Limiting distributions of ratios of Binomial random variables
Adriel Barretto a and Zachary Lubberts · 2025
Read Limiting distributions of ratios of Binomial random variables by Adriel Barretto a and Zachary Lubberts (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-13071.txt.
Introduction
Adriel Barretto and Zachary Lubberts present a 2025 mathematics paper on ratios of binomial counts. Take two independent binomial variables with the same success chance but different trial counts. Raise one to a power and divide by a power of their sum; what distribution does that ratio settle into as trials grow?
Under several settings, the authors prove the ratio converges to a normal distribution, with mean and variance they compute. Binomial counts model coin flips, survey answers, and defect tallies, so ratio limits guide approximations in practice. Simulations confirm the theory across the settings studied. The work adds a clean limit law to the toolkit for proportions built from two samples.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Adriel Barretto a and Zachary Lubberts |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 16 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-13071
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Limiting distributions of ratios of Binomial random variables Adriel Barretto a and Zachary Lubberts Abstract We consider the limiting distribution of the quantity X s / ( X + Y ) r X^{s}/(X+Y)^{r} , where X X and Y Y are two independent Binomial random variables with a common success probability and a number of trials n n and m m , respectively, and r , s r,s are positive real numbers. Under several settings, we prove that this converges to a Normal distribution with a given mean and variance, and demonstrate these theoretical results through simulations. 1 Introduction As part of the analysis in lubberts2025 , the authors consider the quantity \frac{X}{\sqrt{X+Y}}, where X\sim\mathrm{Binomial}(n,p), Y\sim\mathrm{Binomial}(m,p) , and X,Y are independent of one another. The setting of interest in that paper occurs when m has order comparable to n^{2} , so that the quantity in the denominator is typically of a similar order to the one in the numerator, and in this case, it was shown that for large values of n , this ratio has a limiting Normal distribution with mean \sqrt{p} and variance (1-p)/n . While it is well-known that given the value of X+Y , for some random variables X and Y as above, the value of X is a Hypergeometric random variable, the literature is less forthcoming about the distribution of such ratios of a pair of Binomial random variables. In the present work, we extend the previous results to the case where the function takes the form R=\frac{X^{s}}{(X+Y)^{r}}, for r,s>0 . We will show that under several parameter regimes, R has a limiting Normal distribution. We verify these results through simulations, showing the effects of varying each of the parameters on the observed distribution. 2 Limiting Distribution We may approximate the function defining our ratio of interest using the Taylor approximation: f(x,y)=\frac{x^{s}}{(x+y)^{r}}=\frac{(np)^{s}}{(np+mp)^{r}}+\nabla f(np,mp)^{T}\begin{bmatrix}x-np\\ y-mp\end{bmatrix}+Q(x,y), (1) where the quadratic remainder term takes the form Q(x,y)=\frac{1}{2}\begin{bmatrix}x-np&y-mp\end{bmatrix}\nabla^{2}f(\xi,\eta)\begin{bmatrix}x-np\\ y-mp\end{bmatrix}, for some point (\xi,\eta) on the line segment connecting (np,mp) with (x,y) . If we substitute the random variables X and Y into this expression, the linear term in Equation ( 1 ) already looks quite Normal in