates ( Sofer et al. 2016 ) . In contrast, identifying valid treatment confounding proxies may be considerably more challenging in practice. The presence of invalid proxies can result in biased estimation and misleading inference, yet existing PCI literature offers limited methodological tools for dealing with this problem. In this paper, assuming that valid outcome confounding proxies are available, we develop a semiparametric framework for PCI about the population average treatment effect (ATE) that accommodates possibly invalid treatment confounding proxies. After introducing a new class of fortified confounding bridge functions ( Miao et al. 2018 ) , we establish nonparametric identification of the ATE under the assumption that at least \gamma out of K candidate treatment confounding proxies are valid, for 1\leq\gamma\leq K a priori set by the analyst, without necessarily knowing their identity. As such, our proposed approach does not rely on the stringent assumption common in the proximal literature that all specified proxies are valid, providing identifiability conditions as long as \gamma is a valid lower bound for the actual number of valid treatment confounding proxies. Beyond identification, we also consider estimation and inference in the proposed framework, and we characterize a locally semiparametric efficiency bound for the ATE under our proposed model and derive a rich class of multiply robust, locally efficient estimators. These estimators remain consistent if one of several working models is correctly specified, and attain the semiparametric efficiency bound in the union model when all working models are correctly specified. Notably, our method avoids an explicit model selection step, that is, it does not attempt to identify which proxies are invalid. However, as the true number of valid proxies may not be available, the analyst can probe the robustness of empirical results by evaluating whether estimated causal effects remain stable across different values of \gamma over a certain range in a form of sensitivity analysis, given that the identified parameter should be constant provided that \gamma is a valid lower bound for the underlying true number of valid proxies. A similar strategy may be adopted when many outcome confounding proxies are available, to evaluate whether some are invalid, by repeating the analysis and assessing the sensitivity of results across different subsets of outcome confounding proxies. The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 reviews existing identification results for the ATE under the assumption that the given outcome and treatment confounding proxies are valid ( Miao et al. 2018 ; Cui et al. 2024 ) , and then introduces our nonparametric identification strategy that allows for some invalid treatment confounding proxies, without requiring knowledge of which ones are valid, ex-ante. In Section 3 , we develop semiparametric theory for PCI under this framework and construct corresponding multiply robust, locally efficient estimators. Section 4 presents simulation studies, and Section 5 illustrates a real data application evaluating the effectiveness of right heart catheterization in critically ill patients admitted to the intensive care unit. Additional discussion and all technical proofs are provided in the Supplementary Material. Notation . For any random variable V , let L_{2}(V) be the space of square-integrable functions of V with the L_{2} -norm \|\cdot\|_{2} . For any finite set A , we denote its cardinality by |A| and define \mathcal{P}_{t}(A)=\{\nu\subseteq