Style-based Composer Identification and Attribution of Symbolic Music Scores: a Systematic Survey
Federico Simonetta · 2025
Read Style-based Composer Identification and Attribution of Symbolic Music Scores: a Systematic Survey by Federico Simonetta (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-12440.txt.
Introduction
Federico Simonetta surveys computer work on naming the composer of a music score in a 2025 paper. Such tools judge authorship from style alone, using the notes on the page rather than sound. Claims in this field can sway real disputes over who wrote a work.
The survey covers 58 papers across many eras and terms. Much of the work rests on weak checks and plain accuracy scores that mislead on skewed data sets. Simonetta stresses balanced scores and strict cross checks for trust. Real cases tied to Bach, Josquin, and Lennon and McCartney show both the power and the traps of the method. Guidelines for future work close the survey.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Federico Simonetta |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 75 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-12440
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Style-based Composer Identification and Attribution of Symbolic Music Scores: a Systematic Survey Federico Simonetta Abstract This paper presents the first comprehensive systematic review of literature on style-based composer identification and authorship attribution in symbolic music scores. Addressing the critical need for improved reliability and reproducibility in this field, the review rigorously analyzes 58 peer-reviewed papers published across various historical periods, with the search adapted to evolving terminology. The analysis critically assesses prevailing repertoires, computational approaches, and evaluation methodologies, highlighting significant challenges. It reveals that a substantial portion of existing research suffers from inadequate validation protocols and an over-reliance on simple accuracy metrics for often imbalanced datasets, which can undermine the credibility of attribution claims. The crucial role of robust metrics like Balanced Accuracy and rigorous cross-validation in ensuring trustworthy results is emphasized. The survey also details diverse feature representations and the evolution of machine learning models employed. Notable real-world authorship attribution cases, such as those involving works attributed to Bach, Josquin Desprez, and Lennon-McCartney, are specifically discussed, illustrating the opportunities and pitfalls of applying computational techniques to resolve disputed musical provenance. Based on these insights, a set of actionable guidelines for future research are proposed. These recommendations are designed to significantly enhance the reliability, reproducibility, and musicological validity of composer identification and authorship attribution studies, fostering more robust and interpretable computational stylistic analysis. OVERVIEW ARTICLE Keywords: Composer identification, Composer classification, Authorship attribution, Symbolic music scores, Music information processing 1. Introduction The ILLIAC system by Hiller and Isaacson (1955-1956) was one of the first applications of information technology in music ( Hiller and Isaacson, 1958 ) . Around the same time, Youngblood published the first statistical analysis of compositional styles ( Youngblood, 1958 ) . The field of computational stylistic analysis has since evolved, encompassing diverse literatures and overlapping with tasks like genre recognition and algorithmic composition. Youngblood’s work highlights the longstanding significance of this topic in music computing, with important applications in musicology and database labeling ( van Nuss et al., 2017 ) . In this work, computational methods applied to symbolic scores are considered in the attempt to systematically analyze the literature about composer identification. The task of identifying the composer of a musical composition based on its symbolic score has been explored from various research perspectives. Computer scientists and statisticians refer to it as “composer identification” or “composer classification,” while musicologists and historians call it “authorship attribution.” Despite differing aims, the typical scenario remains the same: given a set of music scores, develop an algorithm to predict the composer of a new score. The synthesis of the surveyed literature reveals several distinct research perspectives from which the composer identification task is approached. One reason why scientists approach the composer identification task is to assess the ability of a model to capture the stylistic characteristics of a composer. In this case, composer identification is often associated with genre recognition and style or epoch classification. Another application is the labeling of large databases, often mined from the web, that present a large number of music documents but with noisy or erroneous metadata. In this latter case, the task of composer identification is associated to generic document tagging. In other works, the task is presented as a benchmark for comparing different feature extractors or architecture. When one of these scenario occurs, the main focus is usually on the computational methods, with the final task hidden behind generic nomenclature such as “music tagging” or “music classification”. The aim of authorship attribution is instead to infer the author of a piece of music, given a set of possible authors. This task is often associated with the re-attribution of works whose authorship is uncertain or disputed. A more in-depth discussion of what is authorship attribution is in Section 2 . From a machine learning perspective, the authorship attribution problem may be regarded as a particular case of the composer identification task. In this work, the existing literature about composer identification from symbolic music scores is critically reviewed, providing details of the methodology and criteria adopted during the analyses. Specifically, three main research questions motivated the study: 1. What computational approaches have been developed and applied to composer identification of symbolic music scores? 2. To what extent can music composer identification methods based on compositional style be considered reliable for authorship attribution? 3. How can the research community improve the reliability and reproducibility of music authorship attribution studies? Many studies treat “composer identification” as a machine‐learning benchmark – exploiting gross stylistic differences (e.g., Baroque vs. Romantic) to compare feature extractors or architectures – without any claim to musicological authorship attribution. By contrast, the primary focus is on those works whose aim is to support musicological re-attribution of disputed or anonymous pieces, relying on subtle, individual stylistic traits rather than broad period or genre cues. Nonetheless, the two tasks are closely related, and the distinction is not always clear-cut. While I have attempted to navigate this distinction throughout the analysis, it is often challenging to definitively categorize studies; many works, even when framing composer identification primarily as a benchmarking task, present findings or interpretations that could be perceived as having musicological relevance or broader implications for understanding style, making a rigid separation problematic. Moreover, “composer identification” models may still be used for “authorship attribution” and their study is valid for having a better understanding of the literature and try to answer the research questions. My critique throughout this survey, therefore, evaluates the reliability and applicability of methods primarily through this lens of musicological authorship attribution. While a systematic approach that enforces an objective view on the existing literature was adopted, the heterogeneity of the applications and of the nomenclature used in literature made the effort of collecting existing works particularly difficult. Nonetheless, the first comprehensive analysis of the field is provided, achieving a greater understanding of the possibilities that computational techniques open for the re-attribution of existing works. In Section 2 , the concept of authorship attribution and its similarities and differences with the more general task of composer identification are discussed. In Section 3 , the systematic collection of papers is described. In Section 4 , the evaluation methodologies adopted in the literature are reviewed and a classification among reliable and unreliable protocols is defined. In Sections 5 , 6 , and 7 the repertoires, models, features, and file formats used in the literature are summarized. In Section 8 , the existing problems of authorship attribution approached with computational style analysis are analyzed. Finally, in Section 9 , the literature is numerically analyzed and guidelines are drawn for future research in the composer identification task. 2. Defining authorship attribution in MIR According to Juola, 2007 , authorship attribution can be defined as “any attempt to infer the characteristics of the creator of a piece of [linguistic] data” . In this context, “characteristics of the creator” refer to the stylistic and, in the original linguistic domain, textual patterns manifest in their work, which can be used for tasks such as identifying the author (attribution) or inferring other authorial traits (profiling). The problem is usually presented in one of three possible forms: 1. In the closed-set problem, the author is known to be one of a finite