distribution once n and m are large, since X,Y are independent Binomial random variables. However, in order to show that the limiting distribution of R looks like the linear terms in this equation, we must bound the remainder term. We will make use of the following result from chung2000course : Lemma 1 . Let X_{n}\rightarrow X in distribution, and Y_{n}\rightarrow 0 in probability. Then X_{n}+Y_{n}\rightarrow X in distribution. We will show that after appropriate scaling, the quadratic remainder term converges to 0 in probability, so the two linear terms determine the limiting distribution of R . For any quadratic form x^{T}Ax , applying the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality and monotonicity property of the spectral norm, we have x^{T}Ax=\langle Ax,x\rangle\leq\|Ax\|\|x\|\leq\|A\|\|x\|^{2}, so in order to control Q, we must find an upper bound for \|\nabla^{2}f(x,y)\|_{2} . Note that a Hessian matrix must be symmetric, so its singular values are simply the absolute values of its eigenvalues. The Gerschgorin disk theorem horn2012matrix tells us that any eigenvalue of a matrix must belong to the union of its Gerschgorin disks, so no eigenvalue of a matrix A can be larger than \max_{i}\sum_{j=1}^{n}|A_{ij}|\leq\sum_{i,j=1}^{n}|A_{ij}|. In the present case, the Hessian is given by \nabla^{2}f(x,y)=\frac{x^{s-2}}{(x+y)^{r+2}}\begin{bmatrix}s(s-1)(x+y)^{2}-2rsx(x+y)+r(r+1)x^{2}&r(r+1)x^{2}-rsx(x+y)\\ r(r+1)x^{2}-rsx(x+y)&r(r+1)x^{2}\end{bmatrix}. Utilizing the Gerschgorin bound just stated, we have \displaystyle\|\nabla^{2}f(x,y)\|_{2} \displaystyle\leq\frac{x^{s-2}}{(x+y)^{r+2}}\left[|s(s-1)(x+y)^{2}-2rsx(x+y)+r(r+1)x^{2}|\right. \displaystyle\quad\left.+2|r(r+1)x^{2}-rsx(x+y)|+r(r+1)x^{2}\right]. (2) Now since X,Y are Binomial random variables, we know that with overwhelming probability, |X-np|\leq\sqrt{n\log(n)p(1-p)} , and |Y-mp|\leq\sqrt{m\log(m)p(1-p)} ; let us call this event \mathcal{A} . More precisely, the probability that |X-np|>C\sqrt{n\log(n)} decays faster than Cn^{-2} , and similarly for Y . So to bound the residual term, we see that the event \{|Q(X,Y)|>\epsilon\}\subseteq\{|Q(X,Y)|>\epsilon\}\cup\{|X-np|>C\sqrt{n\log n}\}\cup\{|Y-mp|>C\sqrt{m\log m}\}, and thus \displaystyle\mathbb{P}[|Q(X,Y)|>\epsilon] \displaystyle\leq\mathbb{P}[(|Q(X,Y)|>\epsilon)\cap(|X-np|\leq C\sqrt{n\log n})\cap(|Y-mp|\leq C\sqrt{m\log m})] \displaystyle\quad+Cn^{-2}+Cm^{-2}. Consider x=np+r_{x} , where |r_{x}|\leq C\sqrt{n\log(n)} , and y=mp+r_{y} , where |r_{y}|\leq C\sqrt{m\log(m)} . Then the right hand side of inequality ( 2 ) may be bounded by \frac{Cn^{s-2}\max\{s(n+m),rn\}^{2}}{(n+m)^{r+2}}. We also have the inequality \displaystyle\left\|\begin{bmatrix}x-np\\ y-mp\end{bmatrix}\right\|^{2} \displaystyle=r_{x}^{2}+r_{y}^{2}\leq Cn\log(n)+Cm\log(m), so on the event \mathcal{A} , we get that \displaystyle|Q(X,Y)| \displaystyle\leq\frac{Cn^{s-2}\max\{s(n+m),rn\}^{2}}{(n+m)^{r+2}}(n\log(n)+m\log(m)) \displaystyle\leq\frac{Cn^{s-2}\log(n+m)}{(n+m)^{r-1}}, (3) since s,r are constants. The exact behavior of this quantity depends on the ratio m/n , but in light of Lemma 1 , in order to obtain the distributional convergence results, we must simply show that the final quantity in ( 3 ) still goes to zero after appropriate scaling, for any of the cases we wish to consider. To find the limiting distribution of R=f(X,Y) , we re-arrange Equation ( 1 ) after evaluating at (X,Y) (and neglecting the remainder term for the time being): \displaystyle R-\frac{(np)^{s}}{((n+m)p)^{r}} \displaystyle\approx\nabla f(np,mp)^{T}\begin{bmatrix}X-np\\ Y-mp\end{bmatrix} \displaystyle=\frac{(np)^{s}}{((n+m)p)^{r+1}}\begin{bmatrix}\left(\frac{s(n+m)}{n}-r\right)\sqrt{np(1-p)}&-r\sqrt{mp(1-p)}\end{bmatrix}\begin{bmatrix}\frac{X-np}{\sqrt{np(1-p)}}\\ \frac{Y-mp}{\sqrt{mp(1-p)}}\end{bmatrix}. The last vector will converge to a Normal vector (Z_{X},Z_{Y}) as n,m\rightarrow\infty , but an appropriate scaling is required so that neither of the coefficients of Z_{X},Z_{Y} diverge as n,m\rightarrow\infty , and it is not the case that both of them vanish (since in that case, the limiting distribution is simply point mass at 0). The choice of scaling will again depend on the ratio m/n , but now we have all of the ingredients in place to prove the following theorem: Theorem 1 . Let r,s>0 , p\in(0,1) be constants. Let X\sim\mathrm{Binomial}(n,p) , and let Y\sim\mathrm{Binomial}(m,p) be independent of X . Define R=\frac{X^{r}}{(X+Y)^{s}}. Then as n,m\rightarrow\infty , we have the following convergences in distribution: (i) If m/n\rightarrow\infty , m\log(m)n^{-3/2}\rightarrow 0 , then \frac{m^{r}}{n^{s-1/2}}\left(R-\frac{n^{s}}{(n+m)^{r}}p^{s-r}\right)\rightarrow\mathcal{N}\left(0,p^{2(s-r)-1}(1-p)s^{2}\right). (ii) If m/n\rightarrow\alpha\in(0,+\infty) , then n^{r-s+1/2}\left(R-\frac{n^{s}}{(n+m)^{r}}p^{s-r}\right)\rightarrow\mathcal{N}\left(0,p^{2(s-r)-1}(1-p)\frac{[(s(1+\alpha)-r)^{2}+\alpha r^{2}]}{(1+\alpha)^{2(r+1)}}\right). (iii) If m/n\rightarrow 0 , then n^{r-s+1/2}\left(R-\frac{n^{s}}{(n+m)^{r}}p^{s-r}\right)\rightarrow\mathcal{N}\left(0,p^{2(s-r)-1}(1-p)(s-r)^{2}\right). Proof. It remains to be shown that in the three cases described above, the bound in ( 3 ) still goes to zero after multiplication by the appropriate scaling factor as n,m\rightarrow\infty . (i) When m/n\rightarrow\infty , m\log(m)n^{-3/2}\rightarrow 0 , then C\frac{n^{s-2}\log(n+m)}{(n+m)^{r-1}}\frac{m^{r}}{n^{s-1/2}}\sim\frac{m\log(m)}{n^{3/2}}\rightarrow 0. (ii) When m/n\rightarrow\alpha , then C\frac{n^{s-2}\log(n+m)}{(n+m)^{r-1}}n^{r-s+1/2}\sim\frac{\log(n)}{\sqrt{n}}\rightarrow 0. (iii) When m/n\rightarrow 0 , then C\frac{n^{s-2}\log(n+m)}{(n+m)^{r-1}}n^{r-s+1/2}\sim\frac{\log(n)}{\sqrt{n}}\rightarrow 0. ∎ 3 Simulation We verify our limiting distribution results for different values of the parameters n,m,p,r , and s . For each set of parameter values we tested, we generate 100,000 points (X_{i},Y_{i}) , where X_{i}\sim\mathrm{Binomial}(n,p) , Y_{i}\sim\mathrm{Binomial}(m,p) , and X_{i},Y_{i} are independent. We then compute \frac{X_{i}^{s}}{(X_{i}+Y_{i})^{r}} , and center and scale according to Theorem 1 , obtaining R_{i} . We compare this sample with a sample of 100,000 values Z_{j} drawn from the Normal distribution with mean 0 and the appropriate variance. To measure the accuracy between the distributions of R and Z , we use the discrete KL divergence: We divide the values in \{R_{i}\},\{Z_{j}\} into 100 bins x\in\mathbb{X} , then set A(x) to be the observed proportion of R_{i}\in x and B(x) to be the observed proportion of Z_{j}\in x . We compare the two distributions with the formula D_{KL}(A||B)=\sum_{x\in\mathbb{X}}A(x)[\log(A(x))-\log(B(x))]. (4) When \frac{m}{n}\rightarrow\infty , it can happen that all of the observations fall into a single bin, so in this case we use the reversed formula to get a meaningful comparison of the distributions: D_{KL}(B||A)=\sum_{x\in\mathbb{X}}B(x)[\log(B(x))-\log(A(x))]. (5) We test the distributions in each of the settings of Theorem 1 , as well as the case where m/n\rightarrow\infty , but m\log(m)/n^{3/2}\not\rightarrow 0 . Whenever we fix the value of r or s , it is set equal to 15 (except in Section 3.4 , for reasons that we